Conflict, Security, and U.S. Foreign Policy in the International System
This paper examines the evolving concepts of security and conflict within the international system. It begins by surveying competing definitions of security — from state-monopoly on violence to human security and intrastate security — arguing that the lack of consensus hampers effective global policy. The paper then contrasts Mary Kaldor's distinction between "old wars" and "new wars" with Paul Hirst's technologically deterministic view of modern conflict. Finally, it traces the foreign and security policy of the United States from post-World War II multilateralism through Cold War realism, the emergence of hegemonic maximal realism after the Soviet collapse, and the enduring influence of liberal values on American international conduct.
- Defining Security in the International Arena: Competing definitions of national and human security
- Old Wars vs. New Wars: Kaldor and Hirst: Kaldor's new-wars thesis contrasted with Hirst's technological view
- U.S. Foreign Policy After World War II: Cold War origins and U.S. rise as superpower
- From Multilateralism to Realism: U.S. shift from UN cooperation to hegemonic realism
- Liberalism and the Character of U.S. Foreign Policy: Liberal values shaping U.S. international conduct
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper systematically layers its argument, moving from abstract definitional debates about security to concrete historical analysis of U.S. foreign policy, giving readers a clear conceptual scaffolding before applying theory to practice.
- It uses named theorists — Kaldor, Hirst, and Janis — to anchor competing perspectives, allowing the author to evaluate strengths and weaknesses of each position rather than simply describing them.
- The conclusion on U.S. policy effectively synthesizes realism, maximal/minimal realism, and liberalism, showing awareness that real-world foreign policy draws on multiple theoretical frameworks simultaneously.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative theoretical analysis: it presents two or more competing frameworks (e.g., Kaldor vs. Hirst on modern warfare; realism vs. liberalism in U.S. policy), outlines the strengths and limitations of each, and argues that reality is more nuanced than any single framework captures. This technique is central to political science and international relations writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into three broad sections. The first addresses competing definitions of security (state-centric, human, intrastate). The second contrasts Kaldor's new-wars thesis with Hirst's technological-power view. The third traces the evolution of U.S. foreign and security policy from post-WWII multilateralism through Cold War containment, post-Soviet hegemonic realism, and the persistent influence of domestic liberal values on international conduct.
Defining Security in the International Arena
Security, at its most basic, is personal. People want to be secure, whether on a group, regional, national, or global level. While the most important type of security to most people is individual security — the freedom from threat of harm from outside forces — individual security is not possible without security in the larger arenas. In order to obtain individual security for ourselves and others, we must also obtain group, regional, national, and global security. That much is clear. Yet how we go about obtaining these types of security depends in large part upon how we view security on a large scale. What exactly does it mean for a nation or for the world to be secure? Is it the same "freedom from threat" that defines individual security? Or is it something more complex? Does security on a global level change the definition of security? There is currently no clear consensus on this among researchers in the field of security politics, and without consensus, no real plan can be put into place to ensure global security for all.
One traditional definition of security, as it applies to the national and international arena, is that national security means one nation having a monopoly on the use of violence within a given set of borders. One advantage of this viewpoint is that any nation holding such a monopoly will certainly be secure within its own territories; no other nation can utilize violence in that nation's realm. The Soviet Union during the height of the Cold War was a good example of this type of security. However, a drawback is that this definition only ensures a nation's security from outside forces — and even that only for as long as no other nation becomes powerful enough to seize that monopoly. Furthermore, this definition does nothing to ensure individual security within the nation, since the government retains the option to use violence against its own citizens.
As national security can often be threatened by more powerful external forces, and even internal ones, some researchers are moving toward a different definition of security — one focusing on the security of human beings rather than on nations. This concept is often referred to as "human security." It defines security as the ability of human beings to access basic needs, such as clean air and water, food, shelter, freedom from violence, and freedom from economic exploitation. While this is a noble definition, it is too broad and ambiguous to serve as an effective national or international security policy.
With the changing nature of warfare — from the typical 18th- and 19th-century conflicts fought solely between nations, with clearly demarcated distinctions between soldiers and civilians, to today's internal conflicts that threaten national stability and offer no sanctuary for civilians — a new type of security definition is needed. The concept of "intrastate security" offers one possible way to look at modern security issues, though it involves national leaders brainstorming together to develop common ideas, the kind of group thinking about which Janis urges caution (Janis, 1982). Under this definition, nations working together to address issues that affect all people — such as environmental degradation, poverty, and religious and economic tensions — can find ways to increase internal stability everywhere, thereby stopping internal conflicts that can destroy one nation and spill over into others. This, in turn, would help ensure the security of all nations, provided those nations are able to plan together adequately for the common good.
References
Baylis, J. & Smith, S. (2005). The Globalization of World Politics. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Hirst, P. (2001). War and Power in the 21st Century. Polity Press, Cambridge.
Janis, I. (1982). Groupthink. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Kaldor, M. (1999). New Wars and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era. Stanford University Press, Stanford.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.