Race: Personal Educational Experiences And Reflection Race Dissertation Or Thesis Complete

Length: 5 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Race Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete Paper: #22986816 Related Topics: Personal Narrative, Reflection, Self Reflection, Personal Reflection
Excerpt from Dissertation or Thesis complete :

Race: Personal Educational Experiences and Reflection

Race was seldom discussed explicitly during my early, grammar school education. When the topic of race was broached, it was usually in the context of a lesson on the Civil War or Civil Rights movement. Although such discussions were valuable, they gave the impression that race was something located in America's past, rather than worthy of discussion in the present. However, this did not mean that I was not cognizant of race as a child. I was, but the topic was often unspoken of in school, except on the rare occasions when teachers brought it to the forefront of the attention of the class -- usually in a manner that suggested that the struggle for freedom had been won.

I was fortunate to have parents who always stressed that all people were equal, regardless of how they looked. While they did not give me a multicultural education in a formal sense, they did stress that regardless of color, religion, or disability, I should judge people based upon the content of their character. When I played with children of races other than my own, I never recall being censored.

By the time I was in middle school I began to notice the phenomenon of seeing all of the black -- and Hispanic, East Asian, etcetera -- kids sitting together in the cafeteria as described by Beverly Daniel Tatum. Reading Tatum allowed me to view this in a more understanding and positive fashion. It is very easy to feel excluded when a group of other people self-segregates. I recall one of my best friends in junior high, who was Hispanic. Although the two of us frequently 'hung out' together after school and were close friends during the summer, she would usually sit with other members of her own racial and ethnic group during lunchtime. It was hard not to feel offended by such behavior, with my sensitive teenage ego. With the eye of an educator, I have come to understand the need for identity formation for groups different than my own as well as my need to feel included with my friends, regardless of race.

Although race was more noticeable in my social world as I grew older, it was not necessarily discussed in school more than it was when I was a child, other than as a subject of history. One or two of my teachers did include units that discussed race in a more present-day and positive fashion. I remember in one class, we were all given labels to wear on our heads that we could not see, and then, at the end of class, after doing a series of exercises in which we were treated as the person on the label, were told to take off the labels and read them. This was an illustration of how we often forget about how powerful stereotypes can be, although an individual is far more complex than any self-enclosed category.

Another teacher asked us to write down a series of categories and to write down the stereotypes we held about those groups. This forced us to engage in intense self-scrutiny regarding out belief systems and to honestly admit the prejudices that we had. Rather than looking back and commenting upon the racism of others, we were forced to confront our own blindness. It was difficult to talk about some of the categories to which people belonged and also eye-opening as to how many people from different parts of the world we did not know -- for example, none of us had ever met a Native American.

I have come to believe that a good teacher must enable students to see how race impacts their perspective, and not see their racial identity as separate from themselves and their society. This can be difficult and discomforting in a diverse classroom, because some students may feel uncomfortable talking about race with their multi-ethnic friends. Anger during such debates is perhaps inevitable. But it is better to have anger and divisiveness in the safe space of the classroom than elsewhere -- such as in the hallways, where it can spill over into


Teachers can help break down barriers when students are unwilling. Teenager's egos are often fragile, and even when adolescents want to befriend members of different groups, including different racial groups, they can be afraid to do so. Creating dialogue in the classroom can be a first, formative step in encouraging students to discuss race in an honest way in their daily lives. I believe that it is essential that such dialogue start as soon as possible, and should begin early in the course of young people's education.

Teachers who actively discuss subjects pertaining to race must be prepared to meet with opposition, not just students, but also from parents. According to Tatum and the analysis noted in Race in the schoolyard: Negotiating the color line in classrooms and communities, by Amanda E. Lewis, some whites often claim that race is not a factor in America today and do not wish to talk about it specifically. They often articulate this as a desire to talk about people as people in a race-blind fashion. But this is often an unintended or an intended way of ignoring race. Refusing to talk about how people are socialized into their racial categories is not 'color blindness' but a denial of history. As parents demand more and more input into how children are educated, teachers must be prepared to meet with opposition when they broach the subject in a constructive fashion. Hopefully, if parents can be made to understood that basic skills and other topics critical to the education of children can be disseminated through multicultural materials, such as literature by diverse ethnic groups and world history, they will be able to see that the education of their children can be of a rigorous quality and is more enriched socially because of the open attitude of the classroom. For older children, the self-criticism and critical thinking skills demanded by discussing social issues is of great value in testing situations and the real world.

Preparing students to discuss issues of race enables them to view their lives as part of a large historical context, not simply as a series of issues that are no larger than themselves. For example, when I was in high school I often heard adolescents and young adults who were white complain to black students that the black students are 'always' talking about race, simply if they mention the subject. The white students had 'shut down' about the issue because it did not seem meaningful to them, and no one had guided their learning to show them the connections between their own existences, their race and their hidden privileges -- such as the privilege of walking unmolested in the dark without being seen as a suspect by the police.

The most persistent problem I have noted with the curriculum I was taught, even with the most courageous teachers, is that African-American and non-white literature was often 'bracketed' as different from the general, hegemonic history and literature of the mainstream classroom. For example, when studying American literature, black voices were bracketed for study on 'special days' and black history was emphasized during the Civil War and Black History month. I also noted that, unlike white authors, black authors were almost always talked about in terms of their race, not in terms of their other accomplishments and preoccupations. Talking about issues where race is at the forefront is important, but so is acknowledging the 'whole person' even if he or she is a member of a marginalized group. Furthermore, the idea that race can also affect subtle social interactions, or that the 'white' perspective is itself a worldview (consider how different Native American literature and history would seem, if classrooms were narrated from that point-of-view) is lost when diversity is relegated to merely a shaded 'box' in a history book, or a footnote in a text, rather than seen a part of American culture that is always present -- as a subtext as well as an explicit issue.

Thus multicultural curriculum can be useful, but it must not be a multicultural curriculum of tokenism -- all cultures must be presented as having an equally vibrant and multidimensional history, even if certain cultures (such as American culture) receive more attention in the study of the world community. Regardless of the composition of the school, as America grows more diverse, it is essential that the curriculum looks like America and reflect the complexity of America. Race is important on a conscious and subconscious level, yet every American is simultaneously larger than any specific racial category. Tokenism or the attempt to subsume a person's…

Sources Used in Documents:


Kozol, Jonathan. (2005). The shame of the nation: the restoration of apartheid schooling in America. New York: Crown.

Tatum, Beverly Daniel. (2003). Why are all the black kids sitting together in the cafeteria?

New York: Basic Books.

Lewis, Amanda E. (2003). Race in the schoolyard: Negotiating the color line in classrooms and communities. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.

Cite this Document:

"Race Personal Educational Experiences And Reflection Race" (2011, June 13) Retrieved October 24, 2021, from

"Race Personal Educational Experiences And Reflection Race" 13 June 2011. Web.24 October. 2021. <

"Race Personal Educational Experiences And Reflection Race", 13 June 2011, Accessed.24 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Educational Psychology the Value of
Words: 981 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 80604238

(Smitherman, 2000, p. 287) (Case Study 176) Motivation in education is a crucial aspect of success but it is often incongruent with social attitudes and with the actual educational environment one is exposed to. "Poor educational attainment and delinquency are often described as part of an 'oppositional youth culture' (Ogbu 1978)." (Sanders, 2002, p. 237) the oppositional youth culture that Betts experienced in St. Louis clearly demonstrates the extremes

Educational Leadership the Masters of Education M.Ed.
Words: 3598 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 50614680

Educational Leadership The Masters of Education (M.Ed.) in Educational leadership is designed to assist aspiring school administrators in synthesizing and utilizing current research trends to practical real world environments. The purpose of this essay is to summarize the activities and learning achievements that were developed in understanding new competencies related to educational leadership. This essay will explore the five prescribed program outcomes and how I approached these outcomes with artifacts

Educational Evaluations in Culturally Diverse
Words: 7024 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 51600783

This view is reflected in increasing calls for financial equity among schools, desegregation, mainstreaming, and standardized testing for teachers and students alike; it has been maintained that by providing the same education to all students, schools can equalize social opportunity (Bowman, 1994). This latter position is typically followed up with the use of a particular curriculum designed to support the approach. In this regard, Bowman suggests that, "Knowledge is thought

Educational Platform Development
Words: 1536 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Education Paper #: 75737894

Abstract This paper is a reflection on the aims of education, the image of the learner, the image of the teacher, the value of curriculum, and pedagogical ideas. The paper discusses how education is important not just for students but for the whole community. It shows how teachers and parents must work together to provide a positive example for students, and how teachers and administrators can form a collegial culture for

Personal Philo. One of the
Words: 2584 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 74764397

" (7) Chomsky warns of ideological motivations of some scientific paradigms, just as with the aforementioned racial emphasis of early anthropology. Here, Russell espouses a Platonic episteme by enunciating the expectations of behavior between different classes. While Plato philosophized that persons are born with the characteristics fitting of their caste, Russell envisages a society in which "ordinary" men and women are expected to be collectivized and, therefore, devoid of individual expression. Jean

Educational Leadership
Words: 5923 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 49888068

Educational Leadership Select five empirical articles from peer-reviewed journals that you consider critical to your understanding of your specialization In the last several years, educational leadership has become an integral part of helping schools to outperform their peers. This is because the techniques which are utilized will have a dramatic impact on the teacher's ability to connect with stakeholders. To achieve these objectives, they will often turn to those who can inspire