This paper traces the evolution of criminal justice policy from the 1969 President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice through five decades of reform. It examines how policing transitioned from a politically driven institution to a community-problem-solving model, how courts expanded their role to include forensic evidence and a stronger relationship with law enforcement, and how corrections shifted from purely punitive measures to rehabilitation-focused programs. The paper concludes by identifying key opportunities for cooperation among these three pillars of the criminal justice system, particularly around criminal rehabilitation and re-entry into society.
The evolution of the criminal justice system can be traced to as early as 1969, when the President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice presented a report on the growing challenge of crime in society. In addition to providing a detailed approach to the prevention and fight against crime, the report also outlined means of improving collaboration among policing, courts, and corrections. This is because of the significance of these three components in the criminal justice system and their ultimate impact on the implementation of criminal justice policy.
As the first point of contact between a criminal and the criminal justice system, policing — or law enforcement — has evolved through three distinct phases: the political era, the progressive era, and the reform era. Both the political and progressive periods of policing's evolution occurred during the pre-colonial period, with the political era emerging from the close relationship between police and politics. However, the development of this area of criminal justice has been characterized by significant reforms over the past 50 years, resulting in an emphasis on community problem solving. Unlike the political era, in which police were essentially the law unto themselves, the reform era has resulted in the use of the rule of law as the authority for police actions (Hartmann, 1988).
The courts serve as the venue where disputes are settled and justice is administered. As a major component of the criminal justice system, courts have continued to develop over the last 50 years, contributing significantly to the evolution of criminal justice policy. The courts have expanded to include a trial process that sometimes involves the use of forensic evidence from investigations to determine guilt or innocence. One of the most critical aspects characterizing the evolution of courts over this period has been the imperative to administer justice — driven in large part by high-profile incidents in which manipulation of the court system resulted in justice being denied.
Similar to the policing segment, the reform era has largely influenced the court system. This era has contributed to a remarkable expansion of the court system into the law enforcement arena. Courts now serve as an avenue through which law enforcement agencies seek guidance when policing the community. As a result, courts have had a substantial impact on law enforcement, reinforcing the use of the rule of law in policing practice.
"Shift from punishment to rehabilitation in corrections"
"Collaborative opportunities across criminal justice elements"
You’re 65% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.