Rule of Law and the Gun Control Debate in America
This paper examines the central issues of the gun control debate through the lens of rule of law theory. It explores the ideological spectrum from absolute gun restrictions to no restrictions at all, drawing on scholars such as Radin, Scalia, LaFollette, Lindgren, and Vizzard. The paper argues that the debate is fundamentally about competing visions of safety — one rooted in constitutional rights and liberty, the other in government-enforced security. It also applies criminological frameworks — social bond theory, life course theory, and broken windows theory — to argue that gun violence is as much a cultural and behavioral problem as a legal one, and that effective policy must address both dimensions.
- Introduction: Three-way tension over safety and gun rights
- The Rule of Law: Radin and Scalia on law versus personal discretion
- Gun Control Policy and the Second Amendment: Spectrum of restrictions and Framers' intent
- Criminological Theories and Gun Violence: Social bond, life course, and broken windows theories
- Application and Policy Implications: Culture, behavior, and limits of gun control policy
- Conclusion: Gun debate as rights versus safety paradigm clash
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds a politically charged topic in legal theory, citing Radin and Scalia to give the debate an academic framework that moves beyond partisan talking points.
- It introduces multiple criminological theories — social bond, life course, and broken windows — to broaden the analysis beyond simple pro- or anti-gun positions, demonstrating interdisciplinary thinking.
- It maintains a clear argumentative throughline: that gun violence is a cultural and behavioral problem that narrow gun-control legislation cannot adequately address on its own.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a literature review to synthesize competing scholarly positions before drawing its own conclusions. Rather than simply summarizing each source, it places them in dialogue — for example, contrasting Vizzard's cultural-geographic argument with Lindgren's character-based argument — and uses that tension to build its policy critique. This source-driven argumentation is a hallmark of effective undergraduate research writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a framing introduction that establishes the three-way tension among legislators, gun-rights advocates, and gun-control advocates. The literature review is divided into rule of law theory, gun control policy, and criminological theories, each section contributing a distinct analytical layer. The application section synthesizes these layers into a broader critique of current policy discourse. The conclusion returns to the constitutional framing established at the outset, giving the essay a tight circular structure.
Introduction
The one element that legislators, Second Amendment supporters, and advocates of gun control all have in common is safety. Legislators pass laws that they believe will make the country safer. Second Amendment supporters believe in the constitutional right to bear arms because it gives them the ability to protect themselves. Gun control advocates believe that guns should be banned or more strictly regulated because they think this will make everyone safer. Thus, safety is at the heart of the gun control debate. What creates such conflict and tension among the various sides is the fact that every side has a unique perspective on safety and how best to ensure it.
Legislators believe that nuanced legal changes can help ensure safety. Gun control advocates believe the Constitution itself needs to change — that nuances in law are insufficient and that major changes, such as abolishing the Second Amendment, must be made. Second Amendment advocates, on the other hand, believe the only thing that makes them safe is their own ability to defend themselves with a firearm. If they cannot bear arms, they reason, they are essentially subjects of the state with no recourse. Since there is no way to reconcile these three perspectives, the gun control debate remains fierce. It will not subside until one side prevails over the others — but how that will occur remains unknown.
The Rule of Law
Radin (1989) notes that "the ideal of 'the rule of law, not of men' calls upon us to strive to ensure that our law itself will rule (govern) us, not the wishes of powerful individuals" (p. 781). The point he makes is that in the legal tradition, the rule of law ideal is contested: those who support it cannot point to any single canon that defines it, while those who object to it view it as too idealistic to be of any real value (Radin, 1989). Yet people still believe in the rule of law, if only as a transcendental ideal, because of the utility it has in shaping one's moral course. The moral course of a country is no different from that of its citizens. If people dispute the relevance of the rule of law concept, how much more will they dispute a concrete right — such as the Second Amendment — that controversially grants a nation the right to bear arms even while those arms are used to inflict violence in one mass murder event after another? Radin (1989) does not answer that question, but he lays out the framework by which it might be addressed.
Scalia (1989) offers his take on the rule of law as a law of rules, invoking the image of St. Louis dispensing justice as a fair monarch — his back to an oak tree, those with suits to press gathered around him — and contrasting it with Thomas Paine's argument against monarchy: that in a monarchy the king is law, but in a free society the law is king. This emphasis on law as king places the letter of the law above the rational judgment of any individual. Yet, as Dunn (2013) reminds us, it is the spirit, not the letter, that gives life. Scalia's (1989) broader point is that the rule of law ought to be balanced by personal discretion and a general sense of justice. There is no reason law, by itself, must be inflexible or absolute. When law is presented as a cudgel, it loses its appeal. Law should be tempered by fairness and understanding; when it is rigid, it functions more like a yoke than a guide.
References
Chriss, J. J. (2007). The functions of the social bond. The Sociological Quarterly, 48(4), 689–712.
Cook, P. J., Braga, A. A., & Moore, M. H. (2011). Gun control. Crime and public policy, 257–292.
Dunn, J. D. (2013). "The letter kills, but the spirit gives life" (2 Cor. 3:6). Pneuma, 35(2), 163–179.
Gau, J. M., & Pratt, T. C. (2010). Revisiting broken windows theory: Examining the sources of the discriminant validity of perceived disorder and crime. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(4), 758–766.
LaFollette, H. (2000). Gun control. Ethics, 110(2), 263–281.
Lindgren, J. (2014). Foreword: The past and future of guns. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 104, 705.
Radin, M. J. (1989). Reconsidering the rule of law. Boston University Law Review, 69, 781.
Sampson, R. J., & Laub, J. H. (2005). A life-course view of the development of crime. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 602(1), 12–45.
Scalia, A. (1989). The rule of law as a law of rules. University of Chicago Law Review, 56, 1175.
Vizzard, W. J. (2014). The current and future state of gun policy in the United States. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 104, 879.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.