This essay argues that the United States should abolish the death penalty on moral, financial, and practical grounds. It begins by demonstrating that capital punishment is extraordinarily expensive — often costing far more than life imprisonment — and diverts funds from other social services. The paper then examines the racial and socioeconomic disparities on death row, showing that minorities and the poor are disproportionately sentenced to death. It further addresses the alarming rate of wrongful convictions, the irreversibility of execution, and the weakness of pro-death penalty arguments such as deterrence. The essay concludes that capital punishment is both ethically indefensible and economically irrational.
The United States is one of the only wealthy industrialized nations in the world that still practices capital punishment. The subject of innumerable debates and central to America's political discourse, the death penalty seems like a cruel and outdated method of punishment. In a judicial system that claims to be transparent, unbiased, and egalitarian, the death penalty stands out as a gross anomaly. It is not practiced in all 50 states, but in some — like Texas and Florida — it is carried out with relative frequency. Beyond the ethical issues that surround capital punishment, research suggests that the death penalty is not financially feasible and may even cost more than keeping an individual behind bars for life. Moreover, statistical analysis reveals a disturbing trend on death row: the majority of convicts awaiting execution are non-white. The death penalty is also brutally final. A number of wrongfully convicted individuals have been executed, with no chance for appeal. The United States should eliminate the death penalty for moral, financial, and practical reasons.
The costs associated with the death penalty are enormous and in most cases surpass those associated with non-death penalty cases. In trial, death penalty cases "are estimated to generate roughly $470,000 in additional costs to the prosecution and defense over the cost of trying the same case as an aggravated murder without the death penalty and costs of $47,000 to $70,000 for court personnel" (Death Penalty Information Center). Similarly, death penalty appeals cost up to $100,000 more than non-death penalty murder cases (Death Penalty Information Center). One anti-capital punishment organization claims that the death penalty costs taxpayers millions more than life without parole would (Death Penalty Focus). In California, each execution has cost taxpayers an estimated $250 million, based on all concurrent costs over the past several decades. Each death penalty case ends up costing an average of $1.26 million, compared with $740,000 for non-death penalty cases (Death Penalty Information Center). The United States Attorney General devotes 15% of the office's entire budget to death penalty cases (Death Penalty Focus). Compared to non-death penalty cases in Kansas, capital punishment cases cost as much as 70% more (Amnesty International).
If the sheer numbers are not troubling enough, death penalty cases are diverting funds from other valuable social services and services directly related to the justice system. Amnesty International notes that drug treatment programs, mental health programs, crime prevention programs, and other government services are sacrificed to keep capital punishment in place. Capital punishment also imposes untold emotional suffering and financial burdens on victims' families throughout the trial, appeals process, and related proceedings.
Furthermore, death penalty cases absorb so much time and court resources that other crimes — ranging from rape to assault and battery — receive less attention (Amnesty International). The reasons for the increased costs are clear: attorneys spend more time on death penalty cases, including lengthy and persistent appeals; court time is consumed; and while trials are ongoing, the defendant remains incarcerated at public expense.
"Minorities and the poor disproportionately sentenced to death"
"Hundreds wrongfully convicted; execution cannot be undone"
"Deterrence myth debunked; international censure of U.S. practice"
Death Penalty Information Center. "Costs of the Death Penalty."
Death Penalty Information Center. "The Federal Death Penalty." 2008.
Goering, Laurie. "Florida Leads Nation in Wrongful Convictions among Death Row Inmates." Chicago Tribune. 28 Feb. 2000.
Robinson, Bruce A. "Capital Punishment: The Death Penalty." Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance. 2006.
You’re 33% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.