This paper reviews and synthesizes research on police culture, ethics, and officer behavior, drawing on Paoline's (2004) officer typologies and Kingshott et al.'s (2004) entitlement theory to examine how institutional culture shapes moral conduct. It evaluates the influence of media portrayals, workplace anxiety, job satisfaction, and public perception on officer attitudes. The paper also considers emotional intelligence as a factor in ethical decision-making, discusses the problem of police misconduct and brutality, and examines accountability mechanisms such as consent decrees. The overarching goal is to integrate existing knowledge on police culture and ethics research to better understand the conditions that promote or undermine ethical policing.
Owing to the distinguishable contribution of police officers in any given society, a number of professionals working in the fields of criminology and sociology have emphasized the significance of comprehending the duties of a police officer. In keeping with this tradition, the present analysis examines the behavioral actions and moral obligations of the police officer. Most importantly, the objective of this study is to assess and synthesize the current body of research related to police culture and ethics. Paoline (2004) carried out significant research on police culture and identified seven officer typologies that can serve as a viable framework for research on policing institutions and strategies. Studies related to police culture have widened and grown further by incorporating relevant information from the field of police ethics. One anticipated outcome of this study is that a stable pattern of ethical responses, in accordance with officer typology, will be integrated to expand the existing knowledge base surrounding police culture research (Mason, 2010).
The study of policing is multidimensional. This analysis, nevertheless, emphasizes the facets of policing research that could impact the attitudes and behavior of police officers. Factors such as workplace anxiety, police culture, social networks, media depiction, press coverage, public perception, and job satisfaction are all considered when identifying their impact on police officer attitudes and performance (Mason, 2010).
The research on police ethics will also be evaluated for further consideration. The belief is that the aforementioned factors have the power to considerably impact the attitudes and behavior of police officers and, ultimately, their responses to ethical prompts and typological classification. If one is to integrate the research on ethics and typology, an understanding of the factors related to the study that could affect outcomes is essential (Mason, 2010).
Police culture research is particularly emphasized because of its significant role and effect on officers. This paper will build upon that research to integrate findings from police ethics scholarship. The culture present in police departments can have considerable influence on officer attitudes. It is therefore essential to identify whether the ethical standpoints of police officers differ according to officer type — only by doing so can the attitudes of officers be fully assessed and understood (Mason, 2010).
The typologies present in police culture, as Paoline (2004) has highlighted, are considered the most useful framework for understanding police officers. Certain differences may exist at the individual level, meaning officers may not perfectly match the characteristics of the ethics typology to which they are assigned (Mason, 2010). The characteristics of an ideal typology allow for certain differences to exist between individual officers while still accurately identifying common attributes and behaviors among officers of a given type. Even where individual variation is observed, a typology still makes it possible to predict the attributes and traits of an officer within an ethics classification quite accurately. Moreover, the study of typologies among police officers allows researchers to build upon an enduring body of work and to advance the field of policing research (Mason, 2010).
The analysis of policing as an institution entails a number of research objectives. These include expanding the current knowledge about police ethics and culture and gaining greater insight into factors such as press coverage, job satisfaction, anxiety, and public perception (Mason, 2010). More importantly, the current analysis aims to address the following questions:
1) Are there differences in how officers respond to cultural factors in policing — including perspectives on policies, selective enforcement, supervisors, the public, and aggressive tactics?
2) If cultural variation is present, does Paoline's (2004) typology study offer supporting evidence?
3) Are police officers' responses to ethical queries homogeneous, or do they vary?
4) If differences are present, how does Paoline's (2004) study account for responses to ethical scenarios? That is, can a distinguishable pattern be identified in typological responses among police officers when they face ethical situations?
In order to gain an understanding of the behavior and ethical standpoints of police officers, it is essential to examine the factors that would influence them. Kingshott, Bailey, and Wolfe's (2004) entitlement theory offers a meaningful way of understanding how police culture manifests and how it continues to expand and endure. The theory is concerned with the concept of attachment (Mason, 2010).
According to entitlement theory, individuals learn to suppress beliefs or notions that are considered unacceptable in order to maintain closeness with the people around them, thereby preserving attachment. In doing so, people may compromise their authentic selves by presenting only a socially acceptable side that is not entirely true to reality. Thus, alongside the level of attachment that individuals seek to form throughout their lives, a sense of entitlement also emerges (Mason, 2010).
When a sense of entitlement develops, a person may feel under-entitled — believing that they have no duty to care for others and therefore no ethical obligations toward them. Such an individual is likely to perceive the world as a dangerous place, devoid of nobility, morals, or benevolence. The result is that the person feels connected to others only when serving them, or, at the other extreme, becomes consumed by self-interest while ignoring those around them, giving rise to over-entitlement (Mason, 2010).
According to Kingshott et al. (2004), police culture fosters an environment that encourages over-entitlement through the interactions, situations, and training provided to officers. Over-entitlement is promoted by training programs that emphasize a militaristic form of humiliation without grounding officers in ethical or moral principles related to human dignity and connection (Conti, 2009; Kingshott et al., 2004).
When police officers undergo militaristic training, they may attempt to forge power-based relationships with those around them — including their children, spouses, and the broader community — thereby increasing anxiety, irritation, and mental and physical health concerns (Kingshott et al., 2004). Other factors that can influence an officer's ethical standing include media coverage, workplace stress, job satisfaction, organizational culture, and public perception. If the performance of a police officer is adversely affected by these factors, their ethical judgment may also suffer. In extreme cases, the objectivity and effectiveness of officers might be compromised (Mason, 2010).
The study of policing has maintained a strong presence in scholarly research over the years and has grown considerably in recent decades. This expansion is significant for several reasons. Police officers occupy a uniquely identifiable role in society: they are expected to resolve crime and hold the legal authority to use force. It is therefore important to understand the attitudes and behaviors of those employed in the police force, as well as the environments within which they work, since the workplace setting has a considerable impact on performance. The behavior, ethical standing, and effectiveness of police officers are all affected when workplace environments fall short of adequate standards. Only through continued scholarly study can this vital institution be meaningfully improved (Mason, 2010).
According to Dowler and Zawilski (2007), the majority of public information related to crime and justice is derived from media consumption (p. 193). Cultural and ethical ideologies and messages are also reported to be transmitted through media sources (Dowler & Zawilski, 2007). Cultural beliefs conveyed by the media include notions such as the idea that police officers are heroes. In reality, the media functions to reinforce and affirm cultural beliefs already present in a society.
This is particularly true of messages about the ethics involved in crime and justice incidents. Many people do not experience crime firsthand or engage directly with the justice system. In such cases, the media communicates relevant information about the ethics of crime and its justification to the general public. As a result, media content about the policing system tends to be accepted as accurate and representative of reality, reinforcing existing notions about crime and criminal justice (Mason, 2010).
Because media outlets have the power to considerably shape public perceptions of the police, it is important to assess the kinds of content they portray — whether intentionally or unintentionally. In many cases, however, media content about crime and criminal justice is neither accurate nor representative of real life or ethical complexity. It can be biased or misleading and may reinforce existing cultural beliefs that are incorrect (Mason, 2010).
Incorrect media messages are significant because of the influence they can have on the public. As noted above, many people form their understanding of the ethics of policing and the criminal justice system through media rather than through direct experience or inquiry. Their comprehension of the system is therefore dependent upon what the media depicts. If those depictions are flawed, they cultivate a flawed understanding in the public (Mason, 2010).
This is dangerous because it obstructs meaningful reform, fosters unjustified beliefs about the police, and ultimately affects officer behavior — outcomes that bode poorly for the health and safety of society. Prospective police officers entering the field may also hold inaccurate assumptions about the institution, which can lead to severe consequences if those assumptions shape their professional conduct (Mason, 2010).
A person harboring inaccurate notions about policing ethics may face serious consequences. In an encounter with a police officer, that person may lose their freedom or find themselves entirely subject to the state when appearing before a court. If such a person serves on a jury, justice may be poorly served. All of these outcomes can have serious repercussions for the individual and for others (Mason, 2010).
"Contrasting media fiction with operational reality"
"EI, moral development, and accountability mechanisms"
In recent years, cities and jurisdictions including Detroit, Los Angeles, Prince Georges County, Steubenville (Ohio), Washington, DC, Cincinnati, and the State of New Jersey have been placed under Justice Department decrees. These agencies were subjected to court-ordered consent decrees because there was reason to believe that police misconduct within them had been condoned due to inadequate policies, insufficient supervision, and low levels of training (Smith, 2009).
In recent times, police administration faces the challenge of monitoring unethical conduct in a profession where many practices occur without direct supervision and where decision-making is often characterized by significant ambiguity. Society has grown increasingly wary of police officers in light of publicized incidents highlighting unethical conduct, generating widespread mistrust. These incidents represent a betrayal of public trust (Swanson et al., 1998). This does not change the reality that officers, like those in other demanding professions, must make decisions in an increasingly challenging and volatile environment — one that may leave them uncertain about the appropriate course of action (Cohen & Feldberg, 1991). This challenge is compounded by the fact that the decisions or errors of judgment made by police officers can set off serious chains of consequences for all those involved.
You’re 58% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.