Homelessness in Urban America: Duneier, Jencks, and Crack Cocaine
This paper compares two scholarly perspectives on urban homelessness in America: Mitchell Duneier's ethnographic Sidewalk, which focuses on book vendors in New York City's Greenwich Village, and Christopher Jencks' sociological study The Homeless, which analyzes statistical trends across decades. The paper examines how both authors treat crack cocaine, affordable housing shortages, and racial and economic disenfranchisement as contributing factors to homelessness. It contrasts Duneier's view that homeless individuals develop functional moral cultures and communities with Jencks' argument that homelessness reflects individual estrangement from mainstream social structures, ultimately highlighting the tension between structural and individual explanations for urban poverty.
- Introduction: Two Perspectives on Urban Homelessness: Framing Duneier and Jencks on homelessness
- Duneier's Ethnographic Approach and Street Culture: Participant observation among Greenwich Village vendors
- Moral Order and Community Among Street Vendors: Vendor community, mentorship, and moral agency
- Crack Cocaine, Choice, and the Limits of Duneier's Account: Former addicts, choice, and gender blind spots
- Jencks' Sociological Framework and Statistical Analysis: Statistical trends and crack cocaine as cause
- Conclusion: Structural Forces vs. Individual Estrangement: Individual estrangement versus structural critique
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper maintains a clear comparative structure throughout, consistently returning to the contrast between Duneier's ethnographic, participant-observer approach and Jencks' statistical sociological method.
- It uses direct textual evidence with specific page citations to ground claims about each author's argument, lending credibility and precision to the analysis.
- The paper identifies a genuine intellectual tension — whether homelessness reflects a functional subculture (Duneier) or individual maladaptation to society (Jencks) — and traces it coherently from beginning to end.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative textual analysis across two non-fiction scholarly works. Rather than summarizing each book in isolation, the author weaves the two arguments together thematically — on crack cocaine, moral agency, community formation, and housing costs — allowing the contrast to build argumentative momentum. This technique is especially effective in humanities and social science writing when the goal is to reveal underlying theoretical disagreements between scholars.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by framing the shared subject (urban homelessness) and immediately distinguishing the two authors' methodologies. It then moves through Duneier's key claims — participant observation, vendor community, moral order, and the limits of his focus — before pivoting to Jencks' comparative statistical approach and his conclusions about crack cocaine, marriage decline, and housing costs. The conclusion synthesizes the structural versus individual tension that runs throughout.
Introduction: Two Perspectives on Urban Homelessness
To be homeless in urban America is to live in a state of extreme danger, poverty, and physical precariousness. Both Mitchell Duneier and Christopher Jencks portray a so-called urban underclass, laid low by the legacy of crack cocaine and other corresponding social factors — including depression, disillusionment with societal and conventional familial structures, and the dearth of affordable housing in the urban locations the authors study. While Jencks' book The Homeless takes a more sociological and statistical point of view, arguing that crack cocaine was one of the measurable contributing factors that led to the rise in homelessness, Duneier's book Sidewalk focuses more on street culture in general and relies heavily on anecdotes drawn from the street sellers of books in Greenwich Village, New York City.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.