Fruit and Vegetable School Intervention Study: A Critical Review
This paper critically examines a Dutch public health study (Tak et al., 2010) that investigated whether providing free fruits and vegetables during mid-morning school breaks could reduce unhealthy snack consumption among elementary school children aged 9–10. The review evaluates the study's research problem, literature base, sample selection, and data collection methods. It identifies both strengths — including a large longitudinal sample of 705 children across 55 schools — and methodological weaknesses, such as reliance on self-reported data, government-directed group assignments, and insufficient control for demographic and psychographic variables. The paper also situates the study within the broader context of childhood obesity, sedentary lifestyles, and dietary intervention research.
- Introduction: Diet, Technology, and Childhood Health: Processed food, sedentary lifestyles, and childhood obesity trends
- Research Problem and Questions: School fruit-vegetable intervention to reduce unhealthy snacking
- Literature Review: Taste preferences and dietary exposure studies in children
- Sample Selection: 705 children across 55 schools, intervention vs. control
- Design and Data Collection: Quasi-experimental pre/post design with longitudinal questionnaires
- Methodological Strengths and Limitations: Mixed-method validity concerns and self-reported data issues
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper systematically walks through each component of the study under review — research problem, literature, sample, and design — giving the critique a clear, organized structure that mirrors standard research evaluation frameworks.
- It balances acknowledgment of the study's merits (large sample size, longitudinal design, consent protocols) with pointed methodological critiques, demonstrating analytical rather than purely descriptive engagement.
- The author grounds critiques in cited methodology literature (e.g., Gonyea, 2005; Halkidi and Vazirgaiannis, 2001), lending scholarly credibility to evaluative claims rather than relying on personal opinion alone.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates critical appraisal of empirical research — a core graduate-level skill in which a reader evaluates not just what a study found, but how it was designed, what assumptions it makes, and where its methodology may limit the validity of its conclusions. The discussion of self-reported data validity and cluster variable limitations is a strong example of this technique.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a contextual introduction linking diet, technology, and child health trends, then proceeds section by section through the study's components: research problem, literature review, sample selection, and study design. Each section first describes what the original study did and then offers a critical commentary. The final section on data collection begins to address mixed-method validity issues before the text ends mid-argument, suggesting the source paper was incomplete.
Introduction: Diet, Technology, and Childhood Health
Processed foods and poor diet have had a negative effect on many populations, particularly contributing to obesity, potential Type-II diabetes, and a host of other health problems. Medical doctors, scholars, and researchers all agree that there is a clear link between what we eat and drink and the consequences to our overall health. Technology has certainly done wonders for learning, but has also contributed to children preferring video games to outdoor exercise. This, in combination with unhealthy diets and sugary sodas at school, has negatively impacted children's health.
Dutch researchers in public health and epidemiology were so alarmed by these trends that they developed a study to measure the effects of using fruits and vegetables as an intervention during mid-morning school breaks (Tak et al., 2010). These researchers are well qualified on this topic, as they are professionals in epidemiology, biostatistics, and public health at major universities in Holland. The information examined in this study has been investigated before and in various quantitative contexts. For instance, studies evaluating the relationship between consumption of sweet snacks and dietary preferences found that a number of influencing factors contribute to a child's food preferences (Kalsbeek and Verrips, 1994).
Research Problem and Questions
The study aims to investigate whether a primary school-based intervention of healthy fruits and vegetables would decrease the intake of unhealthy, high-caloric snacks during school breaks among elementary school children aged 9–10. The basic assumption is that the health-enhancing effects of eating more fruits and vegetables will become so habitual — and enjoyable — that children will naturally avoid sugary snacks, providing a way to address obesity before its onset.
There are some quantitative difficulties within the approach acknowledged by the authors, in that the data was self-reported and the Dutch government had already designated the intervention cities (p. 614). While there were no unrealistic demands placed on participants, perhaps not enough methodological detail was provided for a two-year longitudinal study relying on self-reported data. Even though self-reported data is necessary in many circumstances due to budget constraints or overall research design, there are known problems with its use in terms of validity, extrapolation, and tabulation of data sets (Gonyea, 2005).
Literature Review
For children and adults, eating well involves two things: a balanced approach to nutrition and the proper mindset to make healthy food choices in appropriate amounts. A balanced approach to nutrition does not require depriving oneself of everything enjoyable — it simply means eating in moderation and, when possible, including more fresh fruits and vegetables, limiting processed foods and sugars, choosing whole foods, limiting alcohol, and especially limiting sugary drinks and candies that offer only empty calories and little nutritional value.
More than anything else, childhood obesity is a direct result of lifestyle choices and overeating. Children today tend toward highly refined products with heavy sugar content, sugary sodas, and snack foods high in carbohydrates but low in nutritional value. When combined with an increasingly sedentary lifestyle — playing games online instead of engaging in physical activity — the result is stored body fat and a recurring cycle of low energy. Most children, in fact, fail to exercise because they prefer stationary activities: computer games, internet surfing, text messaging, and watching television (Lluch et al., 2000).
The actual literature review in the study was rather cursory, primarily focusing on earlier studies indicating that taste preferences are one of the primary determinants of food choices among children. That said, some studies show that the key to increasing fruit and vegetable intake is repeated exposure to a wide variety of seasonal products combined with an educational program demonstrating the nutritional value of natural snacks (Wardle et al., 2003). Still, the study contains an ample bibliography and list of further reference materials that focus on the manner in which restrictive dietary considerations can lead to more positive outcomes (Gonzales et al., 2009), as well as the ways in which children are taught about food and nutrition and how they approach healthier snack choices (Baranowski et al., 1999).
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.