This paper examines Coach Inc.'s distribution channel strategy within the global leather goods and accessories industry. It provides a company overview, competitive landscape analysis, and assessment of Coach's current multitier distribution structure spanning retail, factory, and department store shop-in-shop formats across North America and Asia. A SWOT analysis identifies Coach's brand strength and multichannel capabilities alongside vulnerabilities such as supply chain dependence and price competition. The paper concludes with a proposed distribution strategy featuring a dedicated customization channel called MyCoach, designed to protect gross margins and deepen customer loyalty among the brand's most affluent consumers.
The paper demonstrates applied SWOT analysis as a bridge between descriptive and prescriptive argumentation. Rather than listing SWOT factors in isolation, the author connects each element directly to channel strategy decisions — for example, linking the "aspirational brand" strength to the justification for a premium customization channel (MyCoach) and tying the counterfeit goods threat to the urgency of protecting the direct-to-consumer channel mix. This technique shows how a standard business framework can be used to generate actionable strategic recommendations.
The paper follows a classic business analysis structure: (1) company financial overview, (2) market and competitive context, (3) current state channel description, (4) SWOT framework, (5) proposed future-state channel design, and (6) targeted marketing recommendations. Each section builds on the previous, ensuring that strategic proposals in the final sections are traceable back to evidence established earlier in the paper.
Coach Inc. (NYSE: COH) is a global leader in the fine accessories and gifts market and one of the most profitable competitors in leather goods and luggage manufacturing worldwide. Coach generated $4.76 billion in revenues in its latest full fiscal year and earned a net income of $1.04 billion. Coach is a highly profitable business, earning a 21.77% net profit margin, a 30.44% operating margin, a 33.12% return on assets (ROA), and a return on average equity (ROE) of 51.3%. An eleven-year financial ratio analysis is included in Appendix A.
These financial accomplishments are significant given how consolidated the fine accessories and gifts markets have become in recent years. The company's own market research shows the overall industry consolidating at a negative growth rate of 9.6% from 2007 to 2012, with continued consolidation of 2.4% projected from 2012 to 2017 (Coach Investor Relations, 2012). Industry analysts estimate that approximately 4,700 companies compete in this industry today, and that in the United States alone the manufacturing and sales of leather handbags and accessories generates $1.8 billion in profits (IBIS Research, 2012).
Coach holds less than 1% of global market share in the broader industry, yet commands significant market share among affluent buyers — those earning over $100,000 annually — located in North America, Asia, and throughout the Middle East, a region that is growing rapidly as a source of revenue (IBIS Research, 2012). Coach is unique in that it competes across a wide variety of product categories at the high end of the market, taking on significant inventory risk by sourcing men's and women's handbags, accessories including business cases and backpacks, as well as footwear, jewelry, and sunwear for both women and men. The company has also successfully moved into fragrance and watches — two product lines generating well over 50% gross contribution margins per the company's latest financial statements (Coach Investor Relations, 2012).
Coach relies on a direct-to-consumer and indirect channel strategy, which gives it greater visibility into customer demand while concentrating the company's focus on key markets (Coach Investor Relations, 2012). The company operates stores in Japan, Hong Kong, Macau, mainland China, and North America, and continues to enjoy success in the Middle East through catalog and Internet-based e-commerce strategies (IBIS Research, 2012). Coach operates 345 retail and 143 factory-based stores across 20 countries (Coach Investor Relations, 2012).
Coach continues to generate profitable sales and achieve strong revenue growth due to the high level of customer loyalty and brand value that its products provide. The company reports that 65% of sales come from returning, loyal customers — the highest repurchase rate of any retailer in its competitive arena (Coach Investor Relations, 2012). In evaluating competitors in this market, industry analysts have noted how fragmented its structure is and how differentiation through customer experience and breadth of products is critical for success (IBIS Research, 2012). Coach has been able to grow into a $4.9 billion corporation by excelling on these dimensions.
The most prevalent competitors include American Apparel and Tandy Brands, in addition to private-label suppliers for mass merchandisers such as French conglomerate Carrefour, United Kingdom-based Tesco, and Walmart. These three mass merchandisers are increasingly sourcing low-end imitations of Coach designs, altering labeling and packaging to avoid potential copyright infringement (IBIS Research, 2012). The net effect of competitors continually pursuing a low-end pricing strategy is a reduction in total industry revenue, as noted in the introduction to this analysis. Price wars are breaking out on low-end products that Coach sells, further accelerating the commoditization of this industry (Coach Investor Relations, 2012; IBIS Research, 2012).
Based on analysis of the industry from IBIS Research (2012) and from Coach's financial statements, the following figure summarizes the competitive landscape of the leather goods and luggage manufacturing industry.
Figure 1: Analysis of the Leather Goods and Luggage Manufacturing Industry
Sources: Coach Investor Relations (2012); IBIS Research (2012)
Coach currently sells through a classical multitier distribution channel structure, relying on 345 retail and 143 factory-leased stores in the United States alone and maintaining retail locations in 20 countries (Coach Investor Relations, 2012). Coach is the dominant high-end retailer of gifts and accessories in Japan, where the typical customer earns in the top ten percent of income in that nation — equivalent to North American incomes over $150,000 per year (IBIS Research, 2012). Due to this affluent and highly loyal customer base, Coach operates 169 department store shop-in-shops based on alliances with Japanese department stores (IBIS Research, 2012). In addition, the company has over two dozen factory stores in Japan and over a dozen factory stores across Hong Kong, Macau, and mainland China.
The following is an overview of Coach's current distribution channel strategy, encompassing direct retail, factory outlet, department store shop-in-shop, and e-commerce components across its primary geographic markets.
Coach continues to succeed in a highly commoditized industry due to its core strengths and the unique approach it takes to address weaknesses and threats. The opportunities are also very significant and could easily lead to Coach surpassing $5 billion in revenue by 2015, according to financial analysts' forecasts (IBIS Research, 2012).
You’re 56% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.