Historical bias in portrayals of Robert E. Lee's views on slavery
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
¶ … Unfavorable Treatment of Robert E. Lee
Among the most important goals of any historian, or history writer, ought to be to present information about events and individuals without any slant or bias. How do historians accomplish this feat? By sticking to their sources, and developing their argument without trying to steer those sources toward their own personal viewpoints. Whether or not authors and historians have done as much for Robert E. Lee, who served as a Confederate General in the United States Civil War is under consideration in this discussion. Two prominent works, Ordeal by Fire by James M. McPherson and Lee Considered by Alan T. Nolan will serve as the basis for determining whether or not Lee was treated fairly in the history books. By the definition of fairness being an unbiased presentation of sources, Nolan did not seem to be as just in his delivery of Lee, painting him as inconsistent with less regard to temporal context than would be expected of a fair portrayal.
Of course, both of these books deal with Lee in a number of circumstances, during the duration of the Civil War and the events leading up to -- and following -- those four years of battle. For purposes of comparison, these texts will be examined herein on the basis of each author's presentation of Lee's stance on slavery and emancipation. Nolan brings up the subject of Lee's views on the Southern institution of slavery early in his book -- in the second chapter. This is noteworthy because the events he discusses do not actually occur until the war is almost over.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.