This paper examines the evolving relationship between employers, employees, and government agencies within the framework of U.S. employment law. It traces the historical development of the employer-employee social contract, the expanding regulatory role of the U.S. Department of Labor, and the structure and purpose of workers' compensation statutes across the fifty states. The paper also contrasts the U.S. employment-at-will paradigm — which places few legal obligations on employers regarding benefits or job security — with the comparatively employee-friendly labor environments found in much of the rest of the world, where collective bargaining and guaranteed employment are more common.
Roger Karnes (2009) cites Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol as an intellectual template for thinking about employer and employee relations, with the inherent warning that the boardroom will always put profits first, even at the expense of an employee's health and safety. During the 20th century, a social contract emerged between employees and employers that provided long-term employment, fair wages, and in some cases pensions. As the century progressed, the government took on a greater role when political representatives created protections for the unemployed, underemployed, minorities, and those without pensions. The role of government in regulating the relationship between employers and employees continued to expand as employee safety became a recognized issue that needed to be addressed.
The role of employers in protecting the health and safety of employees is widely recognized, and many businesses take this responsibility seriously. However, the expanding role of the government in regulating this relationship reveals that some employers take this responsibility too lightly (DOL, n.d.). The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) is the primary federal agency responsible for ensuring that the numerous labor laws protecting both employees and employers are followed. Sanctions can range from small fines to criminal prosecution.
The purpose of workers' compensation statutes is to provide benefits for employees who are injured on the job and to compensate the dependents of workers killed while working (LII, n.d.). These statutes have been enacted at the state level, although several federal statutes have been created that cover federal employees, miners, merchant marines, and harbor workers. The overall goal of workers' compensation laws is to provide an equitable solution for both employees and employers, thereby reducing the need for costly litigation. In some states, the amount of the benefit has been limited to protect employers, and co-worker liability cannot be pursued legally.
Workers' compensation statutes are similar across all 50 states and typically require employers to purchase workers' compensation insurance (LII, n.d.). The benefits paid to injured workers include covering all medical expenses and providing a salary while the worker is unable to work. If the injury results in a permanent disability that limits employability, a lifetime benefit may be paid. Some workers may be required to undergo a vocational retraining program in order to continue receiving benefits. When a worker is killed on the job, dependents are provided with a death benefit similar to what a life insurance policy would provide. More information on the legal framework governing these benefits is available through the Legal Information Institute's workers' compensation overview.
"Employee-friendly labor contracts in international context"
"U.S. at-will employment and minimal employer obligations"
You’re 69% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.