Relevant Evidence Case Study

PAGES
2
WORDS
642
Cite

Legal Concept of Relevant Evidence Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963)

Facts: Defendants Brady and Boblit were convicted of murder by the state of Maryland, with Brady admitting participation in the crime but stating that Boblit committed the actual act of killing the victim. Boblit confirmed this fact in a written statement recording his personal confession, but during the criminal proceedings prosecutors elected to withhold Boblit's confession from the court, as well as from Brady and his attorney. Upon being convicted of the murder, Brady challenged the decision on the basis of potential violations of the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees those accused of criminal conduct the right to due process. The Maryland Court of Appeals affirmed Brady's conviction, but remanded the case for retrial to reassess the question of punishment.

Issues: The prosecution's choice to withhold Boblit's written confession irrevocably altered the sentencing process for Brady, as the court was never made aware that he did not actually commit...

...

While Brady's participation in the crime warranted a murder conviction in light of judicial precedent on the issue of accomplices to violent crimes which result in death, the court may have rendered a reduced sentence in light of the mitigating circumstances present in his case. By withholding the written confession, prosecutors violated Brady's due process right to be made aware of the evidence to be presented against him, as awareness of the written confession would have allowed Brady's attorney to seek a reduced sentence.
Decisions: The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that the prosecution's decision to withhold exculpatory evidence violated Brady's right to due process "where the evidence is material either to guilt or to punishment." Although the Warren Court found that under Maryland state law the written confession which was withheld could not have exculpated the defendant from guilt, but that the evidence was material to the degree of punitive action he would face at sentencing. The…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963)


Cite this Document:

"Relevant Evidence" (2014, February 24) Retrieved May 8, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/relevant-evidence-183631

"Relevant Evidence" 24 February 2014. Web.8 May. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/relevant-evidence-183631>

"Relevant Evidence", 24 February 2014, Accessed.8 May. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/relevant-evidence-183631

Related Documents

Evidence-based nursing is the need of time in order to ensure that the patient outcome is improved and enhanced. Instead of relying only on the information acquired through the nursing education, nurses should incorporate new researches and studies into their daily clinical routine and practices. Despite of its importance, the approach of evidence-based nursing is still not fully registered in the minds of the people and requires clarification. Apart from

Evidence-Based Practice
PAGES 4 WORDS 1453

Statistics in Social Work The steps of evidence-based practice include formulating an answerable question. How does knowing about statistics improve our ability to be an evidence-based practitioner at this step? How understanding statistical principles can enable you to better understand if a question is answerable or not. Are 'baselines' in descriptive function, or predictive function available for assessment. In application of statistics to social phenomena, the frequency, duration and intensity of the subject tested

Evidence-based practice (EBP) is defined as the conscientious, judicious, and explicit use of current best evidence to make decisions about patient care. EBP incorporates the best available evidence in order to guide nursing care and improve patient outcomes. This will assist health practitioners to address health care questions by using an evaluative and qualitative approach. EBP is a problem-solving approach to clinical practice and involves the search for and critically

Evidence-Based Group Work How can I increase attendance of a support group for at-risk teenage Latino students in a school setting? Search for Evidence In order to search for evidence in increasing attendance of a support group for Latino students in a school setting, I went to PubMed as my initial search engine. I chose PubMed because I have found it to be a great starting place for health-care research. Not only does

Janvnbakht, Hejazi, & Ghasemi (2009) have clearly identified the purpose of their study. They have also stated the importance and relevance of the research topic to the current evidence-based practice. An already diagnosed illness of anxiety and depression is included in the study and evaluation of the history of other psychiatric illness confirmed before the study. The use of participants with an already diagnosed illness facilitates the study of

Evidence-based practice is an approach that has been applied to clinical practice and nursing. Evidence-based practice started initially in medicine and went to fields like education, psychology, nursing and dentistry. It should be noted that the research is based on studies that were carried out and these studies go on to fit the scenario that is currently being dealt with. Treatments that are supported empirically are the ones that are proven