This paper reviews Giles Milton's Nathaniel's Nutmeg: The True and Incredible Adventures of the Spice Trader who Changed the Course of History, focusing on the book's central theme: the transformative global impact of the spice trade. The review traces how demand for spices in medieval Europe fueled an Age of Discovery, encouraged colonization of distant lands, expanded international trade networks, and gave rise to powerful early corporations such as the British East India Company. Drawing directly from Milton's text, the paper argues that spices fundamentally reshaped European geopolitics, economics, and global exploration for centuries to come.
This paper demonstrates disciplined use of textual evidence in a book review format. Rather than simply summarizing plot or events, the student extracts thematically relevant quotations and uses them to build an interpretive argument about the book's central claim. Each body paragraph introduces a distinct consequence of the spice trade, supported by a Milton citation, before connecting back to the broader thesis.
The paper follows a five-section structure: a brief framing introduction that states the thesis, three body paragraphs each addressing a distinct theme (exploration, trade growth, and colonization/corporate power), and a synthesizing conclusion. Citations follow Chicago author-page style. The paper is concise — appropriate for an undergraduate book review assignment — and every paragraph advances the central argument rather than summarizing plot.
This paper reviews Nathaniel's Nutmeg: The True and Incredible Adventures of the Spice Trader who Changed the Course of History by Giles Milton, focusing on the book's main theme. The world was a vastly different — and far more profitable — place after spices were discovered in the East, and Europe was transformed most of all. Spices encouraged exploration, created vast fortunes, drove European colonization on distant shores, and changed global trade forever. The world could not live without spice, and spice, in turn, created a new world.
Spices were an important part of life in medieval Europe. They were believed to have medicinal properties and were used in a wide variety of recipes. However, they were expensive, and Venice held a monopoly on their trade. As Milton observes, "spices had become so popular that demand had long since outstripped supply" (Milton 21). The Portuguese initially maintained a stronghold on the Spice Islands in Indonesia, but before long, other nations were dispatching their own expeditions in search of precious spices.
These early voyages of discovery fueled exploration and colonization across the globe. Milton notes that "Ferdinand Magellan [...] had long believed there was a far quicker route to the Spice Islands than the lengthy voyage around the Cape of Good Hope" (Milton 24). The Spice Islands and their extraordinary bounty thus gave rise to an Age of Discovery that has never been rivaled. Moreover, these voyages brought Europeans into contact with new lands and peoples. As Milton writes, "The journals and letters of Hudson and Juet, along with the accounts preserved by the English East India Company, form an invaluable record of the first European contact with native tribes" (Milton 183).
Trade expanded significantly as spices became more readily available, and the benefits were felt well beyond the wealthy merchant class of Europe. Milton explains that "[T]he London merchants reasoned that if they could exchange these goods for cottons, then barter cottons for spices, they would have established a triangle of trade which would benefit everyone" (Milton 121). Trade networks grew around the world because of the Spice Islands and their precious cargo. This commerce also enlarged the upper and upper-middle classes in Europe — particularly in England — giving more people access to trade goods and financial reward.
The changes wrought upon the world by the discovery and trade of spices were dramatic. Geographically, the world became better understood and more thoroughly explored, and trade flourished as a result. Politically, the great powers of the era — most notably Great Britain — began what would become a long history of colonial rule and domination. Economically, the spice trade made many merchants extraordinarily wealthy and gave rise to some of the most powerful commercial enterprises the world had ever seen, such as the East India Company.
Spices created new possibilities and permanently changed the way the world — especially European nations — lived and operated. As Milton writes, the spice trade "would change the course of history on the other side of the globe" (Milton 2), and he was entirely correct. The spice trade enriched individuals, opened the world to exploration, and produced the first modern corporations. It also set in motion centuries of colonization. All of this stemmed from the pursuit of nutmeg and pepper.
Milton, Giles. Nathaniel's Nutmeg: The True and Incredible Adventures of the Spice Trader who Changed the Course of History. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1999.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.