This paper examines the crisis facing multiple tuna species as a result of decades of commercial overfishing and tuna farming. It begins with an overview of the major commercially harvested tuna species — including skipjack, albacore, yellowfin, Northern and Southern bluefin, and bigeye — and documents their alarming population declines. The paper then analyzes the primary causes of depletion, focusing on industrial fishing methods such as long-lining and purse-seine netting, as well as the expanding tuna farming industry along Australian and Mediterranean coasts. Finally, it considers proposed solutions, including fishing moratoriums and catch quotas, while noting the significant loopholes that undermine recovery efforts.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
For centuries, the seas have been viewed as a limitless bounty — a continuous source of food and resources. However, decades of fishing, pollution, and habitat destruction have taken their toll. Scientists now estimate that some 90% of the oceans have been overfished. With over 80 species of fish teetering on the verge of extinction, experts liken the continued human consumption of ocean life to the last buffalo hunt.
This paper focuses on the effects of overfishing on one of the most widely consumed fish species: the tuna. The first part provides an overview of the various tuna species. The next part examines the reasons behind the depletion of the tuna population. The final part details the consequences of this depletion and the various proposals put forth to help the tuna population recover.
Commercially speaking, tuna is the most profitable and important fish species. Because of their popularity, at least six species of tuna are either on the verge of the endangered list or nearing extinction altogether.
The tropical skipjack, for example, is the species most commonly used in canned tuna. Albacore, another light-fleshed tuna, is also frequently canned (Hailes).
Nearly 35% of all tuna harvested from the oceans are yellowfin, the main species used in making sushi. Because of their popularity, scientists say that the yellowfin population has declined by over 30% over the past decade (Hailes).
The Northern bluefin and Southern bluefin are the most endangered tuna species. The Southern bluefin is found in the southern oceans. This species has a high fat content and is highly valued by the Japanese market for making sashimi ("What are Southern Bluefin Tuna").
Their Atlantic counterparts, the Northern bluefin, once populated the Mediterranean seas. However, experts estimate that the critically endangered Northern bluefin is now in danger of becoming extinct. The Northern bluefin population has declined by an estimated 98% over four decades of commercial fishing (ECES News Articles).
Despite these dire figures, the Northern bluefin continues to be harvested for the Japanese sushi market. Making matters worse, bluefin tuna is also growing in popularity in the Mediterranean market. Left unchecked, the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) warns that wild bluefin stock could completely disappear from the oceans within a few years (ECES News Articles).
The critical situation of the bluefin and yellowfin has placed a strain on other tuna species as well. The bigeye tuna, for example, is currently found in the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. Because it is being eyed as a replacement for the popular bluefins, the bigeye tuna now faces the same dangers that decimated other tuna populations ("The Trouble With Tuna").
In a healthy ecosystem, tuna populations would spawn in schools, grow to adulthood, and produce the next generation. However, several factors have disrupted this cycle, interfering with the tuna's ability to spawn and resulting in severely depleted populations.
Most of these disrupting factors are human-made. Since the 1960s, traditional pole-and-line fishing has given way to industrial commercial tactics, which have greatly increased catch volumes and placed enormous stress on tuna populations.
One commercial fishing technique involves the use of long-lines. Instead of single hooks, long-liner boats string out up to 3,000 baited hooks across miles of ocean. Fleets of these boats trawl the sea for hours at a time, hooking far more tuna than could be caught with a traditional, human-operated pole (Greenpeace).
Critics contend that long-line fishing also hooks juvenile tuna, disrupting the school's ability to spawn and preventing the population from recovering. In addition to tuna, these long-lines kill other wildlife, including endangered species of shark and sea turtles. To release trapped dolphins, many fishers simply cut the line and leave the hook inside the animal (Greenpeace).
In the oceans around Australia, the Southern bluefin is often caught using the purse-seine method. Instead of hooks, fishers use fine nets to enclose the fish ("What are Southern Bluefin Tuna"). Currently, there are an estimated 3.5 million such fishing vessels scouring the ocean for edible fish, many equipped with sonar equipment and satellite navigation. These nets can snare up to 120,000 pounds of fish during a single run. The most modern trawlers have their own onboard freezers and processing facilities, allowing them to remain at sea for months at a time.
Corollary to commercial overfishing, tuna stocks are also being depleted by tuna farming. Australian fishers, for example, use purse-seine nets to enclose schools of Southern bluefins and tow them to fish pens located near the Australian mainland. The tuna are then fattened for several months before being slaughtered and sold to Japanese markets ("What are Southern Bluefin Tuna").
Tuna farms have also proliferated along the Mediterranean coast. As of 2002, 30 farms along the Spanish, Croatian, and Maltese coasts produced an estimated 12,000 metric tons of tuna annually. Additional tuna farms were being developed in Tunisia, Algeria, Greece, and Turkey ("Mediterranean bluefin tuna on endangered list?").
Rather than allowing wild tuna populations to recover, these tuna farms place an even greater strain on wild stocks. This is because tuna do not breed in captivity ("Mediterranean bluefin tuna on endangered list?"). As soon as captive tuna are slaughtered and sold, new schools of wild fish must be caught to replenish the empty fish pens.
The growing demand from these farms far outstrips the tuna population's ability to replenish itself. The Southern bluefin, for example, can live up to 40 years and does not reach sexual maturity until it is around six feet long and approximately 440 pounds. Experts believe that females reach spawning size only after eight years. Compounding the problem, the tuna breeding cycle is regulated by season and ocean water temperature. The Southern bluefin spawns only during the warm summer months in the Indian Ocean, and a single female can produce several million eggs during spawning season ("What are Southern Bluefin Tuna").
"Moratoriums, quotas, and key enforcement loopholes"
Forty years of commercial fishing continue to take their toll on tuna and other marine species. The popular Northern and Southern bluefins are now facing extinction. Other tuna species face the same danger, as they are increasingly being eyed as replacements for depleted populations.
You’re 76% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.