Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,818 words

Evaluating Gettier's challenge to the justified true belief theory

~10 min read 3 sections
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Essay 1,818 words

¶ … modify JTB Theory of Knowledge. Analysis of the JTB model reveals that knowledge does not justify belief. The paper evaluates the theory of knowledge, the Gettier's challenge of the JTB, and modification of the JTB theory of knowledge.

JTB (Justified True Belief) is a theory of knowledge attempting to provide a sufficient and set of necessary conditions under which an individual can claim to possess certain knowledge. Prior to Gettier's challenge, many epistemologists have produced a routinely less detail of a person having the knowledge of particular p. The theory suggests that if an individual p has a belief of b, if b is indeed true, and if p is justified to believe b, then "p knows that b." For example, I do believe that I have two hands and indeed, I have two hands because I use my hand to do several things such as writing and typing.

However, people make intuitive distinction between knowledge and belief because people can believe in false preposition. For example, if you know p, then p must be true. Essentially, people can justify of having true beliefs, however, they do not seem to have knowledge. A person can make a mistake in believing something to be true when in fact it is false. Typically, someone can hold a belief when indeed evidence suggests that it is false. For example, a lot of evidence shows that astrologists do not make an accurate prediction. (James 1).

Gettier Counterexamples

Edmund Gettier produced a short piece in 1963 revealing analysis of knowledge. The piece stimulates and clarifies what is exactly knowledge is all about. Gettier's cases are intended to challenge people understanding the propositional knowledge, and the Gettier's proposition had a dramatic impact on knowledge because it attempts to repair the traditional concept of knowledge Gettier (1963) produced two cases to reveal the analysis of the JTB theory of knowledge. Gettier's uses counterexamples to produce arguments that there are beliefs that are both true and justified therefore satisfying the three condition of knowledge (JTB) however they do not satisfy a genuine case of knowledge.

Gettier produces two counterexamples with reference to the JTB analysis. According to Gettier's Case I, Smith is competing for a job with Jones; however; the President of the company tells Smith that Jones will get the job because "Jones has 10 coins in his pocket." (Gettier, 2). Following this proposition, the President assured that Jones would get the job because "he had counted the coins in Jones's pocket ten minutes ago." (Gettier, 2).

Suppose Smith accepts that Jones will get the job because Smiths believes in having strong evidence and justified in believing that Jones will get the job because Jones has 10 coins. However, Smith also does not know that "he himself has ten coins in his pocket." (Gettier, 2). Based on this proposition, Smith justified believe is false because Smith does not know that he also has 10 coins in the pocket; and falsely believe that Jones will get the job.

Typically, the Case I reveal that it is possible to be true and justified without being knowledge. In other words, the established combination of justification, belief, and truth in the Case I does not sufficiently entail and justify the "presence of knowledge." Essentially, Gettier's justification, belief and true seemed to be met; however, the results cannot be categorized as knowledge because of the element of luck involved.

Essentially, Gettier case is not against the traditional belief of knowledge JTB.

1,226 Words Hidden
However, Gettier revealed the flaw in JTB and the flaw assists in better understanding of the nature and epistemic justification of knowledge. The Case I…
References
2 sources cited in this paper
  • Gettier, Edmund L.. Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?\" Analysis, 23:121–23.1963.
  • James Pryor. Theory of Knowledge - The Gettier Problem (archive)
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2014). Evaluating Gettier's challenge to the justified true belief theory. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/theory-of-knowledge-192276

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.