This paper applies the Nadler-Tushman congruence model to evaluate Google's organizational performance across three output levels: financial, organizational, and individual. The analysis demonstrates Google's strong financial performance with $59.8 billion in revenue and substantial cash reserves, its status as a desirable employer recognized by Fortune Magazine, and its dominance in core markets like search while expanding successfully into adjacent products like Android and Chrome. The paper examines how Google converts inputs (hiring top talent) into outputs across all three levels, while acknowledging complexities in assessing whether individual success stems from company value-addition or pre-existing employee capability.
In the Nadler-Tushman congruence model, there are three different levels of outputs. The first level is the financial, and on that measure Google has performed exceptionally well. The company has increased its revenue and earnings substantially since its inception, earning $59.8 billion with net earnings of $12.9 billion. Google's balance sheet is remarkable, with $58.7 billion in cash and equivalents—literally more capital than the company knows what to do with at present.
This situation presents a complex picture for shareholders. While the company's earnings are extraordinarily high, the sheer volume of cash reserves creates a lower return on capital than might otherwise be expected. The stock is trading over $500, with a book value of equity at $87.3 billion and a market capitalization of $346.7 billion, indicating that shareholders are generally receiving good value for their investment. Even at this valuation, Google trades at only a 17.42 forward price-to-earnings ratio, suggesting that investors view the company's future earnings power as substantial relative to its current price.
Google is also recognized as a desirable employer, ranking highly in Fortune Magazine's annual survey of best companies to work for. This achievement demonstrates that Google performs well not just on the employee input side but on the output side as well, as evidenced by the retention of talented individuals who report satisfaction working for the company. The high employer ranking is congruent with overall organizational performance because the company requires exceptional people to achieve its results, and the evidence suggests this alignment exists.
The company generates revenues almost exclusively from advertising, which is the level at which Google must be understood. While the company operates several divisions and can create ad hoc groups to pursue emerging projects, formal data on group-level performance is limited. However, one area where Google has demonstrably succeeded is in capturing market share across multiple segments.
Google dominates the core online search market and related web services. Beyond its core business, the company has also achieved success with products that are not yet financially profitable. Android holds the number one market share in mobile devices, and the Chrome browser ranks among the most popular market leaders in its category. This track record illustrates that Google has been able to achieve market-driven success in products outside its primary revenue-generating business, demonstrating organizational flexibility and competitive capability.
The individual level presents a more nuanced picture. On one hand, Google is a highly successful company with relatively low turnover, suggesting strong performance with respect to individual outcomes. On the other hand, the company's inputs are strong—Google hires top-tier talent—so when these individuals perform well and remain with the company, this does not necessarily mean the company has added genuine value to their development. Their high-level performance might have been incidental to their hiring rather than a product of the employment experience.
"Employee retention, career outcomes, and investor returns"
"How Google converts inputs into successful outputs"
You’re 73% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.