Successful The Business Has Been At Recognizing Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Business Type: Essay Paper: #51731642 Related Topics: Board Of Directors, Stakeholders, Generation, Global Governance
Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … successful the business has been at recognizing and satisfying stakeholder interests.

Paul Terminal Warehouse was originally a start-up business founded in 1916 by Harry McNeely Jr. To him, the nascent business was doing well, providing above-average income for him and his family, and making their lives in the twin cities area opulent by turn-of-the-century standards. Concepts of governance, stakeholder management, and development of plans for managing take-over attempts by his family never most likely entered his mind. He was too busy working to create a business that would outlast his own life, creating a legacy and stable source of income for future generations of the McNeely family. CEOs who are founding members of companies rarely have the ability to step away from the vision of the business and the many demands on their time to create stakeholder models, frameworks and criterion for success, which is why the majority of them fail (Ng, Thorpe, 2010).

Even after a generation of success, the McNeely family ignored the need to define accountability, levels of ownership and performance, and consider the requirements of primary, secondary and key stakeholders in their business plans. As a result, the management team enjoyed a tremendous false sense of security that would later be shattered by bitter family conflict and greed. Studies indicate that founder's families often battle years, even decades, for control of corporate assets when a stable and reliable stakeholder and succeed plan both have been defined and are enforced through wills and trusts (Puri, 2010). Not only has this business grown to a significant size without either of these to vital strategies in place, the stakeholder plans also neglect the critical ecosystem of the business that serves as the foundation of its value chain. These stakeholders include the employees, customers, stockholders (from private investment), suppliers, the local government entities who rely on taxes from this business, and the many ancillary businesses this one feeds with cash from transactions. Too often, it takes the most desperate and challenging of circumstances to bring a company to the realization that they need to have very definite plans about the future, both from a stakeholder as well as a succession planning standpoint. This family business exhibits a rigidity of organizational structure and lack of focus on the future, and instead seems to be looking the organization as a blend of family loyalties and business opportunities. As a result, the company is mediocre to failing at recognizing and satisfying stakeholder interest in the first decades of its existence. Only after a massive legal battle does the company management teams have the ability to separate out the loyalties to the family and the needs of the business.

Describe the mechanisms that are available to manage relationships with stakeholders and to influence the strategic direction and performance of the company.

There is plain and simple not enough communication going on about how stakeholders can be managed to consistent levels of performance with accountability defined in key metrics and expectations. The most fundamental strategy...


The focus on creating a balanced and unified external and internal stakeholder model provides businesses with the necessary foundation for creating more value over the long-term by partnering with, not fighting, stakeholders (Ho, 2010).

By taking into account the previous agreements and many expectations, defining stakeholder feedback and initiatives-based expectations, and then interviewing stakeholders can a foundation be created for future growth (Epstein, Widener, 2011). Often it is only through litigation that family-run businesses wake up and realize that prudent and focused stakeholder management can avert massive drains on company resources, from the time of senior management of the cash they have saved for future growth. The development of Space Center Enterprises as an over-arching business unit to control the two divisions of Space Center business segments follows this pattern. Even this approach however did not entirely work, as the brothers chose to move in their own direction. Only after a balanced, thoroughly defined stakeholder plan had been put into place and a board of directors with strong focus on result were put in charge did the stakeholder plans begin to gain momentum and fuel the next generation of growth for Meritex.

Explain why you think the board of directors for Space Center Enterprises was or was not successful in fulfilling its governance role and in meeting the challenges it faced.

To put in bluntly, the board of directors for Space Center Enterprises failed miserably. There are many factors that contribute to this, with the greatest being the lack of consistency of strategy, lack of listening to stakeholder interests and initiatives, and a lack of coordinated planning to ensure a higher level of performance across the combined business units. All of these factors, in addition to the lack of integrated planning that would synchronize services plans across all three divisions of Space Center Enterprises.

In addition to the lack of stakeholder planning and execution, the company also lacked significant insight into how best to manage the shared goals and objectives of all three companies. There was no galvanizing or unifying force that brought and kept all three companies together. As a result, they each began to divert their attention to their own direction and strategies, and the three-part company eventually fell apart. In the absence of a strong stakeholder plan, the vision of a board of directors or governing body is critical to keeping a corporation unified and moving in the same direction (Soh, Chua, Singh, 2011). This is what the Space Center Enterprises board of directors most lacked. The brother as a result had more compelling visions on their own of where they wanted their businesses to grow. Lacking a consistent and clear stakeholder plan, Space Center Enterprises was actually doomed to fail. This example in the case illustrates how critical it is to have both a consistent stakeholder plan and a unified vision of where the business is going for the long-term. Even after a major lawsuit that led to the eventual development of Space Center Enterprises, the family was still not entirely seeing the value of creating a stakeholder mode that would be strong enough to guide their business yet flexible enough to respond to significant changes in both the market and the broader global economy.

Explain why you think Paddy was or was not qualified to fill in his father's footsteps as CEO of the newly merged Meritex organization, based on strategic leadership responsibilities.

One of the worst ways to attain control of a business is through purely paternalistic means. No one trusts a family heir who comes into a company based on relationships with the founders alone and takes control. Paddy wisely does not play this card; in fact, he delves into the worst and most challenging situations to earn trust and credibility. Paddy is ironically the only member of the family for nearly four generations to concentrate on stakeholders and create a winning compromise for them. He takes into account the pains they have had and financial losses of moving to St. Paul only to find that commitment not delivering the financial reward they were expecting. He also proves to have an exceptionally calm demeanor in the midst of very tense situations and shows that the attainment of shared outcomes with stakeholders, many openly hostile to the family and company. He does all of these activities while also managing a larger part of the company than ever before. He strikes a balance of compromise and empathy to stakeholders who had been ignored in the past. In this way, Paddy emerges as a transformational leader, among many family members who were locked in…

Sources Used in Documents:


Arora, P., & Dharwadkar, R.. (2011). Corporate Governance and Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): The Moderating Roles of Attainment Discrepancy and Organization Slack. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 19(2), 136-152.

Epstein, M., & Widener, S.. (2011). Facilitating sustainable development decisions: measuring stakeholder reactions. Business Strategy and the Environment, 20(2), 107.

Ho, V. (2010). "Enlightened Shareholder Value": Corporate Governance Beyond the Shareholder-Stakeholder Divide. Journal of Corporation Law, 36(1), 59-112.

Wilson Ng, & Richard Thorpe. (2010). Not another study of great leaders: Entrepreneurial leadership in a mid-sized family firm for its further growth and development. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research, 16(5), 457-476.

Cite this Document:

"Successful The Business Has Been At Recognizing" (2011, June 09) Retrieved September 16, 2021, from

"Successful The Business Has Been At Recognizing" 09 June 2011. Web.16 September. 2021. <>

"Successful The Business Has Been At Recognizing", 09 June 2011, Accessed.16 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Successful Business Leader
Words: 2507 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 33446332

Bill Gates: A Successful Business Leader A Successful Business Leader The business world has changed into an uncertain and competitive environment where business entities compete with each other on the basis of their distinctive competencies and strategies (Basefsky, Maxwell, Post, & Turner, 2004). Globalization, intensity of competition, and technological advancements has completely changed the way businesses operate and compete in their industries (Goldsmith & Hesselbein, 2006). The biggest role is played by

Successful FDI MNE: A Business Plan for
Words: 1477 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 50143965

Successful FDI MNE: A Business Plan for Successful FDI The MNE For this paper, the MNE will be a company that originates in the United States, but that is considering FDI in Thailand. The company manufactures a snack product that is popular in the U.S. market, but has not been tested in other (particularly Asian) markets at all. This does not mean the product will not do well there, but there is not

Business Plan of a Meta Search
Words: 2289 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 53564758

Business Plan of a Meta search engine Market Opportunity & Solutions Business Model and Strategy Search engine according to countries and languages Advertisement Revolution Social Networking and Blogging Sites Revenue Opportunities Sales and marketing plan Technology overview Technology implementation Intellectual property Competition Financials Current ratio ROE Debt to equity ratio (D/E) Management Organization and Ownership Organizational Structure Risks and mitigation, Inc. is Meta search engine which intends to provide a multi-category search engine to its users at a faster pace. The growing technology has evolved our lives. Users

Business Summaries This Chapter Addresses the Reasons
Words: 4707 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 71397374

Business Summaries This chapter addresses the reasons that one should study business and businesses to begin with. The authors make the point that they do not intend for this to be a narrow study that just focuses on particular examples of successive and failed businesses, although it will include case studies too. But the major point of studying business, the authors write, is to provide a larger sense of what is needed

Business Communication With Other Cultures
Words: 2942 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 43856927

Business Communication Across Cultures Business Communication is a necessary challenge that each person faces daily. Communication is an aspect of business that is necessary to success and achievement. Many countries in the world are industrialized to the point where their culture is in what is called the information age or the digital age. Digital technology, social media, and information technology are prominent aspects to life, communication and business. This paper will examine

Business Skills and Tactics in
Words: 5051 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 99035950

Having this traditional silo-structured environment makes it very difficult to properly develop a curriculum surrounding service management. Because of this there is a significant gap that exists between the education received by business school graduates and the skills that they need to succeed in today's service heavy environment. Non-traditional Business Skills and Tactics Nontraditional business skills are often referred to as soft skills or people skills. These consist of the ability