Legislative Advocacy Against H.R. 890 and TANF Work Requirements
This paper presents a legislative advocacy position opposing H.R. 890, the Preserving the Welfare Work Requirement and TANF Extension Act of 2013, which would prohibit the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services from granting Section 1115 waivers of TANF mandatory work requirements. The paper argues that HHS waivers are a lawful and necessary mechanism for testing innovative employment strategies for needy families. It outlines a coalition-building approach involving the Administration for Children and Families and university-based model programs, proposes an op-ed framing of current TANF policy as overly restrictive, describes a legislator-targeted advocacy gimmick, and concludes with a one-page brief summarizing the opposition position.
- Introduction and Coalition Building: Opposition stance on H.R. 890 introduced
- Background of H.R. 890: Bill origins, HHS memorandum, and Section 1115 authority
- Agency Affiliations and Coalition Building: ACF and university partners as coalition allies
- Op-Ed: The Case Against Restrictive TANF Policy: TANF rules criticized as rigid and outdated
- Advocacy Gimmick for Legislative Attention: Box-based mailer gimmick targeting legislators
- One-Page Brief and Conclusion: Summary brief opposing H.R. 890 and final argument
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its opposition in statutory authority, specifically citing Section 1115 of the Social Security Act and Section 407, which anchors the advocacy argument in legal legitimacy rather than purely ideological claims.
- Moves through multiple advocacy formats — background analysis, op-ed, gimmick design, and a one-page brief — demonstrating how a single policy position can be communicated to different audiences using different vehicles.
- Directly quotes the HHS Information Memorandum language that triggered conservative opposition, allowing the reader to evaluate the political controversy in context.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates multi-format legislative advocacy writing, a core skill in social work policy practice. By presenting the same position as a formal background analysis, an op-ed, a physical gimmick concept, and a summary brief, it shows how policy advocates must tailor messaging to different stakeholder audiences while maintaining a consistent evidentiary foundation.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into three labeled sections plus a conclusion. Section One covers the bill's background and coalition-building strategy. Section Two presents the op-ed argument and the advocacy gimmick. Section Three delivers a condensed one-page brief. The conclusion synthesizes the opposition stance. This structure mirrors real-world legislative advocacy packages, where multiple communication tools are assembled around a single policy position.
Introduction and Coalition Building
H.R. 890 is a bill to prohibit the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) from granting a waiver relating to compliance with the work requirements of the provisions of welfare. The most recent bill title is the Preserving the Welfare Work Requirement and TANF Extension Act of 2013. This paper stands in opposition to this bill and provides a detailed basis for that position in the following discussion. In brief, the opposition to H.R. 890 is derived from the endorsement that more effective ways to meet TANF goals are and can be developed and effectively implemented, and that much of the current legislation derives from a deeply ingrained suspicion of the poor and of needy families — a suspicion this nation must outgrow in order to be truly innovative and to effectively achieve the honorable objectives of TANF.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.