Adams, Primrose, and Yorick: 18th-Century Anglican Clergy Compared
This paper compares the characterization of three fictional Church of England clergymen — Fielding's Parson Adams in Joseph Andrews, Goldsmith's Reverend Primrose in The Vicar of Wakefield, and Sterne's Yorick in A Sentimental Journey through France and Italy — as literary representations of Anglican clergy between 1730 and 1780. The paper argues that all three authors employ gentle satire and unintentional irony to expose a clergy that is exceptionally learned yet dangerously disconnected from human experience. Situating these characters within the broader context of Enlightenment England, British Protestant identity, and the social role of the parish minister, the paper shows how Fielding, Goldsmith, and Sterne collectively suggest that book learning without real-world engagement renders even well-meaning clergymen ineffective shepherds of their flocks.
- Introduction: Three Clergymen and Their Shared Qualities: Thesis introducing three clergymen's shared comic relentlessness
- Historical Context: Protestant England and the Church of England: 18th-century British Protestant identity shapes clerical character
- Goldsmith's Primrose: Prim, Rosy, and Self-Deceived: Primrose's gentle satire as unreliable, self-important narrator
- Sterne's Yorick: Pride, Sentimentality, and Reluctant Compassion: Yorick's Protestant pride versus his eventual human compassion
- Fielding's Adams: Book Learning Versus Human Experience: Adams's scholarly ignorance parallels Don Quixote's bookish folly
- The Clergy as Sequestered Gentlemen: A Shared Critique: All three authors critique clergy's insularity from real society
- Conclusion: Satire, Sympathy, and the Anglican Pastoral Ideal: Chaucerian tradition of affectionate clerical satire revisited
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper sustains a clear comparative argument across three primary texts, returning repeatedly to the shared mechanism of unintentional irony as the authors' chief satirical tool.
- Historical context is integrated organically rather than dumped in a separate background section — the discussion of British Protestant identity directly informs the reading of each character.
- The paper balances close textual analysis (the snuff-box exchange, Primrose's epitaph over his living wife, Adams's catalogue of languages) with broader literary and cultural claims, giving it range without losing focus.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative character analysis anchored in a single interpretive lens — the gap between self-perception and reality — and applies it consistently across three different narrative modes (first-person unreliable narration, third-person narration, and first-person sentimental travel writing). This methodological consistency across varied texts is a hallmark of strong comparative literary criticism.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thesis-framing introduction, then supplies historical context before moving through each clergyman in turn (Primrose, Yorick, Adams). It then broadens to a shared critique of clerical insularity before concluding with a Chaucerian analogy that frames the three authors' project as a tradition of affectionate yet pointed clerical satire. The structure is cumulative rather than strictly parallel, which allows later sections to build on insights established earlier.
Introduction: Three Clergymen and Their Shared Qualities
One of the clearest features shared by Fielding's Adams in Joseph Andrews, Goldsmith's Primrose in The Vicar of Wakefield, and Sterne's Yorick in A Sentimental Journey through France and Italy is the relentlessness that the characters demonstrate — as though by sheer force of will they might manage affairs to a happy conclusion. In spite of their sometimes obtuse qualities, their evident pride, their naivety and innocence, and their ability to bungle their way into all manner of episodic conundrums, their resolute good humor ensures the reader that whatever grace they do possess will be sufficient to make all well by the end of the narrative.
Such is true of all three clergymen, and to the extent that all three represent the pastors of the Church of England in the 18th century, one could surmise that the preachers of English Protestantism were a well-meaning, if not somewhat aloof and self-absorbed, lot. This paper compares the characterization of Adams, Primrose, and Yorick and considers how realistically they represent Church of England clergymen from the period of 1730 to 1780.
Historical Context: Protestant England and the Church of England
By the 18th century, England had transformed from an entirely Roman Catholic country, as it had been a quarter of a millennium earlier. In 1701, the Act of Settlement held that the English monarch must be a Protestant, and wars against the Catholic Spanish monarchy continued (Roberts 4). England's identity as a Protestant nation, with its king as head of the Church of England, was secured. In 1727, King George II ascended the throne, the second monarch of the House of Hanover, whose dynasty would last for nearly two hundred years. Thirteen years later, the now famous "Rule, Britannia!" was penned by James Thomson and scored by Thomas Arne (Fuld 477).
The British identity from this point forward was fused with a righteous spirit of fight, mastery, pride, self-determination, and unwavering ability. England viewed itself as refined, mannerly, educated, moral, and self-sufficient — relying on no foreign bodies, such as Roman authorities in religious matters. Its ships would rule the waves, its colonies would be a source of wealth, and all of this spirit would be imbibed and projected by the Church of England clergy during this time.
Ironically, the writers Fielding, Goldsmith, and Sterne do not take as sterling a view of the Church of England clergy as the clergy themselves were likely inclined to take. While these authors do not outright condemn the antics, demeanor, or activities of this class, they do take the opportunity to playfully rib, satirize, and spoof the fine gentility of these often country-parish types — men so confident in their sense of right and wrong, and so certain they always know the right way forward, that when they utterly fail to recognize what is right before their faces, they afford the reader great amusement.
Works Cited
Austen, Jane. Pride and Prejudice. UK: Dover, 1995. Print.
Fielding, Henry. Joseph Andrews. Oxford PDF.
Fuld, James. The Book of World-Famous Music: Classical, Popular and Folk. NY: Dover, 2000.
Goldsmith, Oliver. The Vicar of Wakefield. Oxford PDF.
Nunning, Vera. "Unreliable Narration and the Historical Variability of Values and Norms: The Vicar of Wakefield as a Test Case of a Cultural-Historical Narratology." Style, vol. 38, no. 2 (2004): 236–252.
Roberts, Clayton. A History of England. UK: Prentice Hall, 2014.
Shakespeare, William. Hamlet. http://shakespeare.mit.edu/hamlet/hamlet.5.1.html
Sterne, Laurence. A Sentimental Journey through France and Italy. PDF.
Zomchick, John. Family and the Law in Eighteenth-Century Fiction. UK: Cambridge University Press, 1993. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.