Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights: Key Provisions Explained
This paper examines the Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights proposed by the Obama Administration in 2012 as a framework for future legislation protecting personal information collected by businesses. The paper outlines the bill's three major components—control, transparency, and accountability—and situates them within the broader landscape of U.S. federal and state privacy law. It compares the bill to existing regulations such as the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, identifying both similarities and differences. The paper also explores significant challenges to implementation, including conflicts with existing state laws and potential impacts on business practices.
- Introduction: Proposal overview and U.S. privacy values
- Background and Context: Internet growth driving need for protection
- Core Components of the Bill: Control, transparency, and accountability explained
- Similarities to Existing Privacy Legislation: Warrant requirements and surveillance parallels
- Key Differences from Existing Laws: Consumer rights and business obligations online
- Implementation Challenges: State law conflicts and business impact concerns
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Clearly situates the Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights within its historical and legislative context, helping readers understand why the proposal was necessary.
- Uses a structured compare-and-contrast approach to highlight both similarities and differences with existing law, which demonstrates analytical thinking rather than mere description.
- Concludes with a balanced assessment of implementation challenges, acknowledging the bill's value while identifying practical obstacles.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the use of legislative analysis as an academic framework—identifying the bill's components, comparing it to existing statutes, and evaluating feasibility. This approach moves beyond summary by positioning the proposed legislation against the broader regulatory landscape, drawing on multiple cited sources to support each point of comparison.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical context for U.S. privacy values, then introduces the bill and its rationale. A middle section identifies the bill's three core components before transitioning into a two-part comparative analysis covering similarities and differences with existing law. The paper closes by addressing implementation barriers, including conflicts with state law and business interests. This structure follows a classic policy-analysis arc: context → content → comparison → critique.
Introduction
The Obama Administration proposed the Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights in 2012 as a roadmap for future legislation. The proposal was put forth on the premise that a large portion of personal information gathered by American-based businesses regarding their customers and prospective customers remained mostly unregulated (Sanders, 2012). In the past few years, the privacy of consumer information collected by businesses has attracted considerable debate and concern. This is primarily because United States citizens have always valued their privacy. Indeed, from the founding of the republic, Americans have been guaranteed protection against violations of privacy, particularly regarding the unauthorized use of personal information and property.
Background and Context
Consumer privacy has become an issue of considerable attention in contemporary society because of the increased use of the Internet, particularly smartphones and the World Wide Web. The Internet has developed into a platform for business growth and innovation, which in turn helps create future jobs ("Consumer Data Privacy," 2012). This increased innovation has been driven and fueled by the use of personal information, which in turn creates a need to apply privacy principles when developing new ways of protecting consumer data in light of growing Internet use.
Core Components of the Bill
The Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights has three major components, which also serve as the roadmap for regulation to ensure the protection of personal information. These major elements—control, transparency, and accountability—are based on principles of fair information practice that reflect the increased use of personal devices and social media (Kerry, 2014). Singer (2013) notes that the United States system of privacy protection incorporates federal and state regulations that govern the use of personal information across various sectors, including education. As a result, the Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights shares both similarities and differences with other laws focused on the privacy of personal information.
Similarities to Existing Privacy Legislation
One similarity between the Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights and existing regulation is that both would relatively result in increased surveillance by the National Security Agency (Sengupta, 2013). While the focus of the bill is to promote and strengthen surveillance on the web, it is also likely to result in broader surveillance beyond the web. Second, similar to the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, the bill would require law enforcement agencies and personnel to obtain a warrant before conducting surveillance. That warrant would be based on probable cause, allowing law enforcement to read emails or conduct other forms of online surveillance. Third, like existing legislation, the bill is geared toward promoting adequate protection of consumers' personal information online. It provides additional measures through which law enforcement can enhance online privacy protections in light of increasing attempts by individuals to conceal their identities on the Internet.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.