Child Support Distribution Act: H.R. 4678 and S. 918 Analysis
This paper examines the Child Support Distribution Act, introduced in the U.S. House as H.R. 4678 in 2000 and in the Senate as S. 918 in 2001. It outlines the bill's primary provisions, including redistributing child support payments to prioritize mothers and children over state reimbursement, funding skills-training programs for low-income fathers, and promoting marriage. The paper traces the bill's legislative history from its bipartisan House passage to its stalling in the Senate Committee on Finance, discusses the main points of opposition regarding church-state separation and privacy rights, and evaluates feminist critiques raised by the National Organization for Women. The paper concludes by assessing the bill's prospects for future Senate consideration.
- Introduction and Background: Social context and need for child support reform
- Key Provisions of the Child Support Distribution Act: Bill's main provisions for families and fathers
- Legislative History in the House: Bipartisan passage of H.R. 4678 in House
- Opposition and Points of Debate: Church-state and privacy objections to the bill
- The Senate Version and Its Stalling: S. 918 introduced but never debated in Senate
- Criticisms and Concerns: NOW's warnings about custody and women's rights
- Conclusion and Future Prospects: Bill's stalling and chances for future debate
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper traces a specific piece of legislation from introduction through committee, floor debate, and Senate stalling, providing a clear and organized legislative narrative.
- It balances advocacy for the bill's benefits with acknowledgment of legitimate criticisms, including constitutional concerns and feminist objections from the National Organization for Women.
- Concrete figures — such as the $2.6 billion collected in 1998 and the $282 million actually passed to families — give the policy analysis factual grounding.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates policy analysis through legislative tracking: it identifies a bill, explains its provisions in plain terms, follows its path through Congress, and evaluates the arguments for and against it. This approach — combining statutory summary with stakeholder critique — is a standard method in public policy writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing the social problem (inadequate child support for low-income families), then describes the bill's provisions, moves through its House history and floor debates, covers the Senate version and its failure to advance, addresses feminist and constitutional criticisms, and closes with a brief forward-looking assessment of the bill's prospects. This problem-to-solution-to-evaluation arc is logical and easy to follow.
Introduction and Background
The Child Support Distribution Act of 2000 (H.R. 4678) overwhelmingly passed the House of Representatives on September 7, 2000, by a vote of 405 to 18. A similar measure, the Child Support Distribution Act of 2001 (S. 918), was introduced in the Senate's 107th session but never came to a floor debate.
The need for better enforcement of child support laws was evident in a recent survey showing that fewer than one-fifth of inner-city children born to single teenage mothers receive child support from their fathers. In fact, half of these children never see their fathers at all. Many fathers are unable to provide support because they are unemployed and lack marketable skills. As a result, a great majority of these teenage mothers depend on welfare to support their children (Moore).
Works Cited
Clinton, William J. "Statement on House of Representatives Action on the Child Support Distribution Act." Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents; Washington; Sep. 11, 2000: 2020.
Erickson, Jan. "Child Support Linked with Fathers' Rights Bill." National NOW Times; Washington; Winter 2001: 11.
"House Okays Bill to Send Child Support to Parents." Chicago Tribune, 8 September 2000: 12.
Moore, Melissa. "Children of Young Disadvantaged Women Are Unlikely to Receive Consistent Support from Their Fathers." Family Planning Perspectives; New York; Nov./Dec. 1998: 291–292.
United States. Cong. House of Representatives. 107th Congress. H.R. 4678. Child Support Distribution Act of 2001. [Introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives; 1 May 2001]. Thomas Federal Legislation Database, 106th Congress. Viewed 20 November 2002.
United States. Cong. Senate. 107th Congress. S. 918. Child Support Distribution Act of 2001. [Introduced in the U.S. Senate; 8 September 2001]. Thomas Federal Legislation Database, 106th Congress. Viewed 20 November 2002.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.