New Deal Programs: Social Security, Housing, and the CCC
This paper examines three primary source documents from Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal era, analyzing them within an accounting and economics context. Following a brief overview of the economic conditions that prompted the New Deal — including a 54% drop in industrial output and 25–30% unemployment after the 1929 Stock Market Crash — the paper reviews Abraham Epstein's 1935 critique of the Social Security Act, Albert Mayer's assessment of the failed public housing program, and Robert Fechner's optimistic account of the Civilian Conservation Corps. Together, these sources illustrate the uneven success of New Deal initiatives in restoring economic stability and public welfare.
- Introduction: The Economic Crisis Behind the New Deal: 1929 crash context and Roosevelt's New Deal response
- Epstein on the Social Security Act of 1935: Critique of Social Security Act's confusion and burden-shifting
- Mayer on the Public Housing Program: Government's failure to coordinate a coherent housing plan
- Fechner on the Civilian Conservation Corps: CCC's achievements in conservation, employment, and education
- Conclusion: Evaluating New Deal Effectiveness: Mixed outcomes across three major New Deal programs
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds each primary source in its historical and policy context before analyzing its content, helping readers understand why each New Deal program mattered.
- It presents a balanced range of perspectives: one critical source (Epstein), one mixed assessment (Mayer), and one optimistic account (Fechner), giving the analysis intellectual breadth.
- Concise summaries of each source are followed by clear evaluative statements, keeping the argument focused and easy to follow.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates annotated source analysis — summarizing primary documents and situating each within a broader argument about New Deal policy outcomes. Rather than simply describing each source, the author connects them to the central question of whether New Deal programs effectively addressed economic hardship, a technique useful in history, economics, and accounting courses alike.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with macroeconomic context (the 1929 crash and its effects), then moves sequentially through three primary sources. Each source section follows the same pattern: introduce the author and document, summarize the key arguments, and offer a brief evaluative comment. A short conclusion ties the sources together. This parallel structure makes the paper easy to read and well-organized for a comparative document analysis assignment.
Introduction: The Economic Crisis Behind the New Deal
The Stock Market Crash of 1929 and the global depression that followed caused U.S. industrial output to fall by 54%, while unemployment reached 25–30%. In 1932, Franklin Delano Roosevelt was elected president and dramatically changed the course of U.S. economics and politics by introducing strong government regulation and a package of massive public works projects known as the "New Deal." These initiatives were designed to re-employ Americans and to build a more modern national infrastructure. The following sections analyze three primary sources related to New Deal programs.
References
Epstein, Abraham. "Social Security" Under the New Deal (September 4, 1935). The New Deal Network. Retrieved November 16, 2003. http://newdeal.feri.org/nation/na35261.htm
Fechner, Robert. My Hopes for the CCC (January 1939). The New Deal Network. Retrieved November 16, 2003. http://newdeal.feri.org/forests/af139.htm
Mayer, Albert. Can We Have a Housing Program? (October 9, 1935). The New Deal Network. Retrieved November 16, 2003. http://newdeal.feri.org/nation/na35400.htm
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.