Hacksaw Ridge: War, Faith, and Pacifism in Mel Gibson's Film
This paper analyzes Mel Gibson's 2016 war film Hacksaw Ridge, which chronicles the true story of Desmond Doss, a Seventh-day Adventist combat medic who refused to carry a weapon during the Battle of Okinawa. The analysis examines several dimensions of the film: its cinematic techniques for depicting combat, the characterization of enemy soldiers, cultural and religious differences within the American platoon, the framing of Doss as a singular hero, the film's use of religious conviction as a form of propaganda, and its overall anti-war messaging. The paper concludes that while the film avoids glorifying war, it presents Doss's faith in an unmistakably promotional light.
- Introduction: Film overview, cast, and production context
- Cinematic Techniques in Combat Scenes: Slow motion and gore used to convey brutality
- Portrayal of the Enemy: Japanese soldiers lack character or sympathy
- Cultural Identity and Unit Cohesion: Religious difference as the film's central cultural conflict
- Doss as Singular Hero and Pacifist: Doss's convictions frame the film's moral core
- Religious Themes and Propaganda: Faith presented in a promotional, propagandistic light
- Anti-War Messaging and Conclusion: Film's unambiguous anti-war stance evaluated
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper maintains a consistent analytical lens throughout, evaluating the film across distinct thematic categories — combat depiction, enemy characterization, cultural dynamics, heroism, religion, and messaging — rather than offering a general plot summary.
- The writer balances personal observation with critical distance, acknowledging where the film's framing may serve a propagandistic purpose even while respecting the historical reality it depicts.
- Specific scene references (e.g., the Japanese soldier being sent down to the beach) ground the argument in concrete textual evidence rather than vague impressions.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates thematic film analysis, systematically breaking a single text into distinct interpretive categories and evaluating each on its own terms. Particularly effective is the writer's ability to distinguish between what a film depicts and how it frames that depiction — a crucial distinction in media criticism, illustrated clearly in the discussion of religious conviction as propagandistic despite being historically accurate.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an overview of the film's production context and cast, then moves through cinematic technique, enemy characterization, cultural themes, the construction of Doss as a hero, religious propaganda, and finally the film's anti-war stance. Each section addresses a discrete analytical question, building a layered reading of the film rather than a chronological plot walkthrough. The conclusion integrates these threads into a clear evaluative judgment about the film's messaging.
Introduction
Hacksaw Ridge is a 2016 war film directed by Mel Gibson, starring Andrew Garfield as the protagonist Desmond Doss, who served as a combat medic during the Battle of Okinawa in World War II. Because of his religious beliefs, Doss refused to carry a weapon. Both Garfield and Gibson received Academy Award nominations for their work on the film. The supporting cast included Sam Worthington, Vince Vaughn, Hugo Weaving, Luke Bracey, Ryan Corr, Teresa Palmer, and Rachel Griffiths. The story focuses on Doss's experiences in the military and at war, but also on his upbringing and personal life. Despite Gibson's considerable controversy in Hollywood and among the general public, the film was received warmly and largely on its own merits.
Cinematic Techniques in Combat Scenes
The combat scenes are depicted using slow motion, variable sound design, and altered action speeds throughout the sequences. These techniques are in some ways reminiscent of Asian action cinema, though that impression is never dominant. The approach to the war scenes clearly serves to highlight the brutality and cruelty of war for the audience. There is considerable gore, but it never feels gratuitous — rather, it reads as an accurate depiction of the horrors of combat.
This treatment of the battle sequences fits with the film's overall story. As a medic and a pacifist, Doss is constantly confronted with soldiers bearing severe injuries, and his personal worldview means he is genuinely appalled by the violence unfolding around him. The filmmaking choices reinforce rather than contradict that perspective.
Portrayal of the Enemy
The enemy is characterized primarily through the lens of the American soldiers. Little effort is made to give the Japanese soldiers individual character or personality. In one scene, Doss sends a wounded Japanese soldier down to the beach, and the American soldiers waiting below are dismissive about that soldier's fate. Notably, even Doss himself, despite making the effort to rescue the man, seems to act more on instinct than out of any genuine extension of humanity toward him. The Japanese soldiers are clearly not afforded anything close to the sympathy given to the American characters.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.