Hotel Franchising: Advantages and Disadvantages Explored
This paper examines the advantages and disadvantages of franchising hotel operations through a review of industry literature and interviews with two hotel managers in Istanbul, Turkey. Drawing primarily on Rushmore's Hotel Investments Handbook and related hospitality management sources, the study analyzes property lease agreements and management contracts from the perspectives of both property owners and hotel operators. Key themes include financial risk distribution, quality control, brand recognition, operational expertise, and the potential for conflicts of interest. Interview findings from the general manager of Radisson Blu Istanbul Asia and the front office manager of Swissôtel the Bosphorus provide practical, on-the-ground perspectives that complement the theoretical literature.
- Introduction and Background: Research objectives, methodology, and hotel subjects introduced
- Literature Review: Property Lease Agreements: Lease pros and cons for owners and operators
- Literature Review: Management Contracts: Management contract advantages and disadvantages analyzed
- Interview Findings: Istanbul hotel managers share franchise experiences
- Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages: Comparative table of all franchising findings
- Conclusion: Overall assessment of hotel franchising trade-offs
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Combines a structured literature review with original primary research (interviews), giving the argument both theoretical grounding and real-world validation.
- Presents advantages and disadvantages in parallel for both property owners and hotel operators, providing a balanced, multi-stakeholder analysis.
- The summary table at the end consolidates the paper's findings in a scannable format, reinforcing the comparative structure throughout the essay.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of mixed-methods research at an introductory level: it synthesizes secondary literature from industry handbooks and journals, then triangulates those findings with primary qualitative data gathered through structured interviews. This approach shows how practitioner insight can confirm or contextualize theoretical claims without requiring quantitative data.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief introduction identifying its research question and methodology. A substantial literature review follows, organized first around property lease agreements and then management contracts, with advantages and disadvantages enumerated separately for each party. Two interview transcripts provide primary data. The paper closes with a comparative table summarizing all findings and a bibliography of industry and academic sources.
Introduction and Background
The objective of this study is to examine the advantages and disadvantages of franchising hotel operations. To that end, this study conducts an extensive review of the literature in this area of inquiry and supplements it with interviews of two industry professionals in order to determine whether the advantages or disadvantages of hotel franchising predominate.
The first interviewee, Mr. X, is the General Manager of Radisson Blu Istanbul Asia, a well-known hotel in Istanbul, Turkey. The property is owned by a private company, Ant Yapı, and affiliated with the Radisson brand, which is owned by the Rezidor Group. The second interviewee, Mr. Y, is the Front Office Manager of Swissôtel The Bosphorus in Istanbul. That property is owned by the FIBA Group and affiliated with the Swissôtel brand, which is owned by the Raffles Group.
Literature Review: Property Lease Agreements
Chapter 19 of an HVS publication on property management reports that a property lease agreement carries both advantages and disadvantages for both parties involved. According to the literature, hotel management arrangements such as lease agreements offer the property owner several notable benefits.
Advantages for the Property Owner
First, the owner retains title to the property, which provides possession and creates residual value when the term of the lease expires. Second, the financial risk to the owner is minimized, particularly if the hotel company is creditworthy and has guaranteed a minimum rent (Elgin, 2010; Yu, 1999). Third, the owner bears no operational responsibilities (Rushmore, 2002; Xiao, O'Neill, and Wang, 2008).
Disadvantages for the Property Owner
The disadvantages for the property owner are equally significant. First, the operator has little incentive to maintain the property in top condition as the lease term nears its expiration date. For this reason, many hotels are returned to owners in poor physical condition and with a tarnished reputation. Furthermore, because much of the existing business is often diverted to other hotels managed by the operator, few reservations are on the books for the owner or new tenant when the lease ends.
Second, a hotel lease places the owner in a passive position. Under such an agreement, the owner has no input into hotel operations and no control over hotel management. Little can be done if the property is not operated profitably or appropriately unless the terms of the lease are formally violated.
Third, if the hotel is extremely successful, the property owner does not participate in the financial rewards to the extent that an owner-operator would. The potential for profit is therefore somewhat limited (Rushmore, 2002; Wickford, 2012).
Fourth, leases are difficult to terminate. Unlike a management contract, which is an agency agreement, a lease creates an encumbrance on the real estate that gives the tenant specific rights of possession (Rushmore, 2002).
Advantages for the Hotel Operator
There are several advantages in a property lease agreement for the hotel operator. One of the most significant is that a higher chance of success exists "since a proven business formula is in place. The products, services and business operations have already been established" (Business Mart, 2012). Additional advantages include the following:
First, the operator has total control of the hotel during the term of the lease, with very few approvals required from ownership. Second, a profitable hotel creates a leasehold value that can sometimes be mortgaged by the operator. If the terms of the lease permit a transfer, the leasehold value can also be realized through a sale. Third, the upside profit created by a successful hotel benefits solely the operator, who receives whatever money remains after operating expenses and lease rental have been paid (Rushmore, 2002).
Disadvantages for the Hotel Operator
The disadvantages for a hotel operator under a lease agreement are also notable. First, the operator loses possession of the property when the lease term expires, and the leasehold interest loses its value as that term approaches. Second, the financial risks of operating the hotel are borne by the hotel company; the operator must therefore have a net worth sufficient to absorb that exposure. Third, leasehold interests create contingent liabilities on corporate balance sheets that can adversely affect the value of stock in publicly traded companies. Because of the requirements for real estate investment trusts, however, hotel operating leases are sometimes a necessity (Rushmore, 2002).
References
Sealover, E. (2010). Independent hotels struggle against chains, reward programs. The Business Journal.
Wolff, C. (2009). Taking an independent approach. Hotel News Now.
International chains hotel, chains hotel, or independent? (2012). Hotel and Resort Management.
Mayock, P. (2011). Independents team up with brands. Inn Development Management.
Rushmore, S. (2002). Hotel investments handbook. Chapter 12: Franchise agreements and management. HVS.
Advantages & disadvantages of owning a franchise. (2012). Business Mart.
Lorette, K. (n.d.). Owning and operating a franchise hotel 101. Small Business.
Wickford, H. (2010). Hotel franchise disadvantages. eHow Money.
Adrian. (2010). Advantages and disadvantages of a franchise. The Company Warehouse.
Elgin, J. (2007). Are bigger franchises better? Entrepreneur.
Yu, L. (2002). The international hospitality business: Management and operations. Psychology Press.
Xiao, Q., O'Neill, J. W., & Wang, H. (2008). International hotel development: A study of potential franchisees in China. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 27, 325–336.
Xiao, S. (2002). Ramada International: Expanding with franchising.
Walsh, J. P. (2004). Companies extend brands' development throughout the world. Hotel and Motel Management.
Wang, Q. (2002/2005). Development opportunities and strategies of the economy hotel segment.
Zhang, Z. (2003). Rising war among Chinese chain hotels.
Advantages and disadvantages of a franchisor. (2012). StartupBizHub.
Brooke, B. (2012). Benefits outweigh risks in franchising. Bob Brooke Communications.
Song, K. C. (2012). The growth strategies of hotel chains: Best business practices by leading companies. Routledge.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.