Tragic Heroines: Hester Prynne and Tess Compared
This essay compares and contrasts Hester Prynne from Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and Tess from Thomas Hardy's Tess of the d'Urbervilles as tragic heroines. Both women are strong, morally complex figures whose lives are destroyed by the rigid social and religious codes of their respective societies. The essay explores how each author uses his female protagonist to critique the double standards imposed on women, the punishment of innocence, and the cruel workings of class and patriarchy. While Tess dies at the gallows and Hester endures a lifetime of social exile, both outcomes are presented as devastating consequences of societies that held women solely accountable for men's transgressions.
- Introduction: Two Novels, Two Tragic Heroines: Both women introduced as tragic heroines shaped by sin
- Societal Constraints and the Double Standard of Sin: Society punishes women while excusing men's transgressions
- Pearl's Punishment and the Injustice of Puritan Ideology: Pearl suffers for her mother's sin unjustly
- Strength, Determination, and Social Repression: Both women show strength despite social oppression
- Misunderstood and Mistreated: Victims of Men and Society: Men and family misuse and misunderstand both heroines
- The Ultimate Tragedies: Death Versus a Life of Penitence: Tess dies; Hester endures a harsher ongoing tragedy
- Conclusion: The Lasting Weight of Society's Judgment: Living unforgiven can be the greatest tragedy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses direct textual evidence from both novels, citing specific passages with page numbers to support each comparative claim, which grounds the analysis in the primary sources.
- It maintains a consistent dual focus throughout, returning to both characters in each section rather than treating them in isolated halves, which strengthens the comparative structure.
- The argument builds toward a nuanced conclusion — that surviving can be more tragic than dying — which challenges a surface-level reading and demonstrates genuine critical thinking.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the point-by-point comparative method, examining both heroines under the same thematic lenses (societal punishment, victimhood, strength, and ultimate fate) rather than summarizing one novel and then the other. This approach allows the writer to draw meaningful contrasts and parallels simultaneously, making the argument more analytically cohesive.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by identifying both protagonists as tragic heroines defined by societal sin and punishment. It then develops through thematic sections covering the Puritanical double standard, the punishment of Pearl, the women's inner strength, their victimization by men and family, and finally their divergent but equally tragic fates. A brief conclusion reframes tragedy as a question of endurance rather than death alone.
Introduction: Two Novels, Two Tragic Heroines
This essay examines two celebrated works of nineteenth-century literature — The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne and Tess of the d'Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy — with a focus on comparing and contrasting the main characters of each novel. Each of these women is strong and determined, but each has also sinned, and in their respective times, that sin carried devastating consequences. Both Hester Prynne and Tess are therefore tragic heroines. They may triumph for a time, but in the end their lives are defined by tragedy, and each author leaves the reader with a moral lesson to consider.
References
Hardy, Thomas. Tess of the d'Urbervilles. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1979.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. The Complete Works of Nathaniel Hawthorne, ed. George Parsons Lathrop (Riverside Edition), 12 vols. Boston, 1890.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.