1. Home
  2. Topic
  3. English
  4. Reaction
  5. Reaction Paper to Popper and Free Society Essay

Reaction Paper To Popper And Free Society Essay

Download This Paper Download this Essay in word format (.docx)

Excerpt from Essay :

reason than his critique of Plato, Popper provides much food for thought about political philosophy, and especially the political philosophies underlying American society and government. So much modern critical theory and political philosophy is rooted in Plato that it is easy to take for granted that much of what is said in The Republic and other texts needs to be scrutinized. Plato was brilliant but not sacrosanct. I appreciate that Popper urges his readers to criticize Plato and cease believing Plato to be a sacred text. Criticizing Plato actually fulfills Plato's very own objective in his writings, which is to stimulate dialogue and discussion, promote open-mindedness, and encourage critical thought rather than blind faith. What else is the cave analogy if not an urging to readers to step outside the shadow world of falsehood and into the light of truth?

Ironically, Popper champions Plato by critiquing his arguments. Popper is astute enough to recognize the value in Plato's political philosophy, but favors more the methods by which Plato reaches his conclusions, ie. the Socratic dialogue. From this vantage point of deep respect for Plato, Popper builds upon roots democratic theory to provide a solid overview of the concept of "open society." By blending also Marxist theory, Popper presents one of the most thorough and appealing analyses of modern political culture and its being often torn in two different directions between strong centralized governments presided over by elites (Plato's suggestion) and governance that is more directly democratic and populist in nature (more like Marxism). Popper therefore provides a more genuine representation of American idealism than the "republican"...
...I believe that Popper is troubled by both Plato's and Marx's seeming lack of specificity in their philosophies, as they both focus on broad and abstract ideas as opposed to pragmatism and applied political science. When Popper discusses Marx's materialistic philosophy, for instance, I feel that he might miss the value of the main points of Marxist theory and how it helped people to rethink issues related not just to social class but also race and gender. Therefore, there is very real and tangible pragmatism in Marxism (whereas there might actually be less so for Platonic philosophy), and I believe that Popper might overlook this pragmatism only to make his point.

I found Popper's analysis of historicism and historicity as too complicated, and struggled to understand what he means by it other than determinism. If Popper only means to discuss determinism, then I would agree that one of the main weaknesses in Marxism is the deterministic belief that history is taking a pre-determined course or trajectory from different forms of past governments like monarchies through to capitalist democracies, and ultimately to…
Read Full Essay

Cite This Essay:

"Reaction Paper To Popper And Free Society" (2016, April 23) Retrieved March 1, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reaction-paper-to-popper-and-free-society-2156328

"Reaction Paper To Popper And Free Society" 23 April 2016. Web.1 March. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reaction-paper-to-popper-and-free-society-2156328>

"Reaction Paper To Popper And Free Society", 23 April 2016, Accessed.1 March. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/reaction-paper-to-popper-and-free-society-2156328

Related Documents:

  • Realism and the End of

    • Words: 1070
    • Length: 3 Pages

    S.S.R. stands the fact that civil strife is less dangerous if it takes place on the losing side that it is on the winning side (p99). Realists and Their Critics Predictive failure: realism through structural realism failed to predict the fall of the U.S.S.R. And instead foresaw stability in the bipolar system. However, no theory considered the idea of the way in which the Cold War would end. Even so, theorists did

  • Public Policy on People With AIDS

    • Words: 1586
    • Length: 5 Pages

    Public AIDS Policy -- And the Band Played on, for Republicans and Democrats alike, during this public health crisis of the 1980's Today, it hard to remember a day before 'AIDS Walks' through Central Park, before television advertisements in the voice of Whoopi Goldberg proclaimed that "AIDS affects everyone," before AIDS became a public health enemy 'Number One.' But one must look back to the days when AIDS was a disease

  • Spotlighting Samplings 4 Qualitative Research Choices 6

    • Words: 16532
    • Length: 60 Pages

    Spotlighting Samplings 4 Qualitative Research Research Choices 6 the Phenomenology Method The Ethnography Method DEPTH Four Qualitative Approach Comparison Strengths and Critiques of Case Studies "A research design indicates the full research process from conceptualization of the research problem, generation of data, analysis and interpretation of findings, and dissemination of results" (Magilvy & Thomas, 2009, What and Why… Section, ¶ 4). The Question of Interest What type of research design should the researcher use? To answer the study's critical research

  • Robinson, Leahey, Freud Let's Review

    • Words: 580
    • Length: 2 Pages

    Leahey's approach is similar to Robinson's in that it allows Freud to be part of a systematic line, but different in that Leahey sees the process as a combination of far more players. 3. Can you think of any other psychologist from 100 years ago who is still as well-known today? What do you think are some of the important contributions of Freud? Why do you think psychologists are not

  • Group Communication and Decision-Making Methods

    • Words: 3441
    • Length: 11 Pages

    Group Communication and Decision-Making Methods This paper will focus on two primary factors important for the leaders, in the modern world, to completely conquer. These two factors are: Group Communication Decision making methods The paper also provides proof using prior researches done on the aforementioned subjects, focusing primarily on the role of the leader in instigating motivation amongst the employees as well as improving the overall decision making processes. The paper will also take

  • College Students and Alcohol Use

    • Words: 5292
    • Length: 17 Pages

    Psychosocial factors, such as depression, anxiety and social support, also induce drinking. This study confirmed that social cognitive factors drove college students to report on their own drinking. Psychosocial motives drove them to do so only at 1%. Social support was the only significant psychosocial predictor. The awareness of both the positive and negative consequences of drinking was quite likely behind the willingness of college students to report on