This essay analyzes Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life through the lens of competing definitions of wealth and personal success. By contrasting George Bailey's character-driven life with Mr. Potter's purely monetary worldview, the paper explores how community values, selflessness, and human connection constitute genuine richness. The essay traces key moments in George's story — his sacrificed dreams, his reluctant stewardship of Bailey Savings and Loan, and his ultimate recognition by the townspeople — to argue that, by the film's own moral logic, George is indeed "the richest man in town." It also briefly considers whether those standards translate to contemporary society.
In It's a Wonderful Life, the main character George hears a bell ringing at the end of the movie, smiles at the daughter he lovingly holds in his arms, and agrees with her statement that "an angel got his wings." The movie ends with a crescendo of music that would bring tears to the most cold-hearted viewer. George has lived the good life. He is raising a family, has friends and colleagues who admire and look up to him, and all it took for him to realize what he had was an angel to show him the way. That is what the movie implies — whether the same standards hold true in today's society is an entirely different question.
There are numerous examples throughout the film of what was considered a rich man during George's time, and many of those examples stand in sharp contrast to what is considered rich by many people today. Harry Bailey, George's brother, toasts George with the statement: "A toast to my big brother George: the richest man in town." He does so after witnessing the love and respect that the townspeople feel for George. As the film makes clear from its very first scenes, however, George himself does not initially share that assessment of his own life.
Before that moment of recognition takes place, George believes his life is one filled with regrets, unfulfilled dreams, and lost hope. He had planned to "shake off the dirt of this one-horse town and build bridges and buildings." Instead, he finds himself stuck — not just once but twice — caring for his father's creation, Bailey Savings and Loan.
The first time George is prevented from leaving Bedford Falls is when he is set to attend college, but must postpone those plans after his father suffers a stroke and passes away. The Savings and Loan board votes him in as Executive Secretary in order to keep Mr. Potter from shutting down the business. Much of the board's reasoning rests on George's rebuttal to Potter's attempt to close the institution. George tells Potter: "To you, a warped, frustrated old man, they're cattle. Well, in my book, he died a much richer man than you'll ever be." This is a telling rebuttal — George ultimately plays the exact same role as his father, yet he does not yet realize how rich he himself is. He acquiesces to the board's wishes and stays on for the next four years.
His next opportunity to pursue his dreams arrives when his brother Harry returns from college, supposedly to take over the Savings and Loan after graduation. Upon picking Harry up at the train station, George learns a surprise: Harry is not only married, but his wife's father has offered him a research position with his firm. Once again, George is trapped in Bedford Falls. This weighs heavily on him throughout the entire film. He never achieves the ambitious dreams of his youth; instead, he marries Mary and they begin a family together.
One of the defining moments of the film is when George is judged by Mr. Potter. Potter dismisses George as a "miserable clerk" with "no securities, no stocks, no bonds — nothing but a miserable $500 equity life insurance policy." To Potter, who judges individuals solely by their net worth, George is a "warped, frustrated young man." In what Potter clearly intends as the ultimate insult, he tells George: "You're worth more dead than alive."
The conundrum, then, is who is right. Is it Mr. Potter, who believes that men are only worth whatever monetary value they have accumulated? Or is it George, who has lived a wonderful life filled with friends, family, and the respect of nearly the entire community?
"Clarence defines richness through human connection"
"George's friends rally to prove his worth"
Clarence is right, which is why George has lived a wonderful life — a life defined not by financial accumulation but by the depth of his relationships and the breadth of his sacrifice. Harry's toast, offered at the film's emotional peak, is not mere sentiment. It is the community's verdict, delivered collectively, that George Bailey's way of living represents the truest form of wealth. Whether those same standards resonate in contemporary society, where net worth and material success are so frequently used to measure a person's value, remains an open and important question — but within the world of Bedford Falls, there is no doubt that George is, in every meaningful sense, the richest man in town.
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.