Point of View and Its Effect in "A White Heron"
This essay examines how point of view shapes a story's emotional effect, using Sarah Orne Jewett's "A White Heron" as its central example. The paper argues that Jewett's decision to narrate events through the young girl Sylvia's perspective creates a powerful single effect of sympathy, framing the ornithologist as a threat and nature as something sacred. The essay then explores how the story would differ had it been told from the grandmother's or the young man's point of view, each of which would introduce competing sympathies and complicate the narrative. Drawing on Judith Oster and Alan Hirvela and Diane Belcher, the paper concludes that a focused point of view produces a singleness of purpose that enriches a reader's emotional experience.
- Introduction: Point of View as a Narrative Frame: How Sylvia's perspective shapes narrative and reader sympathy
- Sylvia's Perspective and Its Effect on the Reader: Child's viewpoint frames nature, innocence, and moral conflict
- The Grandmother's Point of View: Age, Worry, and Financial Concern: Alternate elder perspective emphasizes poverty and practicality
- The Young Ornithologist's Point of View: Ambition and the Masculine Gaze: Hunter's perspective would add ambition and competing sympathy
- Simplicity of Perspective and Singleness of Purpose: Single viewpoint produces focused emotional effect for reader
- Conclusion: How Point of View Shapes Tone and Sympathy: Point of view determines tone, sympathy, and authorial intent
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper consistently grounds its abstract claims about point of view in specific textual evidence from "A White Heron," including direct quotations, which keeps the argument anchored to the source material.
- The counterfactual structure — asking "what if the story had been told from another perspective?" — is an effective analytical strategy that illuminates why Jewett's actual choice matters.
- The paper moves logically from the established perspective (Sylvia's) to two alternative perspectives (grandmother's, young man's), then draws a synthesizing conclusion about narrative simplicity and authorial intention.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates the use of counterfactual literary analysis — imagining alternative narrative choices to reveal why the author's actual choices are significant. By asking what the story would look like from the grandmother's or the ornithologist's perspective, the writer shows a strong understanding of how craft decisions produce specific reader effects, a technique useful in any close-reading or literary analysis assignment.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a plot summary and central argument, then devotes one paragraph each to unpacking Sylvia's perspective, the grandmother's hypothetical perspective, and the young man's hypothetical perspective. A synthesis paragraph addresses narrative complexity versus simplicity before the conclusion restates the thesis with expanded insight. The structure is clear and progression is orderly, making it easy to follow the argument from setup to resolution.
Introduction: Point of View as a Narrative Frame
How does point of view determine a story's effect? "A White Heron" by Sarah Orne Jewett is told in the third-person narration style, but the point of view the narrator adopts is Sylvia's — the little girl who feels connected with nature and enjoys the beauty, peace, and harmony she experiences in the outdoors. Her perspective allows the author to depict the ornithologist as a kind of barbaric hunter who is out to destroy nature so that he can coldly study it in his lab. To the girl, he is "the enemy" (Jewett) — the hunter who is out to catch the white heron and make of it a prize. He offers money to Sylvia and her grandmother if the girl will only confess where she saw the bird so that he can snatch it from the wild.
Sylvia, too loyal to nature and too fond of the animals and all the life of the outdoors, refuses to divulge the secret. The story concludes with the narrator appealing to the reader to bring some joy to the girl, who is made sad by keeping her secret, denying her grandmother the promised money, and losing the friendship of the ornithologist. The reader is made to sympathize with the girl because the narrator describes the action from her perspective so vividly. However, had the narrator told the story from the young man's perspective or from the grandmother's perspective, it would have been a very different story: the reader might have been compelled to feel sympathy for the grandmother or feel the disappointment of the young man who sought his prized bird.
Point of view is important when telling a story, as Judith Oster points out in her essay on perspective in the classroom. How people look at things — the orientation from which they are situated — will determine what they see, how they think about what they are seeing, and the information they are able to process about the object of sight. In literature, point of view serves as a kind of frame that brings characters and plot into focus, granting a single perspective (unless the story uses multiple points of view, like Rashomon, to convey a more complete picture of events). A writer uses point of view to help manipulate the reader's experience and draw attention to details that might not be obvious were the perspective different.
Sylvia's Perspective and Its Effect on the Reader
In "A White Heron," the action is told mainly from Sylvia's perspective. As a child, her point of view is primarily focused on goodness, the beauty and wonder of nature, and a fondness for the birds, whom she considers her friends. At the end of the story, when she is asked to choose between the happiness of her human friends and the happiness of her own heart in communing with the white heron, she is torn as only a little child can be. She does not want to give up the bird to the hunter for money, but at the same time she does not want to hurt his feelings or make her grandmother sad.
Were the story told from a separate point of view — say, from the grandmother's or from the young ornithologist's — the details provided by the author would surely focus on other elements that only they would notice. The child's perspective is what makes the story's moral stakes feel so immediate and so tender. Because everything is filtered through Sylvia's innocent eyes, the reader is never in any real doubt about where sympathy should be directed, even if the situation itself is genuinely complex.
The Grandmother's Point of View: Age, Worry, and Financial Concern
The grandmother's presence in the story opens up a unique perspective that could have been explored had the author decided to use her point of view. The story of the white heron would be different because it would include details that only the grandmother would feel, think, or know. The story would be told from the perspective of age and worry. The grandmother has to look after Sylvia and has very little money to do it. Her concerns are not for beauty, innocence, or the birds of the wild. These things she might have noticed much earlier in her youth, but for her now they are relatively uninteresting.
A dead white heron that the hunter is willing to pay for is much more valuable to her than a live white heron whose whereabouts are unknown and for which the hunter will pay nothing. Finances concern her. Keeping a roof over her and the child's head concerns her. The liberty of the white heron does not concern her, because she is not a little girl in love with nature. She is an old woman who has undoubtedly experienced all that life can offer — and now, old and alone with the responsibility of caring for this child, she would gladly tell the whereabouts of the white heron if only she knew where it was. Had the author included this point of view, the reader would no doubt feel far more conflicted about where to place one's sympathies.
But Jewett is not concerned with the grandmother's point of view. She wants to convey what it is like to be a child and to be faced with such a terrible decision: to choose one's loyalties in such a painful manner — for money that would make the grandmother happy, but which would rob the girl of her innocence, which she can only maintain by refusing to give up the bird.
Conclusion: How Point of View Shapes Tone and Sympathy
The story "A White Heron" would be much different had Jewett told it from the ornithologist's or grandmother's point of view. Point of view serves the purpose of framing a narrative: it gives the reader a lens through which life and events must be viewed. To see outside that frame, or to see from a different lens situated at another point of reference, would give another take on the events but would also complicate the picture substantially. The reader, like the girl, would be made to feel torn about where sympathies should be placed.
Had Jewett included the grandmother's perspective, the reader might feel obliged to have more sympathy for the old woman than for the innocent child — but this would have undermined the author's primary intention, which was for the reader to identify with the child and to remember what it was like to be young and innocent, to care for beauty and the things of nature. Had Jewett included the point of view of the young hunter, the story would have taken on a colder, more calculating tone, and the author's aim would have been lost just the same. Point of view is essential in communicating tone, a picture, and a feeling — and how it is used will impact the reader and alter their perception and experience of the drama that unfolds in the story.
Works Cited
Hirvela, Alan, and Diane Belcher. "Coming back to voice: The multiple voices and identities of mature multilingual writers." Journal of Second Language Writing 10.1-2 (2001): 83-106.
Jewett, Sarah Orne. "A White Heron."
Oster, Judith. "Seeing with different eyes: Another view of literature in the ESL class." TESOL Quarterly 23.1 (1989): 85-103.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.