This paper examines the ethical and legal landscape of electronic commerce, beginning with a concise definition of e-commerce and the motivations businesses have for adopting it. It then systematically analyzes major legal and ethical challenges, including the enforcement of contracts and legal directives, the collection and security of consumer data, the absence of uniform international laws, violations of copyright and patent protections, and taxation difficulties. Additional issues addressed include consumer privacy, the displacement of small businesses, electronic deception, and language barriers. Drawing on utilitarian and Kantian ethical frameworks, the paper argues that businesses and governments must develop comprehensive, enforceable standards to ensure a secure and fair e-commerce environment.
The paper exemplifies applied ethical analysis: it does not merely list problems but evaluates them through competing theoretical lenses. By weighing the cost-benefit logic of utilitarianism against the categorical imperatives of Kantian ethics, the author shows how the same practice — collecting consumer data via cookies — can be condemned on multiple independent ethical grounds, strengthening the overall argument.
The paper opens with a brief definitional section establishing what e-commerce is and why businesses adopt it. It then moves through a numbered sequence of legal issues (contract enforcement, data security, uniform law, intellectual property, taxation) before pivoting to a shorter "other issues" section covering privacy, small-business displacement, electronic deception, and language barriers. A declarative statement calling for regulatory action precedes the conclusion, which synthesizes the paper's central warning about unresolved ethical and legal risks.
During the last decade, the internet has experienced unprecedented growth. Thanks to the increase in online activity, consumers and businesses from all over the world are becoming more appreciative of e-commerce. However, with enhanced awareness of e-commerce comes a wide range of ethical and legal implications.
It is important to note that governments and relevant authorities have historically found it relatively easy to regulate traditional business enterprises. Indeed, some of the laws regulating businesses today — including those that apply to e-commerce — were enacted before the age of cyberspace. From a legal perspective, electronic commerce introduces new complications and challenges. For instance, given the trans-border nature and application of e-commerce, which laws should govern it? Should each country enact its own e-commerce regulations, or should a single body of laws govern all e-commerce activity?
E-commerce also brings along numerous challenges from an ethical perspective. Ethics, in basic terms, refers to the various rules or standards of behavior an individual elects to adhere to. Just as in many other realms of business, e-commerce carries a number of ethical implications. For instance, can the collection of private information — especially regarding an individual's browsing habits and preferences — without that individual's knowledge be considered ethical?
Before discussing these legal and ethical issues, it is prudent to offer a concise definition of e-commerce. In basic terms, "electronic commerce, or e-commerce, covers the range of online business activities for products and services, both business-to-business and business-to-consumer, through the Internet" (Rosen, 2002, p. 4). As Rosen further points out, e-commerce can be divided into two components: online shopping and online purchasing. While online shopping encompasses all the information and activities that enable a client to conduct commercial activities with a seller, online purchasing consists of all the technology that facilitates "the exchange of data and the purchase of a product over the Internet" (Rosen, 2002, p. 4).
Based on this definition, e-commerce enables business entities to conduct business and reach customers over an electronic platform — the internet. It applies to all key market segments, which Chesher, Kaura, and Linton (2002) identify as consumer-to-consumer, business-to-consumer, and business-to-business. Today, many businesses are increasingly embracing e-commerce in an attempt to remain relevant in a fast-evolving marketplace. Entities that have successfully embraced e-commerce include Target and Walmart, two very successful retailers that, in addition to maintaining physical locations, have developed online stores from which customers around the world can make purchases as if visiting a physical premises.
Businesses embrace e-commerce for a number of reasons. To begin with, e-commerce brings enhanced convenience to the conduct of business, both locally and internationally. Thanks to e-commerce, businesses can operate on a 24-hour basis, seven days a week. In addition to playing a significant role in profit maximization, this serves as an effective cost-reduction measure.
When it comes to profit maximization, e-commerce provides business entities with a global audience that would otherwise be difficult to reach. Unlike brick-and-mortar premises, e-commerce is not constrained by geographical or physical location. In terms of cost reduction, businesses need not display goods and services across numerous physical facilities. A business can simply maintain a warehouse from which it dispatches products to clients around the world. Businesses also benefit from significant reductions in overhead expenses, including rent, direct labor, and insurance.
Customers also benefit immensely from e-commerce. Thanks to the cost savings businesses achieve, they can more easily offer products at a discount. Customers also enjoy the convenience of selecting from a wide range of goods online and making price comparisons between various vendors — all without visiting any physical store locations, which in reality may be far apart. Although the importance of e-commerce in facilitating trade cannot be overstated, its very nature gives rise to a number of ethical, moral, and legal issues, which are addressed in the subsequent sections of this paper.
According to AMR Research analyst Louis Columbus, "trying to regulate and control the mechanisms by which people gamble or do other illegal, immoral acts with the aid of the Internet is like trying to regulate who uses what freeway at a given time of day" (Robinson, 2002). It is not hard to see why this argument holds merit.
One of the legal issues businesses conducting activities online must contend with is the enforcement of legal directives and provisions that could otherwise be enforced relatively easily in a traditional brick-and-mortar setting. For instance, with e-commerce, it is extremely difficult to regulate the sale of items that are ordinarily supposed to be sold only to those who have attained the age of majority. Unlike a few years ago, the internet today is increasingly used by children for activities such as online gaming, social networking, and entertainment. Thanks to e-commerce, children are now exposed to new threats — with the most serious being access to inappropriate commercial content such as pornographic material, weapons, adult literature, and drugs. In the past, exposure to and purchase of such content was strictly regulated: a brick-and-mortar business selling adult literature could easily verify a suspected minor's age by requesting identification. With e-commerce, this is no longer straightforward. Children can now purchase products that are largely unsuitable by using a parent's credit card. While a number of jurisdictions have enacted rules to minimize unsupervised online purchases by minors, the primary challenge that remains is enforcement.
Many online businesses have since neglected their responsibility with regard to the enforcement of legal standards and directives. Most online businesses are concerned only with adhering to minimum legal requirements and few go beyond the set legal limits. To confirm the age of a buyer, most online businesses only require the buyer to tick a box verifying that they are of a certain age. This practice is both a legal and an ethical issue.
When it comes to the enforcement of contracts, e-commerce presents numerous challenges that did not arise in traditional business models. Contract law seeks to address both the formation and the enforcement of agreements. Whenever people conduct business online, agreements are reached between the parties involved, yet most traditional contract principles did not foresee this development. According to Frieden (2009), the best answer to whether e-commerce contracts are enforceable is "maybe." The only agreements with a high likelihood of being enforced by courts, according to Frieden, are click-wrap agreements. Other types of agreements — such as shrink-wrap and browse-wrap agreements — are typically difficult to enforce.
Various factors clearly indicate that businesses and internet users will be more appreciative of e-commerce going forward. This is particularly the case with the widespread availability and usage of computing and smartphone devices that play a significant role in facilitating e-commerce transactions. The convenience e-commerce offers shoppers is also likely to attract more participants. However, every new way of conducting business carries its own benefits, risks, and challenges, and e-commerce is no exception. To ensure a secure, convenient, and fair trading environment, businesses must not only understand the ethical and legal issues highlighted in this paper but also actively pursue solutions to them.
You’re 35% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.