This paper examines the dual goals of the American criminal justice system — crime control and ensuring justice — and considers which objective takes precedence in modern practice. It argues that both goals are fundamentally interrelated, with crime control representing one component of the broader pursuit of justice. The paper also addresses how the criminal justice system changes over time through judicial decisions, legislative adjustments, and shifting public values, including the effects of federalization, privatization, and technological advancement on contemporary criminal justice administration.
The paper uses a compare-and-contrast structure within a broader argumentative framework. Rather than simply listing positions, it situates crime control within the larger concept of justice, then uses real-world trends to illustrate its claims. This technique — subordinating one concept to another rather than treating them as equal opposites — is an effective strategy for handling complex policy questions.
The paper is organized around two distinct but related questions. The first section (roughly three-quarters of the paper) addresses the primary goal of the criminal justice system, moving from a general thesis to specific contemporary examples. The second section addresses the system's capacity for change, covering judicial, legislative, and social mechanisms. The conclusion is forward-looking, tying public opinion and technology to the system's ongoing evolution.
No single purpose defines the appropriate role of the criminal justice system in modern American society. Both crime control and ensuring justice are fundamental goals of the criminal justice system. In the larger sense, crime control is merely one component of the goal of ensuring justice, rather than a competing interest.
To the extent that crime control and ensuring justice are viewed as distinguishable objectives, the contemporary focus of American criminal justice leans more toward crime prevention — despite the fact that controlling crime may also be one of the primary means of ensuring justice in many circumstances.
In part, contemporary societal expectations and social values have emphasized the eradication of criminal activity of all types. In addition to addressing the social consequences of specific criminal conduct motivated by malice or personal gain, modern American criminal justice recognizes the role of so-called "petty crime" and "victimless crimes" in the deterioration of society. Similarly, modern trends in American criminal justice and policing recognize the degree of harm caused by ostensibly "benign" conduct at the lowest end of the spectrum of criminal law.
The American criminal justice system is a constantly changing entity that gradually but continually evolves as a function of judicial decisions and legislative adjustments. Whereas judicial decisions are more likely to concern substantive matters of law and definitions of legal concepts, legislative adjustments generally reflect social consensus, particularly over large spans of time. Admittedly, political access and the relative ability of specific individuals, communities, and entities to generate legislative changes beneficial to them are not equal when viewed from a microcosmic perspective. Nevertheless, over time, changes in the American criminal justice system are largely functions of widely shared societal concerns and social values in the United States.
In recent years, the American criminal justice system has changed in several significant respects: it has become increasingly federalized; it has seen a dramatic increase in the privatization of criminal justice facilities; and it has become ever more effective by virtue of its technological evolution. Likewise, concepts and principles of criminal reform have continually undergone cyclical changes, due in part to unanticipated flaws in prior approaches or simply to changes in society and in the nature of certain criminal activities and tendencies at particular points in time.
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.