This essay examines the parallel experiences of Bigger Thomas in Richard Wright's Native Son and Mookie in Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing as victims of social, economic, and racial oppression in America. Drawing on the historical contexts of the 1930s and 1980s respectively, the paper argues that although both characters are shaped by institutionalized racism, differences in era — particularly the legacy of the Civil Rights movement — account for the divergences in their responses. Despite legal progress, the essay contends that racism persisted across both periods, ultimately driving both protagonists to violence and demonstrating that the struggle for racial equality in America remained far from complete.
When Buggin' Out tells Mookie to "Stay Black!" in Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing, he points directly to the film's central theme. Being Black in America entails struggle, and occasionally that struggle against social and economic oppression manifests in unfortunate acts of violence. Like Mookie, Bigger in Richard Wright's novel Native Son is a victim of social, political, and economic oppression directly related to the color of his skin. Being Black in America means sacrificing hopes and dreams as well as personal values and principles.
When Spike Lee quotes both Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. at the conclusion of Do the Right Thing — Lee also plays Mookie in the film — he makes a powerful statement about the dichotomy of race relations in America. On the one hand, American values idealize equality; liberty and justice are supposed to be truly "for all." Reality, however, deals a harsh blow to individuals like Mookie and Bigger, who soon learn that the ideal of equality has yet to be fully realized. Both men ultimately break down, succumbing to anger and personal turmoil — to their frustration that life in America is not what it should be for people of color. Race relations in America shape Mookie and Bigger's responses to perceived social and economic oppression, and although both characters are flawed, they respond heroically to their respective situations. The similarities and differences between them are directly rooted in the historical contexts in which they live.
One of the main reasons Mookie and Bigger react differently to social and economic oppression is that Mookie lives in post-Civil Rights era America, whereas Bigger's story takes place just after the turn of the twentieth century. In other words, both men are victims of the times they live in even more than they are victims of their own tragic flaws. The inclusion of quotes from two of the Civil Rights era's most notable and influential figures in Lee's film underscores the ideological differences between his work and Wright's novel.
Lee invokes a Civil Rights era that had not even occurred when Wright wrote Native Son. Bigger does not have access to the social networks available to Mookie — concepts such as Black Power or Black Nationalism. The idea that "staying Black" might be socially acceptable was a foreign concept for Bigger, and therefore he deals with political disempowerment with far less finesse than Mookie does.
For Bigger, being Black meant being systematically discriminated against through institutionalized racism. He cannot rent an apartment wherever he chooses because of his race. He is systematically shut out and cut off from sources of wealth and political power in ways that would eventually be outlawed by the 1980s. In Mookie's time, racism was still endemic in American society but was gradually being pushed out of official social and political institutions. Anti-discrimination legislation meant that racism had become less socially acceptable by that decade.
One of the main differences between Do the Right Thing and Native Son is their respective settings. In Mookie's world, racism was more palpable on the streets and in the daily lives of ordinary Americans. For Bigger, racism was far more pervasive, invading American institutions so thoroughly that African-Americans had no legal recourse. Moreover, Mookie lives in a multicultural world in which Korean-Americans, Italian-Americans, and African-Americans coexist and must find ways to promote peace and public welfare without sacrificing the ideals of their communities. Bigger's world is more monolithic. Whites hold the dominant power, and Bigger feels pitted against forces far larger than himself.
"Hip-hop, Black pride, and cultural access compared"
"Both men respond to racism's enduring presence"
"Physical aggression as outcome of social frustration"
Mookie and Bigger are remarkably similar, proving that little has actually changed for African-Americans in terms of gaining social and political power even after the Civil Rights movement. Richard Wright's Native Son illustrates the depth of racial discrimination during the first half of the twentieth century; Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing reveals its persistence during the latter half. The protagonists live in different times, and consequently the level of discrimination they experience differs. Bigger arguably confronts more pervasive and systematic racism because discrimination against African-Americans was largely condoned — practically a way of life in America. For Mookie, racism had at least been superficially outmoded.
You’re 45% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.