This paper compares two financially oriented careers — personal financial advisor and economist — across key dimensions including educational requirements, day-to-day responsibilities, working conditions, compensation, and job outlook. Drawing on data from the Occupational Outlook Handbook, the paper finds that personal financial advisors benefit from strong projected growth and accessible entry points, but require significant sales and interpersonal skills alongside technical knowledge. Economists, by contrast, command higher median salaries and face less client-facing pressure, but opportunities are fewer and advanced degrees are typically required. The paper concludes with a reflective comparison to help students consider which path better suits their skills and personality.
The first position explored here is that of the personal financial advisor. This position typically requires at least a bachelor's degree, and often benefits from more advanced education. The degree is usually in a related field such as finance, economics, accounting, or business, though mathematics may also qualify. Personal financial advisors must also undergo extensive supplementary education specific to the profession. This includes courses in investments, taxes, estate planning, risk management, and in many cases insurance. There are often additional courses tied to required licensing — for example, obtaining a license to trade stocks or to sell insurance. Professional certification is also commonly expected; one prominent example is becoming a Certified Financial Planner (CFP).
There are essentially two elements to day-to-day work as a personal financial advisor. The first is sales and service. The position often involves running one's own business, so sales ability is important, as are customer service and the capacity to build trust. Communication skills are therefore critical to success. Developing and executing marketing programs is an essential part of the business.
The second element is a combination of analytical and administrative work. This is the actual building of portfolios, managing investments, executing trades, and handling other activities related to client assets. Most of the formal training for the role focuses on this aspect. Competence here is essential — to be successful, an advisor must avoid losing clients' money.
Working conditions for personal financial advisors are generally good. Advisors work primarily in offices, with field work reserved for sales calls and networking. There is little to no physical risk involved. A significant share of advisors are self-employed, meaning the primary professional risk is financial rather than physical. According to the Occupational Outlook Handbook (OOH), the median annual wage for personal financial advisors is $64,750, not including self-employed advisors. This is above average for the financial industry and well above the median for all occupations. Those employed by financial institutions often receive bonuses in addition to their base salary. Furthermore, advisors can expect to benefit personally from their market expertise and access to financial information.
The job outlook is strong. The career was projected to grow by 32% from 2010 to 2020 — much faster than average. The primary driver of this growth is demographic change, as core clients tend to be in their late working years or in retirement. The industry may experience some slowdown once the baby boomer generation begins to pass on, but anyone entering the profession today would be well established before that occurs. Challenging market conditions can also stimulate growth, as more people seek professional help rather than managing their own finances.
"Entry pathways and competitive job market access"
"Economist education, pay, and limited job openings"
"Reflective comparison highlighting personality fit"
You’re 47% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.