M. Butterfly: Orientalism, Stereotypes, and Gender Identity
This essay analyzes David Henry Hwang's play M. Butterfly, focusing on how the protagonist Gallimard's deeply held Orientalist stereotypes allow him to sustain a long-term relationship with a Chinese spy he believes to be a woman. Drawing on Edward Said's concept of Orientalism and Puccini's opera Madame Butterfly, the essay examines how Gallimard's fantasy of the submissive Asian woman enables his self-deception, how Song Liling exploits that fantasy, and how the play ultimately reverses conventional gender and power roles. The essay argues that Gallimard's blind acceptance of a false stereotype leads to his personal and professional ruin, revealing him as the true "Butterfly" of the story.
- Introduction: Hwang's Premise and Gallimard's Worldview: Gallimard's lifelong desire for submissive women
- Orientalism and the Stereotype of the Asian Woman: Said's Orientalism applied to Gallimard's fantasy
- Madame Butterfly as Myth and Mirror: Puccini opera as template for East-West stereotyping
- Song Liling and the Deconstruction of the Butterfly Fantasy: Song exploits and critiques the Butterfly myth
- The Reversal: Gallimard as Butterfly: Gallimard revealed as the true Butterfly figure
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay builds its argument systematically, moving from character motivation to cultural theory to dramatic irony, keeping the reader oriented at each step.
- It integrates direct quotations from the play effectively, letting Gallimard and Song speak for themselves rather than relying solely on paraphrase.
- The paper grounds its literary analysis in Edward Said's theoretical framework, giving the reading intellectual depth beyond plot summary.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates how to deploy a theoretical lens — here, Said's concept of Orientalism — to illuminate a literary text. Rather than simply describing what happens in the play, the writer uses Orientalism as a framework to explain why Gallimard believes what he believes, connecting individual psychology to broader cultural and political power structures.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by establishing Gallimard's character and his attraction to an idealized Asian femininity. It then introduces Said's Orientalism to name the cultural mechanism at work. The Puccini opera is examined as the specific myth Gallimard internalizes. Song Liling's role as both critic and performer of that myth is then analyzed. The essay closes by reversing the Butterfly metaphor, arguing that Gallimard — not Song — is the submissive figure destroyed by illusion.
Introduction: Hwang's Premise and Gallimard's Worldview
David Henry Hwang's play M. Butterfly was based on a true story about a French diplomat who carried on a long-term relationship with a Chinese spy he believed was a woman, but who was really a man. This basic story serves as the outline for Hwang's examination of the key questions people asked when the story first broke: Did he really not know? How is this possible? In the play, Gallimard believes that Song is a woman because he holds deep stereotypes about the Oriental; he identifies with Pinkerton of the Puccini opera as a result. When Song's true identity is revealed, Gallimard recognizes that his blind acceptance of a false stereotype has led him to ruin and to the diminishment of his experience and character — and that he is, in fact, the Butterfly in the story.
Gallimard, the diplomat, is presented as a man who has waited his whole life for a beautiful woman "who would lay down for you" (Hwang 505). He seems to elevate Asian women, but in fact he sees them as inferior, which is one reason he is attracted to Song, as he himself reveals: "Did you hear the way she talked about Western women? Much differently than the first night. She does — she does feel inferior to them — and to me" (Hwang 508). He is also driven by guilt as he pursues what he regards as an inferior creature: "If there was a God, surely he would punish me now. I had finally gained power over a beautiful woman, only to abuse it cruelly" (Hwang 510). When he is promoted to the position of vice-consul, he goes to Song and explicitly links his view of her with the opera, asking if she is his Butterfly.
The relationship between the two satisfies Gallimard because he attributes Song's unwillingness to undress or allow certain intimacies to her Asian background and culture. The stereotype he holds of Asian women is that they are always demure, refined, restrained, and shy. This is one reason he has been drawn to these women in the first place — his vision of them gives him the power he never feels he has with a Caucasian woman. In his own culture, women are more assertive and individual, so he seeks a woman who is very different, which conforms to the stereotype he has of Asian women. He tells her that "we will go very, very slowly" (Hwang 512).
Works Cited
"Afterword." 2007. April 5, 2007.
Cheng, Anne Anlin. The Melancholy of Race. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000.
"Henry David Wang — Profile of a Playwright." University News Service (19 June 1995).
Hwang, David Henry. M. Butterfly. In Plays for the Theatre, Oscar G. Brockett (ed.), 492–536. New York: Harcourt Brace College Publishers, 1996.
Jones, Chad. "TheatreWorks' 'M Butterfly' still has wings." Oakland Tribune (29 Aug 2006). April 3, 2007. http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4176/is_20060829/ai_n16694081.
Rich, Frank. "'M. Butterfly,' a Story of a Strange Love, Conflict and Betrayal." New York Times (21 March 1988). April 4, 2007.
Said, Edward. Orientalism. New York: Penguin, 2003.
Shin, Andrew. "Projected Bodies in David Henry Hwang's M. Butterfly and Golden Gate — Critical Essay." Melus (Spring 2002). April 4, 2007. http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2278/is_1_27/ai_89929579.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.