Skip to main content
Research Paper Undergraduate 6,251 words

Border Adjustment Tax: Alternatives for American Job Creation

~32 min read 4 sections Economics · Economic Policy
Abstract

This paper examines the GOP's 2016 border adjustment tax proposal, tracing its intellectual origins, its key supporters and opponents, and its likely effects on American workers and trade. Beginning with the House Republicans' "A Better Way" policy paper, the analysis moves through the proposal's potential winners and losers, its risks of triggering WTO retaliation and trade wars, and the economic uncertainty surrounding its impact on the dollar and domestic employment. The paper then evaluates three alternatives: ethical consumption laws that incentivize buying American-made products, strengthening the International Labor Organization, and renegotiating trade deals to reduce deficits. It concludes that ethical consumption laws represent the least damaging and most constructive path toward domestic job creation, though no single solution fully resolves the complex challenges surrounding U.S. trade and employment.

Key Takeaways
  • The GOP's Border Adjustment Tax Proposal: Origins and mechanics of the border adjustment tax
  • The Impact of the Border Adjustment Tax on American Workers: Winners, losers, and workforce effects of the tax
  • Alternatives to the Border Adjustment Tax: Three policy alternatives to the border tax examined
  • The Best Alternative: Ethical Consumption Laws: Ethical consumption laws as preferred job-creation strategy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper structures its argument clearly across four parts, moving from policy description to impact analysis to alternatives and finally to a reasoned recommendation.
  • It balances multiple stakeholder perspectives—exporters, importers, small businesses, workers, and international trade bodies—giving the analysis credibility and nuance.
  • The thesis is appropriately qualified: the author acknowledges no single solution is perfect, which reflects intellectual honesty and strengthens rather than weakens the argument.
  • Citations are drawn from a wide range of sources including policy briefs, legal journals, economic institutes, and academic texts, demonstrating thorough research.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper uses comparative policy analysis to evaluate multiple solutions against a common set of criteria—impact on American workers, WTO compliance, political feasibility, trade war risk, and tax revenues. This structured comparison allows the reader to follow the reasoning that leads to the preferred alternative rather than simply accepting the author's conclusion on assertion alone.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with an introduction that states the thesis and previews the four-part structure. Part I describes the border adjustment tax and its proponents' claims. Part II analyzes winners, losers, and intellectual origins. Part III evaluates three alternatives across multiple sub-criteria. Part IV identifies ethical consumption laws as the best alternative and examines its implications for workers, the economy, tax revenue, political feasibility, international trade, and WTO compliance. A conclusion synthesizes the key findings.

Essay 6,251 words

The GOP's Border Adjustment Tax Proposal

The GOP's recent tax proposal included a border adjustment tax that was said to be good for American jobs, as it essentially places a tax on imports. While ideologically speaking the border tax serves as an example of the kind of economic nationalism promoted by Trump during the campaign, the actual effect of the proposal is unclear at best and potentially destructive at worst. This paper examines the issues surrounding the border adjustment tax — where it came from, who is expected to profit from it and who is expected to be hurt by it, what alternatives are available to help create jobs in America, and which alternative might work best to address the issue of job creation that the Trump Administration has been so adamant about solving. The thesis of this paper is that while no single solution presents itself as fully satisfactory (because of the myriad variables surrounding the complexity of trade and job creation), an approach based on ethical consumption laws could prove to be the most beneficial and least damaging compared to other possible alternatives, including the border tax itself.

This paper begins with Part I, which examines the Better Way policy paper released by the GOP in 2016 detailing the border adjustment tax and what the Trump team claims it will accomplish. Part II discusses the winners and losers of the tax, its likely effect on American workers, and its intellectual origins. Part III examines three possible alternatives to the border adjustment tax. Part IV describes which of these three alternatives might be best and how it would theoretically impact job creation in America, as well as other factors relating to the WTO and trade.

A Better Way

The GOP's border adjustment tax proposal was released by the House in 2016 in a policy paper entitled A Better Way. Its focus was on lowering the corporate income tax rate — currently among the highest in the world, behind only the UAE and Puerto Rico — to 20%.1 To make up the revenue gap, the GOP proposed taxing imports more heavily, an idea that correlates with one of Trump's major themes since taking office: "Buy American, Hire American."2 Companies seeking to offshore production and send their products back to the U.S. would face a severe penalty, as Trump assured his base of supporters on numerous occasions.

The proposal moves the tax from an "origin-basis" to a "destination-basis"3 — the aim being to prevent companies from profit shifting. The border adjustment tax proposal is therefore a proposal to change the existing corporate income tax into a destination-based cash-flow tax, as the policy defines it. According to this definition, the border adjustment tax would cancel the corporate tax on earned income from exporting; companies instead would be unable to write off costs related to importing. As Pomerleau points out, the border adjustment tax is a common feature of consumption-based tax systems around the world4 — and also in the U.S. itself: "many retail sales taxes in the United States are destination-based and have border adjustments, and most value-added taxes (VAT) throughout the world employ border adjustments."5

The difference between origin- and destination-based systems is that in the former, goods are taxed based on the country in which they are produced without respect to the country in which they are consumed. A destination-based tax, which is what the border adjustment tax constitutes, places a tax on products based on the country in which they are consumed without respect to the country in which they are produced. In other words, both domestic goods and foreign imports would be taxed under the border adjustment tax proposal. This differentiates it from a tariff, which targets imports solely. The destination-based tax applies to goods produced domestically as well — so long as they are also consumed domestically.

Team Trump's Claims

Speaker of the House Paul Ryan stated that imports are undermining American products and that he "sees the tax as a way to level the playing field for U.S.-based manufacturers."6 Rep. Kevin Brady viewed the border adjustment tax proposal as "a way to end the 'Made in America tax' on exports" as well as a way to reduce offshoring.7 Trump himself indicated that the border adjustment tax "could lead to a lot more jobs in the United States," without offering specifics on how it would accomplish that.8 Additionally, Trump's top advisor Steve Bannon was described as "the most enthusiastic backer of the border-adjustment plan."9 White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus, Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, and trade advisor Peter Navarro also supported the border tax — with the expectation that its implementation could effectively "raise more than $1 trillion over 10 years."10

The gist of the proposal is that "the tax on imports will encourage domestic production and cause the already strong dollar to rise, offsetting upward pressure on import prices"11 — though the dollar had declined in recent weeks after Trump indicated it was too strong,12 and Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin appeared to agree, noting that a strong dollar over a short period of time "leads to issues that hurt our exports."13 Though not explicitly detailed in terms of logistics, Trump's expectation was that "companies are going to come back here, they're going to build their factories and they're going to create a lot of jobs and there's no tax."14

3 Sections Hidden · 2,730 words
The Impact of the Border Adjustment Tax on American Workers780 words
According to Julian Emanuel, executive director of U.S. equity and derivatives at UBS Securities, the losers of the GOP's…
Alternatives to the Border Adjustment Tax1,050 words
Alternatives to the border adjustment tax that could be better suited for achieving Trump's stated objective of creating American jobs, particularly in the manufacturing sector, include: 1) the application of ethical consumption laws, 2) the strengthening of the International Labor Organization (ILO) so that labor conditions violations could be referred to the WTO, and 3) reduction of U.S. trade deficits through negotiation with trade partners.…
The Best Alternative: Ethical Consumption Laws900 words
The alternative to the border adjustment tax proposal that best presents itself is the application of ethical consumption laws — specifically, the adoption of tax legislation that provides incentives to consumers who seek to "buy American." While this alternative…

Conclusion

The GOP's 2016 border adjustment tax proposal is the manifestation of a policy of economic nationalism championed by men like Auerbach, Brady, and Trump — and while the ramifications of the tax may be unclear, the idea behind it is not: it is meant to serve the interests of America first by supporting job creation at home through taxation on companies that offshore. The end goal may not, however, spark the growth in domestic business that is desired, as many small and large companies depend upon manufacturing abroad. An alternative solution to the problem of job creation in the U.S. that takes a similar consumer-based approach is the ethical consumption laws tactic. Unlike the border tax, it is non-punitive and does not punish importers; instead it rewards consumers who purchase American-made products and thus encourages domestic production. While this solution may not be a catch-all that addresses every conceivable negative factor impacting trade and business today, it does offer at least a positive partial solution to the issue of job creation in America. However, any policy that promotes economic nationalism is more than likely to be met with resistance from WTO member states. In order to achieve the aims of the Trump Administration and work toward a solution that addresses the domestic needs of Americans, a diverse and multi-front initiative will be needed.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Border Adjustment Tax Ethical Consumption Destination-Based Tax WTO Compliance Trade War Risk America First Offshoring Corporate Social Responsibility NAFTA Renegotiation ILO Standards
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Border Adjustment Tax: Alternatives for American Job Creation. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/border-adjustment-tax-american-job-creation-2171068

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.