This paper analyzes the complex impact of Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal on African-American communities during the Great Depression. While the New Deal was not explicitly designed to address racial discrimination, African-Americans benefited from employment and social service programs, with initiatives like the Works Progress Administration employing 350,000 Black workers. However, the paper argues that New Deal programs were inconsistent—some advanced racial equity, such as FDR's cabinet appointments and anti-lynching stance, while others like the Fair Housing Administration reinforced segregation. The paper concludes that although the New Deal represented important progress, World War II and subsequent military desegregation proved more transformative for civil rights advancement.
Roosevelt's New Deal programs were designed to alleviate poverty, not to specifically address racial discrimination. However, because of the historical legacy of slavery and discrimination in America, African-Americans were often disproportionately affected by the Great Depression and thus could benefit from these social service programs to an equal degree as whites. In the era before extensive legal protections such as the Civil Rights Acts, African-Americans were often the first employees let go by employers seeking to reduce their labor costs during economically trying times like the Great Depression. They also were less likely to be unionized and to receive the protections given by union membership.
The New Deal's progressive employment policies had a very positive effect upon the lives of many African-Americans in an immediate sense. The Works Progress Administration (WPA) employed 350,000 African Americans as 15 percent of its total workforce. African-American membership in the Civilian Conservation Corps eventually reached 11 percent. There was a clause for all Public Works Administration (PWA) contracts establishing a minimum quota for Black workers. Culturally, African-Americans were employed by the artistic side of the New Deal in works such as the Federal Theater, Writing Projects, and Federal Music Projects. New Deal education programs increased the number of African-Americans attending primary school.
FDR passed anti-lynching and anti-forced labor laws which reduced crimes against African-Americans and prevented African-Americans from being kept in a state of virtual slavery in the South via the sharecropping system. FDR was the first president to publicly call lynching organized murder. Within his own cabinet, FDR was quite progressive, appointing many African-Americans to serve in positions of power. He was the first president to appoint an African-American federal judge and promote an African-American Brigadier General in the Army. These appointments signaled a shift in federal leadership regarding the inclusion of African-Americans in positions of authority and influence.
However, some of the New Deal programs actually served to reinforce segregation. For example, the Fair Housing Administration allowed racial segregation to continue in terms of house sales and empowered whites to buy houses while shutting out African-Americans from more desirable neighborhoods. This contradiction between progressive employment initiatives and housing discrimination demonstrated the uneven nature of New Deal reform.
The New Deal was not perfect, but it was an important first step in establishing greater equality for African-Americans in America. It made a substantial impact on alleviating the crushing poverty of African-Americans in a material sense and laid the ideological foundations for much greater change in the years to come. But in many ways, it was World War II and not the New Deal that actually had a greater role in reducing discrimination in America and laying the foundation for the Civil Rights movement of the 1950s. Many African-Americans served their country proudly and made critical contributions to the war effort, paving the way for President Truman's eventual desegregation of the Armed Forces. Given that the U.S. stated that it was proudly fighting discrimination abroad, it made an attempt to create a personal example of greater equality at the home front, if only to feed its propaganda machine.
"World War II more transformative than New Deal alone"
You’re 87% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.