This paper examines three classic short stories through a thematic lens. Katherine Mansfield's "Miss Brill" is analyzed for its portrayal of loneliness and estrangement, focusing on the protagonist's failed attempts at social connection and the symbolic significance of her coat. Ernest Hemingway's "Hills Like White Elephants" is read as a study in manipulation, tracing the persuasion techniques the American uses to pressure his girlfriend into an operation. Finally, Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" is explored as a commentary on tradition, ritual, and civilization, culminating in the shocking revelation of the village's annual human sacrifice.
"Miss Brill" is a story about loneliness and estrangement. Miss Brill is an old woman who is out of touch with her times but who, at the same time, wants to integrate, communicate, and interact with the people around her. She wants to go out, meet with them, and talk with them, but nobody seems willing to do that, and towards the end of the story, they become plainly rude about her appearance.
The first theme to consider in view of this thesis is the fact that Miss Brill longs for interaction with others, something that supports the idea that she is, otherwise, very lonely. She appreciates the fact that there are more people out that afternoon than usual, giving her better chances of finding someone to talk to: "there were a number of people out this afternoon, far more than last Sunday" (Mansfield, 1).
Second, her willingness to interact and communicate is supported by the number of people she tries to talk to, or whose conversations she would like to listen in on. From the young couple at the end to the man with gray hair who lights a cigarette, she wants to be a part of all of their worlds — and everybody avoids her.
Finally, her estrangement is reinforced by the symbolism of her coat, a motif that reflects her being out of place in the world. The coat could be read as a stand-in for Miss Brill herself: an old, out-of-place object that cannot find its footing in the real world or in the new environment around her.
"Hills Like White Elephants" is a story about manipulation and persuasion. The American tries to convince his girlfriend that she should have an operation, although it remains unclear exactly what kind of operation this is — whether it is a simple procedure or something more significant. The operation is widely understood to represent an abortion, given the symbolism woven throughout the text. He employs a diverse array of persuasion techniques to convince her to go through with it.
One of these techniques is to reverse his position and tell her that she does not need to have the operation if she doesn't want to. This functions as a persuasion technique precisely because she has clearly argued throughout the story that she does not want to. Another psychological lever he uses is his declaration of love, claiming he cares deeply for her and always will: "I love you now, you know I love you" (Hemingway, 1). By invoking their emotional bond, he applies pressure that goes beyond rational argument.
"Lottery as ritual, tradition, and dark symbol"
Taken together, these three stories demonstrate how short fiction can use tightly focused themes — loneliness, manipulation, and tradition — to illuminate deeper truths about human behavior and society. Whether through the quiet despair of Miss Brill, the subtle coercion in Hemingway's dialogue, or the communal violence concealed beneath Jackson's ordinary village setting, each story uses its central theme to expose something unsettling about the way people relate to one another and to the worlds they inhabit.
You’re 63% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.