This paper examines the ethical debate surrounding stem cell research, with particular focus on pluripotent embryonic stem cells. It introduces the biology of stem cells — distinguishing pluripotent from multipotent types — and outlines their therapeutic potential in treating conditions such as Parkinson's disease, cancer, and heart failure. The paper then evaluates the central ethical objections raised by critics, including the claim that embryos constitute human life from the moment of conception. Drawing on scientific evidence and bioethics scholarship, the author argues that undifferentiated cells do not possess the characteristics of a human being, that nature itself destroys the vast majority of fertilized embryos, and that informed consent provides a sound ethical framework for obtaining stem cell materials.
Few topics have stimulated as much debate and controversy as stem cell research. Stem cells, which are often harvested from human embryos, have demonstrated potential for a wide range of scientific and therapeutic purposes — from treating cancer and Alzheimer's disease to repairing damage to hearts, kidneys, and other organs. Opponents of stem cell research claim that because these cells have the potential to develop into human life, harvesting them from embryos — which results in the termination of the embryo — is immoral. Whether the embryo is left over from a fertility clinic or created specifically for the purpose of harvesting stem cells, opponents see no meaningful distinction.
Unfortunately, those who oppose stem cell research base their argument on a flawed presupposition: that all potential human life must be treated as though it were a fully developed human life. They assert that the potential for human life naturally confers the same rights as those held by a living human being. In recent years, scientists have demonstrated that this premise is false. Stem cells are simply blank human cells with the potential to be converted into whatever type of cell is needed, and those who oppose stem cell research are projecting human characteristics onto a mass of undifferentiated cells.
Stem cells are "special cells with unique abilities" (Allman, 16). They are "blank" cells — that is, undifferentiated cells. While every other type of human cell is designed for a specific purpose (muscle, nerve, skin, and so on), stem cells have not yet differentiated into a particular cell type. "Pluripotent" stem cells are undifferentiated cells found in embryos. During sexual reproduction, a sperm cell fertilizes an egg cell, forming a single zygote. In the initial days following fertilization, the zygote divides repeatedly, producing a mass of undifferentiated cells that will eventually differentiate into the various parts of the human body. Before these cells become skin cells, muscle cells, or bone cells, they remain a mass of blank human cells — stem cells. At this stage, through scientific manipulation, they can be applied to a number of therapeutic treatments.
Another category of stem cells, called "multipotent" stem cells, can be found in adults or in the umbilical cords of newborns. These cells have a more limited capacity: "their development is limited to the cells that make up the organ system that they originated from" ("Academic Health Center"). However, one specific type of multipotent stem cell — the "hematopoietic" stem cell, derived from the blood system — appears to have the ability "to self-renew continuously in the marrow and to differentiate into the full complement of cell types found in the blood" ("Stem Cells and the Future," 19). Because of this capacity, hematopoietic stem cells are considered the premier adult stem cell for treating leukemia and other cancers, blood disorders, and diseases of the immune system.
Researchers believe that the potential uses of stem cells are virtually unlimited, particularly in the case of pluripotent stem cells. It is widely held that stem cells could be used to grow replacement cells or even whole organs, which could treat a variety of conditions ranging from "Parkinson's disease to heart failure to spinal injuries" ("Academic Health Center"). Stem cells could also repair organs within the body that are not functioning properly, as in the case of diabetics. By studying how cells become differentiated, scientists may also unlock the mechanisms behind cancer cell development and genetic diseases.
Additionally, stem cells can serve as research tools, functioning as a testing ground for new drugs. They are more accurate than animal models and can substitute for human subjects in the testing process. Given all of these applications, the limitations placed on stem cell research by ethical objections carry significant real-world consequences for medical progress.
Since multipotent stem cells are derived from adults or from the umbilical cords of babies, research involving this type of stem cell is generally not considered controversial. Pluripotent stem cells, however, are derived from human embryos, and collecting them requires terminating the embryo — making their use extremely controversial (Francis, 13–14). When human embryos are involved, a number of ethical issues arise, generating considerable disagreement among scientists, ethicists, researchers, academics, and government officials.
"Evaluating personhood claims and embryo status"
"Fertility clinics, donor consent, and ethical sourcing"
Many have attempted to curtail stem cell research on the basis of the cells coming from something that may potentially become a human being. These people attribute to a mass of undifferentiated cells the characteristics of a fully developed human being. Scientific research has shown, however, that these objections lack foundation. Nature itself destroys fertilized eggs in vast numbers, and even in cases where it does not, the harvested cells are undifferentiated — not yet exhibiting any of the characteristics normally associated with a developed human organism. Stem cells therefore have no more claim to "human rights" than a strand of hair or a scraping of skin.
You’re 48% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.