John McCain as the Stronger Candidate: Experience Over Idealism
This essay compares John McCain and Barack Obama as presidential candidates, arguing that McCain's decades of military and political experience, demonstrated courage, and independent judgment outweigh Obama's youth and idealism. The author uses a metaphor of cake and icing to frame substance over style, examines McCain's military background and prisoner-of-war experience, discusses his reputation as a "maverick" willing to oppose his party, and contrasts the VP choices of both candidates as evidence of their respective leadership philosophies. The essay concludes that McCain's proven ability to navigate complex issues and take calculated risks demonstrates superior qualification for the presidency.
- Introduction: Substance Over Style: Cake-and-icing metaphor frames McCain over Obama
- McCain's Military Background and Experience: War service and POW experience build character
- McCain as a Political Maverick: Willingness to oppose party shows true strength
- Leadership and Decision-Making: Political experience and measured judgment versus emotion
- Conclusion: The Stronger Choice: VP selection reveals leadership philosophy and vision
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Opens with a memorable extended metaphor (cake and icing) that clearly frames the argument: substance matters more than style or glamour.
- Uses concrete evidence to support claims, including McCain's military service, his prisoner-of-war experience, and a direct quote from McCain responding to accusations of racism.
- Acknowledges counterarguments implicitly—explaining why McCain appears less outspoken than Obama (measured judgment, not weakness) and why his VP choice of an unknown candidate actually demonstrates strength rather than poor judgment.
- Maintains a consistent, persuasive tone throughout while addressing reader uncertainty about candidate selection.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The essay employs comparative analysis paired with symbolic reasoning. Rather than presenting a list of McCain's accomplishments, the author uses an extended metaphor to establish a evaluative framework, then applies that framework to interpret specific facts (military background, political history, VP selection). This technique moves the reader beyond surface-level comparison toward a principled basis for judgment.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with introduction and metaphor, then builds an argument in three stages: (1) McCain's military credibility and war experience, (2) his independence within the Republican party, and (3) his demonstrated wisdom in staffing decisions. Each section provides specific evidence or anecdotes. The conclusion ties all elements back to the central claim that experience and character trump glamour and idealism.
Introduction: Substance Over Style
In the battle between John McCain and Barack Obama, you are likely to feel rather confused. On one hand, you have a young man with a touch of glamour, and on the other, a man who may not be glamorous but has years of political experience behind him. For those who are die-hard Democrats or Republicans, the choice is easy, but for those in between the two extremes, making a decision is definitely not straightforward.
My grandfather once gave me a piece of advice that has helped me on many occasions: "Darling, you may love the icing, but it's the cake that really matters." Over the years, I have come to the conclusion that fluff is always just that—fluff—and it cannot replace the real thing. The icing on the cake may taste great and look beautiful, but it is the cake below that really counts. You can buy cake without icing, but you will not buy icing without the cake.
This metaphor makes it clear who the stronger choice is between McCain and Obama. Obama is young with all his youthful idealism and fancy dreams, but McCain has solid experience behind him that prevents him from making false promises or showing people dreams they cannot realize. While Obama may appear more charismatic, McCain's substance provides a more reliable foundation for leadership.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.