Skip to main content
Case Study Undergraduate 1,165 words

Cost of Capital at Ameritrade: A CAPM Case Analysis

~6 min read 6 sections Finance · Corporate Finance
Abstract

This paper analyzes the cost of capital for Ameritrade, a leading U.S. deep-discount brokerage firm, in the context of a proposed major investment in advertising and technology infrastructure. Using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), the paper estimates Ameritrade's market risk premium at 7.2% (derived from 1929–1996 historical data) and calculates an asset beta of approximately 2.1 using regression analysis of comparable discount brokerage firms. Because Ameritrade carries zero debt, its cost of equity equals its opportunity cost of capital, yielding an estimated cost of capital of 21.5%. The paper concludes that any project Ameritrade undertakes must return more than 21.5% to be considered worthwhile, and assesses the tension between management's optimistic projections and more conservative analyst forecasts.

Key Takeaways
  • Ameritrade: Background and Innovation: Company history and commitment to technology innovation
  • The Need for Capital Evaluation: Why CAPM is needed to assess investment risk
  • Estimating the Market Risk Premium: MRP calculated at 7.2% from historical data
  • Beta Estimation via Comparable Companies: Asset beta of 2.1 derived from peer regression
  • Calculating the Cost of Capital: Cost of capital and equity both equal 21.5%
  • Project Viability and Analyst Outlook: Management optimism versus analyst caution assessed
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • Grounds each methodological choice — such as selecting a long historical period for MRP and using comparable firms for beta — in a stated rationale, making the analytical logic transparent.
  • Acknowledges data limitations honestly, noting that Ameritrade's short IPO history prevents a direct beta regression and justifying the pivot to comparable companies.
  • Closes with a practical judgment: comparing the derived 21.5% cost-of-capital threshold against both management's optimistic forecasts and the more cautious analyst consensus.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates applied use of the Capital Asset Pricing Model by working through each input — market risk premium, asset beta, and leverage — step by step and clearly stating the formula and data source for each. The use of comparable-company analysis to proxy Ameritrade's unobservable beta is a standard corporate-finance technique that the paper executes and explains clearly.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with company context and motivation for the study, then transitions to methodology (CAPM framework, MRP calculation, beta estimation via regression on peer firms), followed by the core result (21.5% cost of capital), and concludes by applying that result to assess the proposed investment's likelihood of success. The structure mirrors a standard capital-budgeting case analysis.

Essay 1,165 words

Ameritrade: Background and Innovation

Ameritrade is one of the most successful brokerage companies in the United States. Since its founding in 1975, it has provided a wide range of brokerage services to its customers. The company has consistently been among the first in the industry to adopt technical innovations: touch-tone phone trading was introduced in 1988; eBroker®, an Internet-only brokerage division, was launched in 1996; and in 1998, Ameritrade introduced Darwin: Survival of the Fittest™, one of the first interactive, CD-ROM-based options trading simulators. That same year, Ameritrade became one of the first brokerages to offer complex options order entry on the Internet and introduced electronic trade confirmations by email.

One of the company's defining characteristics is its deep commitment to information technology and its central role in brokerage services. Sustained investments in client-facing innovations — including touch-tone phone interfaces, Internet-based trading platforms, and electronic stock trading — have been critical to maintaining competitive positions in the deep-discount brokerage segment and to capturing new markets. However, everything new, particularly in the world of finance, is often met with skepticism, since there is no guarantee that innovations will boost profits enough to justify their cost. Such skepticism is well-founded: investing in information technology carries significant risk due to intense competition in the IT-services and computer-hardware markets and the rapid pace of technological change.

The need to reform the company and take advantage of emerging economies of scale prompted Ameritrade's Chairman, Joe Ricketts, to expand the company's customer base. This expansion required considerable investments in customer support and other services to meet growing customer demand.

5 Sections Hidden · 630 words
The Need for Capital Evaluation110 words
Because there is no definitive strategy for the company's planned investments in technology and advertising, Ameritrade needs to evaluate the risks of this initiative carefully. The company's existing capital base is not large enough to support…
Estimating the Market Risk Premium130 words
Using data from Exhibit 3 of the Harvard Business School case Cost of Capital at Ameritrade, it is possible to estimate the market risk premium (MRP). The market risk premium represents the additional return an investor earns…
Beta Estimation via Comparable Companies210 words
Evaluating the Capital Asset Pricing Model also requires estimating beta, which measures the sensitivity of a stock's return to the return on the market portfolio. Assessing the asset beta allows evaluation of the systematic risk embedded…
Calculating the Cost of Capital80 words
Because Ameritrade carries zero debt, its asset beta is equal to its equity beta. Applying the Capital Asset Pricing Model with a risk-free rate drawn…
Project Viability and Analyst Outlook100 words
The estimated cost of capital for Ameritrade is 21.5%, meaning any project the company undertakes must generate a return above that threshold to be considered viable. Under this criterion, Joe Ricketts's proposed investment in advertising and technological…

References

Mitchell, Mark, and Erik Stafford. Cost of Capital at Ameritrade. Harvard Business School, April 26, 2001.

Ameritrade. Company History.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Cost of Capital CAPM Market Risk Premium Asset Beta Equity Beta Comparable Companies Discount Brokerage Opportunity Cost Regression Analysis Investment Threshold
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Cost of Capital at Ameritrade: A CAPM Case Analysis. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/cost-of-capital-ameritrade-capm-analysis-72231

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.