Medicare and Medicaid: History, Populations, and APRN Roles
This paper provides an overview of Medicare and Medicaid, tracing their political origins from early 20th-century health insurance proposals through the landmark Social Security Amendment of 1965. It examines the populations each program serves, including low-income individuals, the elderly, disabled persons, and children. The paper then analyzes Virginia's Medicaid expansion efforts before considering arguments made by states that resist expansion, including concerns about care quality, cost shifting, and the need for state-level policy flexibility. The paper concludes by reflecting on the role of Advanced Practice Registered Nurses in advocating for equitable, high-quality care within these programs.
- A Brief History of Medicaid and Medicare: Political origins from Roosevelt through Johnson's 1965 law
- Populations These Programs Are Intended to Serve: Elderly, disabled, low-income, children, and pregnant women
- States That Have Expanded Medicaid: Virginia's Medicaid expansion efforts and legislative battles
- Reasons Why States Opt Not to Expand Medicaid: Cost, care quality, and need for state-level flexibility
- The Role of the Advanced Practice Registered Nurse: APRNs advocating for reform and equitable patient care
- References: Cited sources supporting the paper's claims
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its policy analysis in historical context, tracing the long legislative struggle from Theodore Roosevelt through Lyndon Johnson's 1965 signing — giving readers a clear sense of why these programs exist.
- It balances descriptive content (program history and populations served) with evaluative content (arguments for and against expansion), providing a rounded view of a contested policy issue.
- The personal reflection on the APRN role ties the abstract policy discussion to professional practice, grounding the argument in real-world nursing responsibilities.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses structured policy analysis: it introduces background, defines beneficiary populations, presents a case study (Virginia), and then systematically addresses counterarguments to expansion. This "claim and counterargument" structure is a useful undergraduate technique for health policy writing, demonstrating that the author understands multiple stakeholder perspectives.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into five substantive sections plus a reference list. It opens with historical background, moves to program eligibility, narrows to a state-level case study, examines opposition arguments, and closes with a professional role reflection. Each section builds logically on the last, moving from macro (national history) to micro (individual nursing practice).
A Brief History of Medicaid and Medicare
The idea of a national health insurance plan gained political momentum in the first part of the 20th century. President Theodore Roosevelt was among the pioneers in making health insurance a campaign issue. The Second New Deal, crafted by President Franklin D. Roosevelt, involved incorporating the Social Security program into federal law (Piatak, 2015). The Act aimed to reduce the extent to which factors such as poverty, old age, widowhood, and children without known fathers were treated as societal dangers. The New Deal had a significant portion of its content struck down by the Supreme Court, either on grounds of unconstitutionality or because the provisions fell outside federal jurisdiction. Acts such as the National Industrial Recovery Act and the Agricultural Adjustment Act were among those ordered removed.
The medical insurance scheme drafted by President Roosevelt and his team was similarly invalidated. Later, President Truman attempted to incorporate a social health scheme into his government programs but also failed. Earlier efforts include a 1915 proposal in which the American Association for Labor Legislation presented a health insurance bill before state legislatures — an effort that also failed (Piatak, 2015). Nevertheless, in 1965, the Social Security Amendment Bill was passed under President Lyndon Johnson, clearing both the House and the Senate with 307 and 70 votes respectively. The Act of 1965 had two parts, which were later named Medicaid and Medicare (Piatak, 2015). Johnson was notably modest at the signing ceremony, crediting former President Truman for initiating the process.
Populations These Programs Are Intended to Serve
President Lyndon Johnson formally signed the Medicaid and Medicare implementation bill into law on July 30, 1965. Initially, the Medicare segment comprised Part A, covering hospital insurance, and Part B, covering medical care insurance — together forming what is known as Original Medicare. Both parts were designed to help Americans manage healthcare costs. Over the years, Congress has reviewed and amended the plan to make it accessible to more Americans. Medicare extended its coverage in 1972 to include people with disabilities, patients with end-stage renal disease, and all individuals aged 65 and above (Piatak, 2015).
Medicaid has also made significant strides over time in assisting American citizens in need of healthcare. Initially focused solely on individuals requiring financial assistance, the program has evolved to include people with disabilities, those with low income, pregnant women, and individuals requiring long-term care. In 1997, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) was established, providing preventive healthcare to approximately 11 million uninsured children. All 50 states, the District of Columbia, and U.S. territories offer CHIP health plans.
The Medicare Modernization Act (MMA) of 2003 represented the most significant change to the Medicare program in nearly four decades. Private-sector health plans approved by Medicare were designated Medicare Advantage, or Part C. Medicare Part D was also added through the MMA as an optional prescription drug benefit. The Affordable Care Act (ACA), enacted in 2010, established the Health Insurance Marketplace — a centralized platform through which consumers could apply for and enroll in private insurance plans across a broad spectrum (Salmond & Echevarria, 2017).
States That Have Expanded Medicaid
Virginia has continued to expand Medicaid in order to make it accessible to more residents. Terry McAuliffe (D), the former governor, was instrumental in advancing Medicaid expansion in the state. However, in June 2014, the state legislature failed to include the expansion program in its budget (Advisory Board, 2018). Subsequently, a number of lawmakers reversed their opposition to the expansion following a significant influx of Democrats in the 2017 midterm elections. They won the governorship and agreed to include a Medicaid work provision as a condition of benefit eligibility.
A state budget bill was passed by the state legislature on May 31st, expanding the program to include up to 400,000 low-income residents. The legislation directed state officials to apply for a federal waiver to either encourage or require some non-disabled beneficiaries to engage in work activities, and to impose premiums on certain beneficiaries (Advisory Board, 2018). The bill was signed into law on June 7th, with Virginia's Medicaid expansion set to begin on January 1, 2019.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.