Sentimental vs. Realistic Techniques in American Fiction
This essay compares sentimental and modernist narrative techniques in three works of American fiction — Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin, Jessie Redmon Fauset's Plum Bun, and Nella Larsen's Passing — to evaluate which approach more effectively promotes social change regarding African-American experience. The paper argues that sentimental strategies, including idealized characters, familiar plot structures, and emotional appeals to family and romance, reach broader audiences and elicit deeper empathy than the more detached, morally ambiguous techniques of literary modernism. Through close reading of each text, the essay demonstrates how sentimentalism mobilizes readers across racial lines while modernism, though artistically compelling, encourages reflection rather than action.
- Introduction: Sentimentalism vs. Modernism as Vehicles for Social Change: Thesis: sentimental novels persuade more broadly than modernist ones
- Empathy and Identification in Uncle Tom's Cabin: Stowe uses motherhood and humanity to build cross-racial empathy
- Moral Appeals and Sentimental Persuasion in Stowe's Narrative: Stowe's moral scenarios compel readers toward abolitionist action
- Angela Murray and Sentimental Identification in Plum Bun: Fauset uses romance and identity to engage sentimental readers
- Modernist Ambiguity and Detachment in Nella Larsen's Passing: Larsen's realism withholds moral guidance and limits reader action
- Conclusion: Reflection vs. Change: Sentimentalism drives action; modernism encourages reflection only
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its comparative argument in close textual evidence, quoting directly from all three novels to support analytical claims about narrative technique.
- It moves logically from the broadest claim (sentimentalism outperforms modernism for social persuasion) to specific textual demonstrations in each novel, maintaining a clear throughline.
- The essay acknowledges potential objections — such as the use of multiracial rather than fully Black protagonists across all three texts — and absorbs them into the argument rather than ignoring them.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative literary analysis across historical periods, using two nineteenth- and early twentieth-century texts (Stowe and Fauset) as examples of a single mode (sentimentalism) and one modernist text (Larsen) as a contrasting case. This triangulated comparison allows the author to isolate the variable — narrative technique — while holding the thematic concern (African-American social experience) constant across all three works.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis paragraph establishing the central claim, then devotes roughly half its length to Uncle Tom's Cabin, examining both empathy and moral rhetoric. It then turns to Plum Bun to show that sentimentalism operates even in an African-American-authored Harlem Renaissance text, before concluding with Passing as the modernist counterexample. The final paragraph synthesizes the contrast, arguing that modernism promotes reflection while sentimentalism promotes action.
Introduction: Sentimentalism vs. Modernism as Vehicles for Social Change
Despite critical caveats about literary quality, the use of sentimental techniques in novels that attempt to precipitate social change is ultimately more persuasive than the use of modernist techniques in similarly motivated social-activist novels. Sentimental strategies that encourage readers to identify with idealized characters and familiar, even formulaic plots allow sentimental novels to act as more popularly persuasive vehicles for social change than modernist novels that deploy realistic techniques. The latter rely on less obvious strategies of identification with protagonists and present more morally complex scenarios, making them compelling as art but less effective as instruments of popular persuasion.
One of the greatest strengths of the sentimental novel is its ability to elicit empathy. Although a literary critic may blanch at the use of such devices as stock characters and idealized moral scenarios — deployed most vividly in works such as Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe and Plum Bun by Jessie Redmon Fauset — these sentimental techniques reach a larger audience on a more visceral level than the harder-to-identify-with, more distanced literary devices found in, for example, Nella Larsen's Passing. In the sentimental novels, unlike Passing, the ordinary reader — regardless of race or initial political persuasion — is able to enter the inner world of oppressed African-American characters and identify with those who suffer, rather than viewing them with the detached objectivity encouraged by Larsen's modernism.
Works Cited
Fauset, Jessie Redmon. Plum Bun. Boston: Beacon Press, 1999.
Larsen, Nella. Passing. New York: Anchor Books, 2001.
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom's Cabin. 1852.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.