Recipient Names Request For Discovery Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Business - Law Type: Term Paper Paper: #49909478 Related Topics: Civil Procedure, Building Construction, Broadcasting, Administrative Law
Excerpt from Term Paper :

The foreign tribunal has jurisdiction over the parties appearing before it, and can order them to comply with discovery, while it might not be able to exercise that same power over non-parties and would need the assistance of a statute like § 1782. (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2471). Both Wal-Co and Expert Builders are parties in the foreign proceeding, which has the power to grant broad discovery to either party, therefore the Court would lack a compelling reason to grant the discovery request.

In this instance, there is a pending complaint with the I.C.C. However, Expert Builders would not have had to file a complaint in order to seek a discovery order. Instead, § 1782 is applicable when a dispositive ruling by a tribunal is within reasonable contemplation. (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2468). That means that the proceeding with the I.C.C. almost certainly meets § 1782's requirements for a proceeding.

Furthermore, the District Court does not attempt to impose U.S. discovery rules upon the foreign tribunals. In fact, purpose of § 1782 is to aid the foreign tribunals in their attempts to get at discoverable information. The courts do not try to determine whether the evidence sought would be discoverable under the laws governing those foreign proceedings (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2468). Nor do they attempt to determine whether that information would be discoverable under U.S. laws (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2468).

However, the statute does specifically prohibit the discovery of privileged information, which is relevant because Expert Builders is seeking information about the communication between Wal-Co and its attorneys. This issue is not critical when trying to determine whether the court should hear the petition, but it can be considered. When making a ruling on a request for domestic discovery in a foreign proceeding, the district court can look at whether the request is an attempt to circumvent the rules of evidence or other proof-gathering restrictions of the foreign jurisdiction or the United States (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2471). Courts can reject unduly burdensome requests (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2471). Furthermore, the Court may consider whether the party has attempted to first obtain discovery in the foreign jurisdiction. (583 F.Supp.2d 233, 241). Taking all of these factors together, the Court should be suspicious that Expert Builders is attempting to use § 1782 discovery as a fishing expedition in contravention of domestic and international rules of discovery.

While the above issues are of interest in helping the court determine whether or not it should consider the petition, the real question at issue is whether the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in Paris is a tribunal under § 1782. Whether or not a private arbitration committee qualifies as a tribunal is a matter of some disagreement among the circuits. The Supreme Court has previously determined that the Commission of the European Communities is a "tribunal" under 28 U.S.C.S. § 1782(a), because it is a first-instance decisionmaker (124 S. Ct. 2466, 2470)....


Furthermore, in re: Application of Babcock Borsig AG for Assistance before a Foreign Tribunal, 583 F.Supp.2d 233 (2008), the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts determined that Private, foreign arbitral body, operated by International

Chamber of Commerce, qualified as "tribunal" within meaning of federal statute providing for assistance to foreign and international tribunals and litigants before such tribunals.

(583 F.Supp.2d 233, 238-9).

However, these decisions are not unanimous. In La Comision Ejecutia Hidroelecctrica Del Rio Lempa v. El Paso Corp., 617 F.Supp.2d 481 (S.D. TX, 2008), the Court determined that Statute authorizing district courts to assist discovery efforts of litigants before foreign and international tribunals did not extend to arbitral tribunals. (617 F.Supp.2d 481, 483). That court was not seeking to overrule Intel; instead, it argued that "The Supreme Court in Intel shed no light on the issue. In fact, the Supreme Court has not addressed the application of § 1782 to arbitral tribunals, not even in dicta. Intel never mentions arbitral tribunals in the text of the opinion itself." (617 F.Supp.2d 481, 485). Therefore, the court concluded that, "An arbitral tribunal exists as a parallel source of decision-making to, and is entirely separate from, the judiciary, which was not the case with the D-G Competition as the Court was at pains to point out in Intel.(617 F.Supp.2d 481, 485-6).

The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit agreed with that decision. In National Broadcasting Co. Inc. v. Bear Stearns & Co., Inc., 165 F.3d 184 (2nd Cir.1999), the Court agreed that the "Statute authorizing district courts to assist discovery efforts of litigants before "foreign or international tribunals" does not apply to proceedings before private arbitral panels." (165 F.3d 184, 185). In fact, that court held that the authors of § 1782 "had in mind only governmental entities, such as administrative or investigative courts, acting as state instrumentalities or with the authority of the state. (165 F.3d 184, 185). In fact, the court felt that "the absence of any reference to private dispute resolution proceedings such as arbitration strongly suggests that Congress did not consider them in drafting the statute (165 F.3d 184, 185).

The reasoning in La Comision Ejecutia Hidroelecctrica Del Rio Lempa v. El Paso Corp., is compelling. The I.C.C. is not a tribunal as its decision-making ability is separate from the judiciary. Had the parties intended their dispute-resolution to be subject to the rules of § 1782, they could have agreed for their disputes to be settled by a court, even a court in a foreign jurisdiction, rather than by an arbitrator.


The party's request for discovery documents does not meet the statutory requirements of 28 U.S.C.S. § 1782, so that it can be entertained by the Court, because the I.C.C. is a private arbitrating panel, not a tribunal under the terms of § 1782.


28 U.S.C.S. § 1782 (a).

In re: Application of Babcock Borsig AG for Assistance before a Foreign Tribunal, 583

F.Supp.2d 233 (D. Mass. 2008).

Intel Corporation v. Advanced Micro Devices, 124 S. Ct. 2466 (2004).

La Comision Ejecutia…

Sources Used in Documents:


28 U.S.C.S. § 1782 (a).

In re: Application of Babcock Borsig AG for Assistance before a Foreign Tribunal, 583

F.Supp.2d 233 (D. Mass. 2008).

Intel Corporation v. Advanced Micro Devices, 124 S. Ct. 2466 (2004).

Cite this Document:

"Recipient Names Request For Discovery" (2012, February 12) Retrieved June 25, 2021, from

"Recipient Names Request For Discovery" 12 February 2012. Web.25 June. 2021. <>

"Recipient Names Request For Discovery", 12 February 2012, Accessed.25 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Market Driven Management
Words: 25695 Length: 75 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 32150042

Pharmaceutical industries have to operate in an environment that is highly competitive and subject to a wide variety of internal and external constraints. In recent times, there has been an increasing trend to reduce the cost of operation while competing with other companies that manufacture products that treat similar afflictions and ailments. The complexities in drug research and development and regulations have created an industry that is subject to intense

Burnout and Technical College Counselors
Words: 7250 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 98439444

The assumption here is that counselor burnout may be heightened as a result of the diversity of students who attend post secondary educational institutions, and the variety of services the 2-year postsecondary counselors must provide to these students. This assumption is congruent with the findings of a study by Wilkerson and Bellini (2006) who advise, "Professional school counselors are asked to perform multiple duties as part of their daily

Exegesis of Hebrews One of
Words: 5259 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 21024028

Unless the author's typological approach is appreciated, the interpreter may wrongly assume that the author is making literal statements about the salvation-historical significance of Christ. The fact that Hebrews was originally written in Greek does not provide any substantial or definitive help in the search for author or audience. During the time period in which Hebrews had to be composed, Christians in Rome spoke Greece. In fact, Hellenism had much

Foster Children
Words: 8637 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 87113745

Foster Children/Foster Care Issues of a Foster Child Child Abuse Families and Children Served through Foster Care The Policy Framework This thesis reviews foster care in the United States: the reasons why children fall into the category of children who need to be taken out of their families and placed in care, the numerous emotional and psychological responses of children in foster care, and the psychological and emotional care that is given to children that

Learning Model "Morris Goes to School" by
Words: 1085 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 52255253

Learning Model "Morris goes to School" by B. Wiseman. Heading: Your name, whole group, 5th grade, all, 09/03/2012. Objectives for Lesson The students will engage in reading and writing activities with reflection and understanding. The students will be motivated to connect the story to their own particular cultural/ethnic / routine experiences The students will be encouraged to generate situations and to apply to new circumstances using the story as their base The students will be encouraged to imagine

Consumer Behaviour Toward Coffee Shop
Words: 6960 Length: 24 Pages Topic: Business - Advertising Paper #: 26667122

As it has been mentioned throughout the previous sections, the literature review represents the research conducted through secondary sources. The information is divided into six distinct sub-sections as follows: 2.1. Consumer behaviour 2.2. Maslow's hierarchy of needs 2.3. The product brand 2.4. Elements in the coffee purchase decision 2.5. The coffee industry and the coffee market in Thailand 2.6. The ability of advertising and marketing to stimulate coffee purchase 2.1. Consumer behaviour Customer behaviour can be understood