AIDS and Its Metaphors by Susan Sontag: A Critical Review
This paper reviews Susan Sontag's 1989 non-fiction work AIDS and Its Metaphors, which identifies and analyzes the predominant social metaphors applied to Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. The review examines Sontag's methodology of contrasting medical fact with popular misconception, tracing her discussion of key metaphors including innocence versus guilt, war, religious condemnation, and AIDS as a foreign plague. The paper also highlights Sontag's use of historical and literary examples to contextualize her argument, and considers the sociological implications of value judgments placed on those who contract the disease, ultimately affirming Sontag's practical, demystifying purpose.
- Introduction: Overview of Sontag's work and its context
- Structure and Methodology: Book's organization and metaphor categories
- Medical Reality Versus Social Perception: Sontag's distinction between fact and myth
- The Innocent and Guilty Metaphor: Stigma and value judgments around transmission
- Sontag's Pragmatic Purpose: Sontag's stated goal of calming public imagination
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review clearly identifies the central thesis of Sontag's work — the gap between medical reality and social metaphor — and evaluates how successfully the book addresses it.
- It moves logically from structural observations about the book to specific content analysis, giving the reader a coherent sense of both form and argument.
- The inclusion of a direct quotation from the primary source grounds the review in textual evidence rather than paraphrase alone.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates analytical summary: it does not simply retell what Sontag writes, but evaluates why her distinctions matter, particularly in the discussion of the innocent/guilty metaphor and how it reflects broader sociological value judgments about sexual behavior and disease transmission.
Structure breakdown
The review opens with context about the work and its publication period, moves through an assessment of the book's structure and methodology, then focuses on a specific metaphor as an illustrative example, and closes with Sontag's stated pragmatic purpose supported by direct quotation. This progression from overview to close reading to authorial intent is a reliable model for academic book reviews.
Introduction
Susan Sontag's non-fiction work AIDS and Its Metaphors deconstructs many of the fallacies surrounding this disease while presenting it in its proper medical context. The predominant theme of the work is identifying and analyzing the realities and misconceptions embedded in the many metaphors applied to Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS). Sontag identifies approximately four or five commonly used metaphors relating to AIDS and underscores their social and medical relevance for those involved with this deadly epidemic. The manuscript was originally published in the 1980s, when the perception of AIDS was still relatively novel and intensely terrifying for most of the population in the Western hemisphere.
Structure and Methodology
One of the chief strengths of this work is its structure, which is extremely lucid and accessible to readers. After an opening segment in which Sontag explicates some of the basic medical facts about the disease and its treatment, she largely organizes the work around an examination of the most prevalent metaphors associated with it. These include the innocent-and-guilty conundrum, war, religious condemnation, and AIDS as a foreign plague. In exploring each of these metaphors and how they shape society's understanding of the condition, Sontag draws on a wide range of historical and literary examples that both contextualize her arguments and illustrate them concretely. As a result, the reader gains a clear understanding of each metaphor and the sociological repercussions it produces.
Medical Reality Versus Social Perception
With such a coherent methodology, the book ultimately seeks to clarify the meaning of AIDS — both as it actually is medically and as it is conceived of by the surrounding population. It is one of the strengths of this work that Sontag draws a critical distinction between these two concepts. She uses medical fact to help clarify social misconception, largely returning the focus of the disease to its medical roots. Nonetheless, the sociological implications she uncovers while examining specific metaphors related to AIDS are revealing — if not about the disease itself, then certainly about the society that employs these metaphors.
Bibliography
Sontag, Susan. (1989). AIDS and Its Metaphors. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.