Case Study Critiques: Child and Adolescent Counseling
This paper presents critical evaluations of three child and adolescent counseling case studies drawn from Golden's (2002) casebook. The first critique examines the treatment of a young boy following his father's death, questioning the appropriateness of antidepressant medication, premature pathologizing of normal grief, and the eventual bipolar diagnosis. The second critique evaluates family therapy with an adolescent girl, addressing the misuse of adjustment disorder diagnosis and the therapist's skill in facilitating family communication. The third critique analyzes a suicide assessment, identifying flaws in the therapist's listening and confirmation bias, while acknowledging appropriate handling of suicidal ideation and safety planning.
- Case One: Pathologizing Grief in a Young Child: Critique of antidepressants and grief misdiagnosis
- Premorbid Factors and Family Context: Family dysfunction and overlooked premorbid issues
- Case Two: Adolescent Family Therapy and Diagnosis: Adjustment disorder label and family therapy concerns
- Therapeutic Technique in the Family Case: Therapist strengths in communication and contingency planning
- Case Three: Suicide Assessment and Therapist Limitations: Therapist confirmation bias and poor active listening
- Suicidal Ideation, Safety Planning, and Overall Assessment: Safety contract limitations and risk level conclusions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The critiques are grounded in clinical literature and diagnostic criteria, citing the DSM and standard psychiatric references to support evaluative claims rather than relying on opinion alone.
- The author maintains a consistent critical voice across three separate cases, identifying recurring problems such as premature diagnosis, confirmation bias, and over-medicalization of normal developmental experiences.
- The paper balances criticism with acknowledgment of what therapists do well, demonstrating evaluative nuance rather than blanket condemnation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied diagnostic reasoning — the author references the DSM-IV-TR and clinical literature directly to challenge or affirm specific treatment decisions, showing how academic frameworks can be used to evaluate real-world clinical practice. This technique bridges theoretical knowledge and practical application effectively.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized as three sequential case critiques. Each section introduces the clinical scenario, identifies diagnostic or therapeutic shortcomings, and offers alternative perspectives or recommendations. The critiques increase in clinical specificity, moving from medication concerns and family neglect in Case One, to diagnostic labeling and communication skills in Case Two, and finally to the nuances of suicide risk assessment in Case Three. A shared references list ties all three critiques together.
Case One: Pathologizing Grief in a Young Child
In 1989–1990, antidepressant medications were not approved for use in nine- and ten-year-olds, yet this child was placed on antidepressants immediately after his father's death. Predictably, he experienced worsening mood swings and was eventually diagnosed with bipolar disorder — with no apparent consideration of the well-documented fact that mania is a fairly common side effect of antidepressant medications.
The second concern involves placing a troubled young man from an unstable home immediately into grief therapy following his father's death. There is no more obvious way to communicate to a nine-year-old that he is "sick" — that there is something wrong with the way he feels. One must ask: did no nine-year-old ever survive such a loss without professional intervention? What did children who experienced tragedies do before professional counselors existed? The implicit assumption that they all grew up as maladjusted adults is unsupported and troubling.
Third, the author of the original case claims that grief is indistinguishable from major depression. This is a significant clinical error. Although depressed mood is often part of the grieving process, the two conditions are diagnostically distinct — which is precisely why one is classified as bereavement and the other as depression. The therapist would have benefited from consulting the DSM (in this case, the DSM-III-R) before working with clients in a mental health setting. The subsequent decision to hospitalize the child compounds these concerns considerably.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed., text revision). Washington, DC: Author.
Golden, L. B. (2002). Case studies in child and adolescent counseling. Columbus, OH: Prentice Hall.
Sadock, B. J., & Sadock, V. A. (2007). Kaplan and Sadock's synopsis of psychiatry: Behavioral sciences/clinical psychiatry (10th ed.). Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.