This paper traces the origins and evolution of nonprofit organizations from ancient history through the modern era, with particular emphasis on the development of the American nonprofit sector. It examines the legal and philosophical roots of nonprofit law in England, including the 1601 Statute of Charitable Uses and the Elizabethan Poor Law, and follows the sector's growth through the American Revolution, the nineteenth century, and the rise of private and community foundations in the twentieth century. The paper also addresses governance frameworks, accountability standards, and the ongoing debate over tax-exempt status for large, financially successful nonprofits.
An organization can essentially be defined as nonprofit if it is not obligated to distribute any financial surplus to the individuals responsible for controlling the use of the organization's assets. The most typical categories for nonprofit organizations are arts, advocacy, civic, education, cultural, health, and human or social service, and these organizations range widely in size and scope.
Nonprofits are described by the Internal Revenue Service as organizations that serve religious, charitable, scientific, or educational purposes, and whose income does not benefit anyone associated with the administration or execution of the organization's services. According to section 501(c)(1), there are several types of nonprofits, including social welfare organizations, voluntary employee beneficiary associations, credit unions, labor unions and agricultural organizations, and mutual insurance companies, among others. The impact of nonprofits is widespread, and all segments of society are affected by the work and services they provide. For example, most people are at some point affected by services offered by nonprofit organizations such as hospitals, day care centers, universities, religious institutions, arts and cultural programs, recreation programs, and nursing homes.
Nonprofit organizations vary in complexity from simple, informal groups of individuals organized around a common aim to large, complex worldwide organizations. For a nonprofit to transition from informal to formal status, it must incorporate. Incorporation allows the nonprofit to be treated as a separate legal entity, which carries the benefit of enabling the organization to file for tax exemption. The most commonly found type of nonprofit organization classified by the IRS is the charitable nonprofit designation. One common type of nonprofit is a foundation, which typically provides funding to charitable organizations. There are two types of foundations: private and public. Private foundations are generally endowed by one of three entities — a founding individual, a family, or a corporation — and they typically function to provide funding to public charities, award scholarships, support government activities, or operate similarly to public charities.
Public foundations, on the other hand, are nonprofit organizations without ties to government that receive funding from various diverse sources. Continuing to receive funding from different sources is necessary for public foundations in order for them to maintain their status as charitable organizations. Public foundations are operated and managed by directors and trustees, and are often primarily focused on administering grant programs for other organizations and individuals. Types of public foundations are numerous, including community foundations, women's foundations, and health funding foundations, among others.
Nonprofits are broadly responsible for providing services such as higher education, hospital care, social services, advocacy, and cultural programming. Religious congregations are also generally nonprofit organizations. There are two primary categories of nonprofits: member-serving and public-serving. Member-serving organizations serve only their members and do not provide services to the general public. Public-serving organizations, by contrast, provide services to the public and not exclusively to their members.
The most prominent and important role of nonprofit organizations is advocacy. Nonprofits play a crucial role in identifying and raising awareness of problems in the public sphere that may have gone unaddressed in the past. They effectively bring attention to political, ethnic, social, community, and human rights issues. The core functions of nonprofit organizations include a service role, an advocacy role, a community-building role, and the role of guardians of shared values.
The development and evolution of nonprofit organizations are deeply rooted in history. For instance, the survival of the Pilgrims who arrived in America in 1620 can be largely attributed to the charity offered by Native Americans, which can be considered an early form of informal charitable nonprofit activity. The tax-exempt nonprofit sector in the United States is rooted in the period before the formation of the republic, when it arose in response to the service needs of early settlers. Voluntary hospitals, orphanages, and fire departments were established by early settlers to meet and address pressing community needs. The organizations founded by these settlers pioneered American traditions of citizen initiative and the promotion of public welfare by individual members of society.
The idea of nonprofit organizations has its roots in ancient history, dating as far back as primitive clans organizing to meet collective needs. There is evidence of nonprofit-type organizations in the Old Testament, where tax exemption for the temple and its priests is documented. Charitable action is also demonstrated in ancient history through documented Jewish, Roman, and Greek traditions.
Early Christianity gave rise to charitable donations and organized relief efforts. Not only were the wealthy expected to contribute to charity — all people were expected to practice individual almsgiving as a selfless gesture of penance. This selflessness was apparent in early times, but it gradually transitioned into a more self-serving practice as the upper class, clergy, and bishops began to use philanthropic actions to serve their own interests.
Throughout the Middle Ages, the Church played the most critical and prominent nonprofit role in society, serving as a hub for education, social welfare, culture, and the arts, and often directing its services primarily toward the poor. However, the development of the Church of England brought with it a shift in perspective regarding poverty across European society. The poor began to be viewed not as victims of misfortune but as being directly responsible for the hardships they endured, and were often deemed unworthy of charity. This shift in perspective resulted in welfare provision moving away from individuals and toward institutional entities, driven by the economic advantages and increased effectiveness of organized social welfare systems.
The origins of nonprofit law are found in England, where the widespread problem of poverty was addressed through the development of two landmark laws. Both laws were important for the emergence and development of American nonprofits. The first was the 1601 Statute of Charitable Uses, which served as the foundation for all Anglo-American philanthropy law. The second was the Elizabethan Poor Law of 1601, which provided the backbone for public poor relief in both England and America.
The 1601 Statute of Charitable Uses was developed to outline how funds could be appropriately allocated to charitable purposes. It was grounded in the premise that the institution of the church should receive support through tax revenue and that social services and education should remain under the exclusive control of the church. This law also defined the role of the state in monitoring nonprofit activities. The leading institutional body named in the law was the Church of England, which prompted dissent from other religious sects in England as well as from many people in the American Colonies. In America, the clause designating the Church of England as the ruling body was dismissed after the Revolution.
The second law established in 1601, the Elizabethan Poor Law, was developed to identify individuals who could be classified as the "worthy poor." This law was enacted in response to major changes occurring in England at the time, including a rapidly growing population that was producing exponential growth in towns and cities. The law rested on several core principles. Individuals were expected to care for themselves, and the responsibility of care was placed first on the family. For those who were unable to care for themselves, were deemed worthy poor, and had no family, the responsibility of care fell upon the local parish.
This law also substantially influenced the development of nonprofit law in America, as its grounding principles aligned closely with the developing culture of the American Colonies. For instance, in 1630, the first governor of Massachusetts, John Winthrop — also a Puritan leader — put forward a "Model of Christian Charity," which stated that it was the holy duty and responsibility of the wealthy to care for the poor. This marked the beginning of active religious involvement in charitable action in America, as religious leaders began encouraging parishioners to participate in and donate to church-operated charitable activities. The influence of religion on philanthropy remains very much present in the charitable activities of various religious organizations throughout the world today.
Voluntarism is an integral component of nonprofit organizations' activities and effectiveness. The roots of voluntary action in the United States can be traced to Benjamin Franklin, who personifies the voluntary spirit. Franklin was not a wealthy individual, yet he rose to public prominence primarily through organizing voluntary efforts. He directed his energies toward improving communities by empowering individuals to take responsibility for themselves. Among the nonprofit initiatives Franklin helped establish were Freemasonry in America, volunteer fire companies, a militia, the University of Pennsylvania, the Pennsylvania Hospital, and the Philadelphia Public Library. Franklin also believed that civic purposes could be advanced and community self-help initiatives supported through private institutions funded by a combination of private contributions and public subsidies.
The American Revolution introduced vast changes to the conception and operation of nonprofits in America. This was largely due to the limits placed on governmental action resulting from the withdrawal of support for the Church of England among the American people, which effectively brought about the separation of church and state.
This separation had important implications for the nonprofit sector. The most prominent development came with the First Amendment to the Constitution, which states that the government cannot enact any laws governing the establishment or practice of religion. The disestablishment of the church resulted in a shift in how the public would access services such as healthcare, education, social welfare, and the arts. Poverty was no longer addressed exclusively by the church; instead, responsibility was transferred to local governments, and voluntary associations came under the governance of state agencies.
The American public then increasingly relied on associations to confront economic and social challenges that had previously been handled by the church. The prominence of associations as the driving force behind the nonprofit sector was heavily influenced by Alexis de Tocqueville's observations in the 1820s. Observing Americans operating effectively within associations, Tocqueville remarked that Americans of all social and economic backgrounds banded together not only to achieve industrial and commercial goals, but also for moral and religious purposes. Tocqueville admired how Americans could organize themselves to work toward a common aim, very often through voluntary action. This dynamic spurred rapid growth of the nonprofit sector through the development of charitable organizations, schools, hospitals, colleges, and other institutions.
"North-South divide, unions, and social reform movements"
"Rise of foundations and shifts in government funding"
"Model Nonprofit Corporation Act and accountability standards"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.