Skip to main content
Case Study Undergraduate 2,046 words

Aguilar v. Felton and Agostini v. Felton: Establishment Clause

~11 min read 6 sections Law · Supreme Court Case
Abstract

This paper presents a structured legal case analysis of two landmark Supreme Court decisions: Aguilar v. Felton (1985) and Agostini v. Felton (1997). Both cases center on whether federally funded Title I remedial education programs, delivered by public school employees inside parochial schools in New York City, violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The paper examines the factual background, legal issues, the Court's reasoning, and analysis for each case, tracing how the Supreme Court's understanding of church-state entanglement evolved over twelve years to produce opposite outcomes on substantially similar facts.

Key Takeaways
  • Aguilar v. Felton: Factual Background and Issues: NYC Title I program in parochial schools challenged
  • Aguilar v. Felton: Reasoning and Analysis: Court finds excessive church-state entanglement in monitoring
  • Aguilar v. Felton: Conclusion: Title I program ruled unconstitutional under Establishment Clause
  • Agostini v. Felton: Factual Background and Issues: Injunction challenged after doctrinal shifts in case law
  • Agostini v. Felton: Reasoning and Analysis: Court reverses prior ruling citing changed Establishment Clause doctrine
  • Agostini v. Felton: Conclusion: Appellate decision reversed; injunction ordered vacated
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The parallel structure — applying the same analytical framework (background, issues, reasoning, analysis, conclusion) to both cases — makes direct comparison easy for readers and clearly illustrates doctrinal evolution.
  • The paper grounds each argument in specific case citations (e.g., 473 U.S. 402, 408 and 521 U.S. 203), demonstrating proper legal citation practice and supporting claims with authoritative sources.
  • The analysis sections go beyond restating the Court's holdings, offering independent reasoning about why the decisions were reached and what policy implications follow from them.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates comparative case brief writing, a core legal research skill. By juxtaposing two decisions involving nearly identical facts but yielding opposite outcomes, it illustrates how shifts in judicial doctrine — particularly the Court's revised approach to entanglement and indoctrination under the Establishment Clause — can overturn precedent without a change in the underlying facts.

Structure breakdown

The paper is divided into two parallel case briefs. Each brief follows the standard IRAC-adjacent format: Factual Background → Issues → Reasoning → Analysis → Conclusion. The first brief covers Aguilar v. Felton (1985), which struck down the Title I program. The second covers Agostini v. Felton (1997), which reversed that holding. A references section closes the paper. The symmetrical structure makes the doctrinal contrast between the two decisions immediately visible.

Essay 2,046 words

Aguilar v. Felton: Factual Background and Issues

New York City used federal funds from the Title I program of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to pay the salaries of public school employees teaching in private parochial schools in the city. The program was established to help children from low-income families. The teachers involved were not employees of the private schools; they were city employees assigned by the city to those schools and supervised by city employees. All professionals involved in the program were directed to avoid participating in religious activity at the school, to bar religious materials from their classrooms, and to use only materials and equipment paid for under Title I. Furthermore, those Title I materials were used solely for the remedial program, and classrooms were cleared of all religious material before remedial classes began.

Taxpayers brought an action in the District Court for the Eastern District of New York, alleging that the program violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which guarantees the separation of church and state. The trial court granted the taxpayers' motion for summary judgment, and the appellate court reversed. The case was then brought to the Supreme Court for review.

The central legal issues before the Court were as follows: Does the use of public school funds to run a non-religious educational program at a parochial school violate the Establishment Clause? Does the fact that the instructors are public school employees, told that they are under the sole control of the public school system, change the outcome of the case? Does the fact that New York adopted a system for monitoring the religious content of publicly funded classes in religious schools differentiate this case from prior cases that have determined such funding to be a violation of the Establishment Clause?

5 Sections Hidden · 1,225 words
Aguilar v. Felton: Reasoning and Analysis390 words
In two prior cases, the Establishment Clause was considered an insurmountable barrier to the use of public funds in religious schools [473 U.S. 402, 408]. The programs involved in this dispute are essentially similar…
Aguilar v. Felton: Conclusion95 words
The Court ruled in favor of the taxpayers and determined that the Title I program violated the Establishment Clause. Placing city employees as teachers in parochial schools and supervising them…
Agostini v. Felton: Factual Background and Issues150 words
Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Aguilar v. Felton that New York City's Title I parochial school remedial education…
Agostini v. Felton: Reasoning and Analysis510 words
Under Title I, a local education agency (LEA) providing services to private school students faces several restraints. The LEA must retain complete control over Title I funds, use…
Agostini v. Felton: Conclusion80 words
The Court reversed the appellate court's decision and remanded to the District Court with directions to vacate its order. The ruling reflected the Supreme Court's evolved understanding of the Establishment…

References

Agostini v. Felton, 521 U.S. 203 (1997).

Aguilar v. Felton, 473 U.S. 402 (1985).

Key Concepts in This Paper
Establishment Clause Title I Funding Church-State Entanglement Parochial Schools Public Employees Religious Indoctrination Stare Decisis First Amendment Remedial Education Judicial Doctrine
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Aguilar v. Felton and Agostini v. Felton: Establishment Clause. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/aguilar-agostini-felton-establishment-clause-18320

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.