This paper presents a crisis intervention practice session with a female client in her fifties who is struggling with alcohol abuse. Drawing on research into substance use among midlife women, including the influence of menopause and social stigma, the paper outlines how cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) was applied through metaphor-based techniques. The session dialogue demonstrates collaborative therapeutic strategies, including the "two experts" framework, the architect-and-surveyor metaphor, and behavioral exercises such as tooth-brushing with the non-dominant hand. The paper also examines cognitive distortions associated with depression and helplessness, and argues that empathic listening and collaborative engagement are essential to meaningful therapeutic progress.
The paper demonstrates applied literature review — using research not as an end in itself but as a foundation for clinical decision-making. Each source is introduced with its relevance to the client clearly stated, and the session dialogue then shows those concepts enacted in practice. This "research-to-application" structure is a hallmark of effective counseling case study writing.
The paper opens with a framing quotation and session overview, moves into a literature review on midlife women and alcohol use, explains the CBT framework and specific techniques to be used, presents a dramatized session transcript, reflects on the session's clinical implications, and closes with a brief conclusion. This arc — from research context, through technique, to application, to reflection — gives the paper a clear and logical progression typical of clinical case study format.
The client in this case is unable to stop consuming alcohol; she smelled of alcohol prior to arriving at the session. The positive aspect of this session, evident from the outset, is that she has decided to seek help for her addiction. A woman in her fifties may be going through or approaching menopause, and she is certainly experiencing changes as she moves into midlife. Given that she has a problem with alcohol, however, any other issues dragging her down from where she once was are exacerbated by the drinking. Some creative and proven strategies are needed in this therapy; the basis for those strategies will be cognitive behavioral therapy.
Prior to the arrival of the woman (referred to here as Gina) for her appointment, it is important to research the issues surrounding a woman in her fifties who may be involved in abusing substances such as alcohol. Few if any of the specifics from the research will necessarily apply to Gina directly, but having a broad psychological and social background on women who may be approaching or going through menopause — and who also have a drinking problem — is certainly important for the counselor and therapist. There will be no attempt to fit Gina's issues into a neatly pre-arranged therapeutic package based on research into women her age struggling with alcohol, self-esteem, and depression.
As author George E. Vaillant explains, while men get drunk and it tends to be "a source of merriment" in film and popular literature, "intoxication in women (who develop alcoholism for the same reasons as men do) amuses no one" (Vaillant, 1995, 123). Because women can "drink less alcohol safely" than men, because there are "stronger social sanctions against heavy drinking in women" than in men, and because alcoholism is more stigmatized in women, women face "more barriers to obtaining treatment" (Vaillant, 123).
Given these realities, Vaillant — a professor of psychiatry — asserts that diagnoses in women are frequently missed, and that there is a strong likelihood women will be treated for "secondary depression and anxiety rather than primary alcoholism" (123). Vaillant further argues that alcohol abuse appears to be the "cause of psychological problems in women, rather than psychological problems causing the alcohol abuse" (124).
Regarding issues that Gina may have relating to menopause, Dr. Nada L. Stotland, past president of the American Psychiatric Association, explains that "menopause means aging" and that "aging is frightening… so we pretend we are just halfway through life" rather than facing the reality that age is catching up with us (Stotland, 2005, 1).
Author Nancy Beckham referenced 108 research studies and conducted her own meta-analysis, arriving at six points relating to menopausal stigmas. Several of those points are relevant here: (a) "life stresses account for much of the variation in emotional well-being" during menopause; (b) "negative preconceptions about the physical and emotional aspects of menopause" lead to even greater distress; (c) viewing menopause as a "deficiency disease" leads to additional emotional problems associated with middle age; (d) blaming personal emotional problems on menopause is a form of "masking" rather than solving those problems; and (e) ten psychological studies show that "natural menopause leads to few changes in psychological characteristics" — only a "decline in introvertedness" and hot flashes are the obvious, universal changes (Beckham, 2001, 12).
Beckham also notes that negative attitudes toward menopause, a "lack of social support, poor marital relations," and stressful life events contribute to feminine difficulties in midlife (12).
The fundamental skills employed in the session with Gina will draw on Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). According to psychologist Warren Mansell, the foundational principle of CBT is building a collaborative relationship between the therapist and the client (Mansell, 2010, 51). Rather than having the client view the therapist as a "paternalistic figure who administers esoteric techniques" such as free association or hypnotism, the therapist in this instance will have a set of analogies ready to establish a relaxed, comfortable setting for the work ahead.
Metaphors are a key part of Mansell's approach to CBT. Will Gina readily accept the idea that there are two experts in the room? According to Mansell, the client is "not only an expert on [her] life, but also on their particular type of problem and how it works in the context of [her] life" (51). Another useful metaphor is the "architect and surveyor" approach. In this scenario the therapist is the architect, seeking to build a house in a "scenic meadow with beautiful meandering streams" — but unable to build without the help of a surveyor (the client). The surveyor can position the house so that flooding streams and poor soil will never pose a problem, hence the indispensability of the surveyor (Mansell, 51).
Yet another metaphor to be embraced in this session is that of the therapist as a "private detective" — like the television character Columbo — gathering information in a "quiet, curious, unassuming, and even naive" manner (Mansell, 51). Mansell also offers the metaphor of the therapist as a coach helping players develop their own strengths, with the client as a team member learning to "deal with their problems" (52).
Mansell additionally employs the concepts of "going to the post office" (clients do not want to be pushed and told where to go, so they resist this approach) and the therapist as a business consultant — not in charge, but simply offering suggestions on a better way to do things (53). Brushing one's teeth with the opposite hand is yet another of Mansell's practical strategies.
If Gina shows signs of anxiety beyond what might be considered normal nervousness, generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) would be a relevant clinical consideration. Psychologists Jayne Rygh and William Sanderson posit that "relaxation techniques" — an important component of CBT — can lead to "marked reductions in the symptoms of GAD as compared with nondirective treatments" (Rygh et al., 2004, 8). Moreover, Rygh's review of 13 controlled clinical trials — which included CBT, cognitive therapy, behavior therapy, placebo or nonspecific treatment, and psychodynamic treatment of GAD — concluded that "CBT produced the most intermediate and long-term improvement in both anxiety and depression" (9).
A competent, creative therapist should be able to bring Gina to a point where she understands that doing things differently can work for her. There is no point in lecturing Gina about her drinking problem. The 12-step program offered by Alcoholics Anonymous is also an option available to her. The appropriate approach with an individual like Gina is to empathize — demonstrating true empathic understanding rather than mere sympathy — and to become a skilled, attentive listener. If she senses that the therapist is already thinking about the next thing to say rather than genuinely listening, the therapy will not succeed. Sincerity, professionalism, and a deeper inquiry into her underlying issues — achieved by making her the surveyor and maintaining a truly collaborative relationship — can help her make the changes she needs to reclaim her job and continue the productive aspects of her life.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.