This essay examines the role of religion in Frederick Douglass's autobiography, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845). Drawing directly from Douglass's own account of his early life in bondage, the paper traces how religion functioned in contradictory ways: offering genuine comfort and humanity to enslaved people, yet also serving as a rhetorical weapon used by slaveholders to rationalize brutality. The essay highlights key episodes — including Mrs. Auld's moral transformation and the scriptural justifications offered by slave masters — to argue that slavery was fundamentally incompatible with authentic religious practice, corrupting even the most devout individuals who participated in the institution.
The paper demonstrates effective use of close reading: rather than summarizing the narrative broadly, the writer selects specific passages and characters to show how a single text can illuminate a complex ideological contradiction. The contrast between genuine religious feeling (Douglass's gratitude to Providence) and weaponized religion (masters quoting scripture to justify beatings) is developed through careful quotation and commentary rather than assertion alone.
The essay opens with biographical context establishing Douglass's significance, then moves chronologically through his narrative to track religion's shifting role. A central section focuses on Mrs. Auld as the pivotal example of slavery corrupting religious character. The paper then addresses scriptural misuse by slaveholders before concluding with the thesis that slavery and genuine religion are incompatible. This chronological-then-thematic structure suits a literary analysis of an autobiography well.
Sometime around the year 1818, in Talbot County, Maryland, a child was born to a slave woman named Harriet Bailey. This child, named Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey, was a slave the moment he was born, but through sheer determination would die a free man. In between his birth and death, Frederick — who later changed his name to Frederick Douglass — suffered under the yoke of slavery, escaped to freedom, and became a great writer, orator, and leader of the abolitionist movement. During his life he wrote three autobiographies; the first, entitled Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, is a graphic description of his early life as a slave and his struggle to be free (Douglass). While Frederick Douglass was not an overly religious man, religion played an important part in his story. Religion brought him comfort and kindness and helped him learn to read, but it was also twisted to justify the most heinous acts of cruelty and murder.
Frederick Bailey, prior to his becoming Douglass, lived the first part of his life as a slave in the South during the early part of the 19th century. He did not even know the exact date of his birth, as his mother had been separated from him as an infant. She was sold to another plantation, and he never actually met her; having also never met his father, he had no idea as to that man's identity either. Instead, he was raised by his maternal grandmother, Betty Bailey, until he was seven, when he was sent to Baltimore. He remained there, under the ownership of several masters, until 1833, when he was sent to work for a notorious "slave-breaker." During his time in Baltimore, he had, under the tutelage of a caring white woman, learned to read — which became both the source of his current sufferings and the means of his later escape. After several failed attempts, Frederick Bailey finally succeeded in 1838 in making his way to New York and an abolitionist safe house.
Frederick Bailey labored for many years both to support himself and to help sustain the abolitionist movement. He became an eloquent orator and writer, as well as a statesman and spokesman for the abolitionist cause. His first autobiography, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, was first published in 1845 and was an immediate bestseller; within three years, more than 11,000 copies had been printed. While skeptics promoted the idea that a former slave could not have written such an eloquent piece of work, his subsequent writings proved beyond a doubt that this former slave was indeed a literary and intellectual genius.
After changing his name to Frederick Douglass and becoming famous as an orator, writer, statesman, and spokesman, he continued his work in the abolitionist movement. During this time, Douglass was not an irreligious man, but he was not an overly religious man either. He attended churches and mingled with pastors, reverends, and other religious individuals, but unlike Martin Luther King Jr. a hundred years later, Douglass was not a minister or a church leader of any kind. Nevertheless, while he may not have been a deeply religious man, religion played an important part in his story.
During his life as a slave, Douglass experienced cruelty and violence far earlier than he experienced the kindness usually associated with religion. His first master, whom he referred to as "Captain Anthony," was "a miserable drunkard, a profane swearer, and a savage monster" (Douglass, Chapter 1). Douglass recounted how his aunt would be whipped for this white man's pleasure. He then described many other instances of cruelty toward slaves, including the killing of a slave named Demby, who was shot in cold blood by a ruthless and cruel slave master (Douglass, Chapter 4).
It was not until Douglass was moved to Baltimore that he first mentions the Lord. He had been transferred to a family named the Aulds, relatives of his former master, and when he saw the pleasant conditions he would be experiencing, he was overjoyed. Douglass interpreted this new life "as a special interposition of divine Providence in my favor," and declared, "This good spirit was from God, and to him I offer thanksgiving and praise" (Douglass, Chapter 5).
But Douglass would learn that even the kindest and most religious people can turn cruel when exposed to slavery. His new mistress, Mrs. Auld, was at first a kind and decent woman who taught him to read and always had "bread for the hungry, clothes for the naked, and comfort for every mourner that came within her reach" (Douglass, Chapter 7). As Douglass went on to lament, however, "Slavery soon proved its ability to divest her of these heavenly qualities. Under its influence, the tender heart became a stone, and the lamblike disposition gave way to one of tiger-like fierceness" (Douglass, Chapter 7). Mrs. Auld was a kindhearted, God-fearing woman who, when exposed to the evils of slavery, changed into an evil, contemptible woman with a heart of stone.
If there is one thing that Frederick Douglass's life as a slave has demonstrated, it is that slavery is not compatible with religion. Those who practice the institution of slavery often lose their humanity and become violent, uncaring monsters. The transformation of Mrs. Auld from a kind and loving person to a cruel slave owner with a heart of stone is a perfect example of this. Worst of all is the fact that many of these individuals justified their actions through religion. Even the ostensibly good and kind masters would rationalize the cruelty of other slaveholders by invoking scripture. Those who are truly religious at heart cannot partake in the institution of slavery without risking their very souls — and it was precisely these genuinely religious individuals whom Douglass encountered when he escaped to the North and became part of the abolitionist movement.
You’re 79% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.