This paper examines Kurt Cobain's biography, from his rise to fame as Nirvana's lead singer to his suicide in 1994. Using frameworks from addiction and change theory, the paper maps Cobain's substance abuse progression through stages of change (precontemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance) and identifies warning signs that might have informed an intervention. The paper analyzes how professional and personal pressures, combined with his heroin addiction, contributed to his death and explores how a relapse prevention treatment plan grounded in the stages of change model could have potentially altered his trajectory. The conclusion suggests that while Cobain recognized his addiction problem and sought rehabilitation, full-blown heroin dependence ultimately overcame his stated commitment to recovery.
Kurt Cobain was born on February 20, 1967, in Aberdeen, Washington. According to one biographer, "Kurt Cobain dragged (screaming) the Alternative/Grunge Rock revolution into the American home" (Dean, 2003). With his Seattle-based band, Nirvana—a Buddhist term meaning to "extinguish desire"—Cobain released "Smells Like Teen Spirit" in December 1991, which was subsequently voted the No. 1 Song of the 1990s in an October 2000 VH-1 poll. A string of other major recording hits, including "Come As You Are" and the "Nevermind" album, followed, with sales exceeding 10 million copies.
The band members of Nirvana included Cobain on guitar with his "strident, angst-glutted, and tormented vocal wail," Chris Novoselic on bass, guitarist Jason Everman, and drummers Chad Channing and Dave Grohl, all hailing from Aberdeen, Washington—the most overcast city in the contiguous United States. In 1992, Cobain married Courtney Love, soon had a baby daughter, and his performing career seemed enormously promising. As Dean notes, "Cobain was a young man with great promise, a charismatic personality, and a brilliant and ironic wit" (p. 455).
Following a suicide watch after one unsuccessful attempt, Cobain committed suicide with a self-inflicted gunshot on April 8, 1994, at age 27 in his Seattle home. According to Dean (2003), "A whole musical movement mourned its leader and spokesman" (p. 455). However, not all observers shared this view. For instance, Karas (1994) reports that "Many fans believed Cobain was less an icon for his generation and more an addict who tried to beat his depression with heroin and abandoned a young daughter" (p. 10).
Despite this unsympathetic view, the majority of journalists wrote about Cobain's death in reverent terms following his suicide and widely acknowledged his contributions to the grunge musical genre and his talent as a performer. These mixed views are not surprising, given that although he had much going for him, his personal life and substance abuse were sources of major concern. As Ali (2002) points out, "Anyone who thought Cobain was an easy read probably wasn't a Nirvana fan" (p. 60). Despite not being "an easy read," Cobain did provide several warning signs characteristic of suicide. For example, Ali notes that Cobain wrote in his journal that "Hope I die before I turn into Pete Townshend" and adds that "The tragedy is, he got his wish" (2002, p. 60). These warning signs could have been used to develop an intervention that might have prevented his death.
Although the specific reasons for any individual suicide are unique, several factors in Cobain's background are salient with respect to his suicide in 1994. Cobain's hometown, Aberdeen, Washington, has the nation's highest suicide rate, which is attributed in large part to the gloomy atmosphere created by persistent rain and 300 cloudy days each year. Despite his wealth and seeming success, some biographers maintain that Cobain faced significant professional challenges and dilemmas that may have contributed to his suicide.
For instance, Burnett (1995) reports that "Cobain hated the fact that frat boys were cranking his songs at kegger parties. These were the sort of timeless, bullying nobodies who would have pummeled the hell out of him and his friends in high school for being weird" (p. 215). Moreover, Cobain's recording and performance success created another professional dilemma. As Burnett (1995) suggests, "It was an impossible tightrope: writing angstful music when he was a millionaire, trying to write songs which couldn't be co-opted by corporate rock and teeny-boppers, while at the same time avoiding these very pretensions" (p. 215).
Although some observers were alarmed by Cobain's mental status—particularly in view of his substance abuse and following his failed suicide attempt—others maintained that he was a well-adjusted young man, especially given his celebrity status. As Hansen (2012) notes, "Some journalists focused on his personal problems and anxieties that led very neatly to a suicide, while others wrote that Cobain was happy and looking to his future" (p. 267). It is noteworthy that some observers believed Cobain was far more humble about his success than outward appearances might suggest. As Ali (2002) points out, "Cobain never thought he was worth as much as we did" (p. 60).
Despite these mixed views, Cobain's "journey through the stages of change to addiction"—from first being disinterested to becoming involved and finally becoming addicted—can be readily understood through addiction and change frameworks. According to contemporary addiction theory, "The road to addiction begins with an individual's exposure to the behavior and with personal views about the value of engaging in the behavior" (Chapter 4, p. 68). Given the impossible tightrope confronting Cobain in his personal and professional lives, the phases of his addictive behavior can be linked to these challenges and his attempt to respond through substance abuse. The same source notes that "Risk factors represent problems and issues in various areas of functioning that interact with thinking about and engaging in the addictive behavior" (p. 69).
This observation is congruent with a letter Cobain wrote to his fans in 1992 following a stay in a rehabilitation center. The letter was not released until 2002, eight years after his death. In it, Cobain explained his use of heroin to treat an uncomfortable stomach condition:
So after protein drinks, becoming a vegetarian, exercise, stopping smoking, and doctor after doctor I decided to relieve my pain with small doses of heroine for a walloping 3 whole weeks. It served as a band-aid for a while but then the pain came back so I quit. It was a stupid thing to do and I'll never do it again and I feel real sorry for anyone who thinks they can use heroine as a medicine because um, duh, it don't work. (cited in Inside Cobain's Heroin Letter Never Sent, 2002, para. 4)
Unfortunately, Cobain's addiction to heroin overcame his stated commitment. Large amounts of the drug were found in his system following his suicide. Furthermore, noticeably absent from analyses concerning Cobain's death are mentions of the demands of fatherhood on young men and the enormous pressures this creates in their lives. Despite his wealth, it is reasonable to suggest that Cobain experienced these types of problems in ways that contributed to his substance-abusing behaviors.
Although every situation is different, people tend to go through five stages of change as they attempt to resolve their addiction. These stages, along with corresponding tasks and goals for each, are summarized in the following framework:
Precontemplation: The stage in which there is little or no consideration of change of the current pattern of behavior in the foreseeable future. Tasks include increasing awareness of the need for change, increasing concern about the current pattern of behavior, and envisioning the possibility of change. The goal is serious consideration of change for this behavior.
Contemplation: The stage wherein the individual examines the current pattern of behavior and the potential for change in a risk-reward analysis. Tasks include analysis of the pros and cons of the current behavior and the costs and benefits of change, along with decision-making. The goal is a considered evaluation that leads to a decision to change.
Preparation: The stage in which the individual makes a commitment to take action to change the behavior pattern and develops a plan and strategy for change. Tasks include increasing commitment and creating a change plan. The goal is an action plan to be implemented in the near future.
Action: The stage in which the individual implements the plan and takes steps to change the current behavior pattern. Tasks include implementing strategies for change, revising the plan as needed, and sustaining commitment in face of difficulties. The goal is successful action for changing the current pattern, with a new pattern of behavior established for a significant period (3-6 months).
Maintenance: The stage wherein the new behavior pattern is sustained for an extended period of time and is consolidated into the lifestyle of the individual. Tasks include sustaining change over time and across a wide range of situations, integrating the behavior into the person's life, and avoiding slips and relapses. The goal is long-term sustained change of the old pattern and establishment of a new pattern of behavior.
The contents of Cobain's unpublished letter and the fact that he sought rehabilitation for his addiction prior to his suicide suggest that he had reached the contemplation and preparation stages but never succeeded in moving beyond them. His 1992 letter demonstrates contemplation—he recognized the problem and acknowledged the need for change. However, his actions indicate he remained trapped in preparation, unable to transition to the action stage where sustained behavioral change would occur.
In retrospect, it is easy to predict Cobain's suicide given that his suicide note included the line "It's better to burn out than to fade away" (taken from Neil Young's "Hey Hey, My, My (Into the Black)") and he made it clear that he intended to continue his pattern of behavior irrespective of his stated commitments to stop using heroin. In his 1992 unpublished letter, Cobain advised that those who counseled him to "not freak out and get healthy" were not going to succeed. As Cobain explained:
Gee I wish it was as easy as that but, honestly I didn't want all this attention but I'm not freaked out which is something a lot of people would like to see. It's an entertaining thought to watch a rock figure who's public domain mentally self destruct. But I'm sorry friends I'll have to decline. (cited in Inside Cobain's Heroin Letter Never Sent, 2002, para. 5)
Therefore, an effective intervention for Cobain would have required developing an action plan that included a concrete approach for changing his substance-abusing behavior patterns and a maintenance plan that reinforced his change in behaviors through periods of difficulty and challenge.
"Why standard rehabilitation failed Cobain"
The research showed that Kurt Cobain was the lead singer and guitarist in the grunge band Nirvana, who skyrocketed to fame by the time of his suicide in 1994. The research also showed that despite mixed views about his mental status during his lifetime, there were sufficient indicators of his imminent suicide to compel others to take action to help him. Likewise, Cobain recognized that he had a problem with heroin and attempted to solve it through rehabilitation. Despite this assistance, and due in large part to his background and lifestyle, in the final analysis it is reasonable to conclude that Cobain's full-blown addiction to heroin was also responsible for his taking his own life, leaving legions of Nirvana fans to lament yet another rock star loss to suicide.
You’re 94% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.