This paper reviews Robert M. Edsel's The Monuments Men (2009), which chronicles the U.S. Army's little-known monuments division and its efforts to protect and recover Europe's cultural heritage during the Second World War. The review covers the division's origins under Eisenhower's orders, the Nazi looting of museums and private collections, Hitler's artistic ambitions and the Nero Decree, and the role of individuals such as Rose Valland of the Jeu de Paume museum in Paris. The paper argues that Edsel's book fills a significant gap in World War II historiography by highlighting the cultural dimensions of the conflict.
The paper demonstrates how to integrate direct textual evidence (page-specific APA citations) with evaluative commentary. Rather than merely summarizing the book's plot, the reviewer contextualizes each narrative element within an argument about the book's significance, showing readers how summary and analysis can work together in a book review format.
The review opens with a thesis about the book's purpose and scope, then moves chronologically through the book's major themes: the Nazi looting backdrop, key individuals, the division's formation, Hitler's Nero Decree, and the division's composition. Each section advances the central claim that this is an overlooked but important story. The final paragraph returns to the opening thesis in a reinforced conclusion, giving the essay a satisfying circular structure.
Robert M. Edsel's The Monuments Men is a study of the United States Army's attempt to save valuable art objects during the Second World War. Edsel's primary objective was to showcase the men and women involved in what was known as the "monuments division" and tell their unique stories as they relate to the importance of saving many of Europe's most valuable art treasures. Although the initial responsibility of the monuments division was to safeguard monuments and buildings against bombing and shelling when possible, their mission was later expanded to cover movable works of art that the Nazis had stolen and relocated throughout the war (Edsel, 2009, p. 2). The work done by this unique group of U.S. Army soldiers is a story that had not been told before. Edsel's book fills a significant gap in the narrative of the Second World War that had hitherto been overlooked.
The initial phase of the story of the monuments division begins with an overview of Adolf Hitler's vision of collecting the greatest works of art and centering them within the Third Reich. This notion creates the backdrop against which the primary function of the monuments division is set. Not all works of art were destroyed simply because they were of Jewish origin, as had been previously assumed. Many of these works were simply "hidden" from public view by placing them in mines or other locations where they could not be readily seen.
Initially, Edsel thought he could write about all the works of art that the Nazis attempted to hide or place in centralized locations. However, as the sheer number of works revealed itself, it became apparent that the scope would be too large for a single book. The author then decided to focus on operations in Northern Europe. One museum in particular — the Jeu de Paume in Paris — was used as a clearinghouse by the Nazis for the spoils of France (Edsel, 2009, p. 177).
Fortunately, one of the Jeu de Paume's employees, Rose Valland, secretly recorded many of the works that the Nazis filtered through the museum, giving the men and women of the monuments division invaluable information as to the whereabouts of many pieces of artwork. This information greatly facilitated the return of many works of art after the war. Valland was, therefore, something of a cultural hero for the French and was rewarded for her efforts after the war with the Legion of Honor, the Medal of the Resistance, and was made Commander of the Order of Arts and Letters by the French government (Monumentsmen.org, para. 6).
Robert Edsel's The Monuments Men tells an incredible story about the Second World War that has been seldom mentioned and largely forgotten. It is an important story of war because, next to the tragic loss of human life that occurs in all wars, the loss of a particular culture through its works of art and monumental structures is equally tragic. The story of those whose job it was to preserve the cultural heritage of the many nations overrun by the Third Reich — and then robbed of their cultural treasures — is one that needs to be remembered by future generations. This, then, is the premise of Robert M. Edsel's The Monuments Men: a story that should be treasured as much as the very treasures these remarkable people sought to save.
You’re 58% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.